The Hypocrisy of DCAA
 We have another U.S. Court of Federal Claims decision to discuss today. But before we do so, you need some background.
-
Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation has been enmeshed in complex litigation with the U.S. Government over an alleged noncompliance with Cost Accounting Standards (CAS 418), appealing the Government’s demand for roughly $80 million at the Court of Federal Claims. In December 2011, we told readers about the factual background of the case and expressed some layperson-type approval for Judge Lettow’s interpretation of the requirements found in CAS 418. Subsequently, Judge Lettow ruled against the Government’s argument that its claim was not time-barred by the Statute of Limitations found in the Contract Disputes Act of 1978 (as implemented in the Federal Acquisition Regulations). As we told readers, the Judge helpfully ruled that an agency’s administrative procedures—even those mandated by the FAR—do not act to delay accrual of a Governmental claim. The clock starts ticking when the Government knew—or should have known—that it had suffered an injury. Period. That’s not to say the Judge Lettow ruled for Sikorsky that the Government’s claim was time-barred; rather, the Judge simply ruled against the Government’s argument as to why it should not be time-barred, finding there were genuine issues of material fact that needed to be addressed in a trial.
-
The DCAA has recently issued audit guidance that (1) auditors are to report that a contractor is denying them access to records when the contractor asserted that any of its records were protected by attorney-client privilege, and (2) auditors are to obtain contractors’ internal audit reports (and, where helpful, the associated working papers), and to report that a contractor is denying them access to records if the contractor refuses to provide the requested information—even when the contractor asserts that that requested internal audit reports were generated under attorney-client privilege. We discussed the two pieces of audit guidance right here. Our concerns revolved around the fact that Courts have consistently denied DCAA access to contractors’ internal audit reports—whether or not they were prepared under attorney-client privilege. DCAA seems to be ignoring legal precedent in its quest for contractor information. Attorney Karen Manos’ excellent article on the topic can be found over here. Further, we were concerned about DCAA’s attack on the time-honored concept of attorney-client privilege. As Ms. Manos noted (and as we subsequently wrote about), disclosing attorney-client privileged documents to DCAA may well result in a broad waiver of that privilege, to the detriment of the contractor. So it’s kind of a big deal and every contractor’s counsel should be in the process of drafting policy positions regarding what information will and will not be released to DCAA.
With that background in mind, let’s now look at Judge Lettow’s September 13, 2012 decision in the continuing Sikorsky CAS 418 litigation, in which he ruled on a motion by the Government to strike e-mails between DCAA auditors (used by Sikorsky as evidence in its arguments that the Government’s claim was time-barred by the CDA Statute of Limitations), because those e-mails were subject to the “deliberative process privilege.”
Yeah, you read that right. The Government asserted that e-mails between DCAA auditors were subject to privilege and should not be disclosed to the contractor, even though the contractor is using those e-mails in its appeal of a Government claim for some $80 million dollars.
On one hand the DCAA is mounting a concerted attack on attorney-client privilege and may well be recommending that contractors’ costs be suspended if the contