Who’s The Top Gun in the Defense Industry?
Each of the major defense contractors thinks it is better than its competitors. It’s a point of pride. Moreover, it’s endemic to the corporate culture of each company. But from an outsider’s (hopefully) more objective point of view … which one is Top Gun?
This is important because each company seeks to woo analysts and investors. Each seeks to maximize the metrics perceived to be important to stock analysts. So when an outsider analyzes the companies and publishes the results, it’s worth taking a look at.
Over at Seeking Alpha, “Diesel” compared Raytheon, General Dynamics, Northrop Grumman, and Lockheed Martin to “find out which one provides the best value” to shareholders. Note that “Diesel” did not include Boeing in the comparison “because less than half of BA's revenues come from the defense industry.”
“Diesel” compared the four mega-defense contractors on ten metrics, including profit margins, Return on Equity (ROE), Debt/Equity Ratio, Price to Book Ratio, Current Dividend Yield, 5-Year Average Dividend Yield, Payout Ratio, 5-Year Dividend Growth, Price/Earnings Ratio, and 52-Week Stock Price Change.
One problem with “Diesel’s” analysis is that each metric had the same weight. In other words, in the analysis ROE is equal to 52-Week Price Change. In reality, some metrics are more important than others. Moreover, Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) was not included in the analysis; that’s an important metric to defense contractors.
But enough of the methodology, let’s get to the results. Of course, you can review “Diesel’s” article right here, if you want more detail.
-
Profit Margin—Winner: General Dynamics, with a profit margin of 8 percent.
-
ROE—Winner: Lockheed Martin, with a ROE of 80 percent, beating the competition by a wide margin.
-
Debt/Equity Ratio—Winner: General Dynamics, edging out Raytheon, and Northrop Grumman.
-
Price/Book Ratio—Winner: Northrop Grumman.
-
Dividend Yield—Winner: Lockheed Martin, with a current yield of roughly 4.75%.
-
5-Year Average Dividend Yield—Winner: Northrop Grumman.
-
Payout Ratio—Winner: General Dynamics, with a ratio of less than 25%.
-
5-Year Dividend Growth—Winner: Lockheed Martin had the most dividend growth over the past five years.
-
Price/Earnings Ratio—Winner: Raytheon and Northrop Grumman tied, with General Dynamics just behind the two.
- 52-Week Price Change—Winner: Lockheed Martin.
Overall Winner: Lockheed Martin
“Diesel” ends the analysis with the following statement—
Lockheed Martin is a strong buy with these fundamentals. This is good stock for long term (3-10 years) value investors. … In the last decade, there is a linear growth [in dividend yield] and the stock never paid less than the year before in dividends. During the same time, the stock's capital gain was about 64%.
The thing is, “Diesel” is so focused on the trees, he has no awareness of the forest. In addition to the methodological concerns we noted above, there is no discussion of the macro issues facing the industry. There is no mention of the looming near-term cuts to the defense budget, or of the ability to export aircraft and arms given the possibility of a European recession. In other words, “Diesel” is focused on historical metrics to the exclusion of obvious and near-term market issues facing the industry.
They say that “past performance is no guarantee of future returns” on most prospectuses. We agree. Caveat emptor.
The “Largest and Most Brazen” Government Contract Fraud?

In October, 2011, reports emerged from Alaska, such as this one, indicating that Alaskan Native Corporation (ANC) Eyak Technology LLC (EyakTech) was a participant in a “massive kickback scheme” involving “corrupt” officials in the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). Reports quoted the U.S. Attorney as stating it was “one of the most brazen corruption schemes in the history of federal contracting."
Prosecutors alleged that the USACE personnel accepted $20 million in bribes and kickbacks from EyakTech employees, and used the money “for BMW's, Rolex and Cartier watches, flat-screen televisions, first-class airplane tickets and international properties.” Reportedly—
… EyakTek subcontract[ed] work on its $1 billion federal contract to a Virginia firm that is identified in the indictment only as ‘Company A.’ Prosecutors allege the chief technology officer for ‘Company A’ would then submit fraudulently inflated invoices for the work.
One of the corrupt Army Corps of Engineers officials would approve the invoices, prosecutors say. The federal payment would go to EyakTek, which subtracted its profit margin and paid the rest to ‘Company A,’ according to the indictment.
The inflated invoices allegedly totaled about $20 million between 2007 and this year, according to the indictment. The chief technology officer of ‘Company A’ would allegedly funnel shares of the extra cash to Eyatek executive Babb and the Corps of Engineers officials who were part of the scheme.
Harold F. Babb (EyakTech Director of Contracts) was arrested, as was Michael Alexander and Kerry Khan—both employees of USACE. In addition, Khan’s son, Lee, was also arrested.
More recently, Mr. Alexander has reportedly agreed to plead guilty to his part in the scheme. The Washington Post (link in previous sentence) reported that Alexander “plans to plead guilty to charges of bribery and conspiracy to launder money.” According to the WaPo—
Prosecutors said that Alexander, a program director, and Kerry F. Khan, an Army Corps program manager, received kickbacks in exchange for directing government contracts to a subcontractor specializing in software encryption devices and other information assurance technology. … The scheme, which authorities said spanned roughly four years, involved phony and inflated invoices for government contracts and millions of dollars in kickbacks that were funneled through a network of shell companies in the United States and around the world. … The two Khans and Babb have pleaded not guilty. Two officials with an EyakTek subcontractor — Nova Datacom — have already pleaded guilty.
Recently we wrote about fraud at commercial headphone-maker Koss. We report on Koss from time to time in support of our assertion that fraud in the government contracting sector is no more prevalent than it is in the commercial sector. We report on corrupt government employees in the (perhaps futile) reminder that it often takes two to tango—and that too much focus on contractors without an equivalent focus on controls within the Federal government creates a gaping opportunity for corruption. Not all ANC companies are corrupt; not all USACE personnel are crooked. And not all contractors are out to gouge the government. But there are enough miscreants and fraudsters to make investments in internal controls and oversight worthwhile. This story, which has been under our radar screen for the past three or four months, reminds us that the wrongful actions of a few taint the rest of contractors and government employees—almost all of whom are focused on doing the right thing and spending taxpayer funds wisely.
|
ASBCA Throws-Out DCAA’s Methodology for Determining Allowable Executive Compensation!
On January 18, 2012, the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals (ASBCA) confirmed what many in the profession had long suspected—finding that DCAA’s methodology for evaluating the reasonableness (and allowability) of the compensation paid to executives was “fatally flawed statistically” and “therefore unreasonable”. Here’s the full decision, for your review. To summarize, J.F. Tayor, Inc. (JFT) is a privately held government contractor, who has been performing for the DOD for more than 20 years, to glowing CPARS reviews. DCAA’s “Mid-Atlantic Compensation Team” (MACT) reviewed the compensation paid to its executives during audits of the company’s incurred cost submissions for its Fiscal Years 2002 through 2005, and questioned a total of $849.000. DCAA recalculated JFT’s submitted rates based on its questioned costs, and the cognizant ACO used those rates to unilaterally determine JFT’s final indirect rates for the four years in question. The ACO demanded that JFT submit adjustment vouchers based on the unilaterally determined final indirect rates—and demanded refunds of the “overpayments” of roughly $620,000 made to the company via payment of its interim vouchers (of which about $29,000 was related to a contract not administered by DCMA). A dispute ensued. The government’s witnesses included the MACT Supervisory Auditor and Paul Dorf, Managing Director of Compensation Resources. Mr. Dorf did not fare well. We will not heap derision on the problems with his resume and his claimed P.hD. We will simply quote the Judge: “We give little or no weight to the testimony of Dorf.” JFT’s expert witness was Jimmy J. Jackson, who is an expert in statistics and quantitative analysis. Jackson found “numerous” “fundamental flaws” in DCAA’s methodology, which (in his expert opinion) rendered DCAA’s findings “significantly overstated and speculative.” Jackson found nine separate errors in DCAA’s methodology, including—
-
Ignored data dispersion/Use of arbitrary “range of reasonableness” allowance
-
Ignored differences in survey sizes
-
Inconsistent reliance on surveys
-
Inconsistent use of 50% percentile vs. mean
The government argued that DCAA’s methodology for determining reasonable compensation was “sufficiently valid to serve as the basis for the ACO’s decision”. Unfortunately for its case, the Judge wrote—
The government made no effort at the hearing or in its brief, to respond to [Jackson’s] statistical arguments … and thus we are left with unrebutted evidence that the methodology used by DCAA was fatally flawed statistically and therefore unreasonable. Moreover, the government effort to support its own methodology was supplanted by an expert witness of questionable judgment. Consequently, we conclude that there are statistical flaws in the government methodology for determining reasonable compensation and that the computations performed by Jackson to overcome these flaws are reasonable. … JFT has met its burden of showing its executive compensation costs were reasonable, except for [roughly $42,000].
While the government may still appeal this decision, in the meantime it’s a great victory for a relatively small company who took on DCAA and won. Contractors facing significant compensation disallowances are advised to scrutinize this case closely, and evaluate whether the flaws found by Jimmy Jackson are present in their individual disputes. JFT was represented by the well-respected firm of Wiley Rein. Here’s a link to a summary of the case from the Wiley Rein attorneys who handled the case.
Update on Fraud at Headphone-maker Koss

We’ve been following the stories of fraud and embezzlement at commercial headphone-maker Koss for quite some time. We first wrote about it here, in support of our thesis that instances of fraud within the government contracting community are no more prevalent than they are in the commercial sector (or in the government-employee sector for that matter). More than two years ago, we wrote—
On December 24, 2009 reports emerged that Koss Corporation fired its long-time VP of Finance and Corporate Secretary, for allegedly embezzling millions from the company. The individual in question (Ms. Sujata ‘Sue’ Sachdeva), was ‘suspended’ on December 21st, ‘for financial improprieties,’ and was fired on December 24th for embezzling as much as $31 million over the past 18 years. Two members of the Koss accounting staff who reported to Ms. Sachdeva were also put on unpaid administrative leave. According to the Wall Street Journal, ‘The government alleges she embezzled company funds to pay off her personal American Express credit-card charges for the purchases of furs, jewelry, apparel and home decor.’
Importantly, Ms. Sachdeva, as VP of Finance, was responsible for many ‘management representations’ provided to its external auditors, Grant Thornton. Because those representations can no longer be relied upon, Koss’ financial statements must be reaudited, and will likely need to be restated. Koss is a publicly traded company, so the SEC and PCAOB will also be involved in the resolution. But Grant Thornton won’t be involved in that resolution, because that audit entity was dismissed after the fraud was uncovered.
Quite a lot has happened in the past two years. In July, 2010, we wrote that—
On July 17, 2010, Ms. Sachdeva pleaded guilty to six counts of wire fraud for embezzling roughly $34 million from her employer over a period of approximately 11 years. … S-Squared admitted that, ‘During the 12-year span she authorized the issuance of more than 500 cashier's checks costing Koss about $17.5 million. That figure includes $10 million to American Express, plus payments to high-end retailers, including Neiman Marcus and Saks Fifth Avenue. Payments also went to charitable groups.’ In addition, ‘From February 2008 to December 2009, she authorized 206 wire transfers totaling $16 million from Koss accounts to American Express to cover items she bought with the credit card.’ The plea agreement stated that Koss employees worked ‘in concert with Sachdeva or at her direction’ to make fraudulent entries to the company's books to conceal the embezzlement. ‘These entries would falsely overstate assets, understate liabilities, understate sales, overstate cost of sales, and overstate expenses,’ and the false entries ‘concealed the actual receipts and profitability of Koss,’ allowing the scheme to continue.
We further noted a couple of points raised by Francine McKenna on her blog regarding this family-owned and family-operated publicly traded company. We wrote—
Management oversight of the financial reporting process is severely limited by Mr. Koss Jr.’s lack of interest, aptitude, and appreciation for accounting and finance. Koss Jr., the CEO and son of the founder, held the titles of COO and CFO, also. Ms. Sachdeva, the Vice President of Finance and Corporate Secretary who is accused of the fraud, has been in the same job since 1992 and during one ten year period worked remotely from Houston!
Perhaps Ms. McKenna was prescient—or perhaps she’s just that smart—but Mr. Koss, Jr. has been in hot water with the SEC over his role (or lack of role) in the Koss fraud fiasco. Recently, Mr. Koss, Jr. and the company reached a settlement with the SEC.
In October, 2011, the SEC filed both a complaint and proposed settlement agreement with Michael J. Koss (former COO, and CFO, and currently CEO). The complaint alleged improprieties—
… based on Koss Corporation’s preparation of materially inaccurate financial statements, book and records, and lack of adequate internal controls from fiscal years 2005 through 2009. During this period, Sujata Sachdeva (“Sachdeva”), Koss’s former Principal Accounting Officer, Secretary, and Vice-President of Finance, and Julie Mulvaney (“Mulvaney”), Koss’s former Senior Accountant, engaged in a wide-ranging accounting fraud to cover up Sachdeva’s embezzlement of over $30 million from Koss.
Among other control failures, the SEC asserted the following—
-
Sachdeva and Mulvaney were able to hide the substantial embezzlements in Koss’s financial records in part because Koss and Michael J. Koss did not adequately maintain internal controls to reasonably assure the accuracy and reliability of financial reporting.
-
While Koss’s internal controls policy required Michael J. Koss to approve invoices of $5,000 or more for payment, its controls did not prevent Sachdeva and Mulvaney from processing large wire transfers and cashier’s checks outside of the accounts payable system to pay for Sachdeva’s personal purchases without seeking or obtaining Michael J. Koss’s approval.
-
As a result, Sachdeva, with Mulvaney’s assistance, was able both to initiate and authorize wire transfers of Koss’s funds to her personal creditors totaling approximately $16.3 million, and to order cashier’s checks payable to credit card companies and her designated payees totaling approximately $15.5 million.
-
Koss’s computerized accounting systems were almost 30 years old and access to the accounting systems could not be locked at the end of the month and there was no audit trail. Sachdeva and Mulvaney were thus able to make undetected post-closing changes to the books and bypass an internal control requiring Michael J. Koss to authorize those changes.
-
Many account reconciliations were either not prepared or were not maintained as part of Koss’s accounting records. To the extent that reconciliations were conducted, they were improperly performed by the same persons who initiated or recorded the transactions (i.e. Sachdeva or Mulvaney), enabling those persons to make modifications to the reconciliations to cover up fraudulent entries.
-
While Sachedeva provided Michael J. Koss with reporting certifications for his review, he did not conduct an adequate review of Koss’s accounting in connection with these certifications.
This is good stuff, because it tells us what went wrong at Koss. (Apparently, many things went wrong ….) Our readers should review their accounting policies, procedures, and controls in light of the SEC’s allegations, and see if they are similarly vulnerable to employee embezzlement.
This report stated: “The proposed settlement would enjoin the company and Mr. Koss from future violations and order Mr. Koss to reimburse Koss $242,419 in cash and 160,000 of options pursuant to Section 304 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (Mr. Koss had previously voluntarily reimbursed $208,895 in bonuses to Koss).” Both Koss the company and Koss the CEO consented to the SEC’s injunctive order without either admitting or denying the underlying allegations, as is commonly done is such matters. Unfortunately for all parties, the Judge in the case (Judge J. Randa) didn’t believe the proposed settlement was reasonable and thought it was overly vague. In December, 2011, Judge Randa directed the SEC to explain why its proposed settlement was “fair, reasonable, adequate, and in the public interest."
In January 2012, the SEC responded to the Judge. The FedSECLaw story (link above) reports the details of the SEC’s response. The story concludes with the following—
… Judge Randa is the latest Judge to question how the SEC does things, focusing on the language of the Judgment – language which is similar (if not identical) to the language which it has used for years. The SEC could satisfy Judge Randa by amending the language, but seems reluctant to do so (other than adding language from the consents, which is also similar, if not identical, to language used in other consents).
This story at CFO.com asserts that difficulties in drafting approved settlement agreements may lead to more litigation, stating—
Sachdeva and two other employees in the accounting department were fired long ago. The company restated its financials, dismissed its accounting firm, and changed several procedures in the finance department, including doing away with petty cash. Koss Corp. also hired a new CFO and has pledged to keep the CEO and CFO roles separate.
SEC chairman Mary Schapiro has acknowledged the frustration judges and the public have expressed about the regulator’s settlements. More cases could end up in litigation, consuming the regulator’s time, if agreements are more difficult to reach. Last year the commission made 682 settlements, virtually the same number as 2010, according to a NERA Economic Consulting study released earlier this week.
From our point of view, the fundamental story here concerns the consequences of weak internal controls and oversight failures, and of trusted employees who took the advantage of the opportunities with which they were presented to steal a huge amount of money. We are not particularly concerned with whether or not corporate attorneys and their external counsel can negotiate quick and relatively inexpensive settlements with the SEC. Koss is a commercial company, but don’t think that your company is exempt from the litany of failures recited by the SEC. What happened to Koss can happen to any company, when management focuses attention on irrelevant or extraneous aspects of the business, instead of focusing on taking care of business.
|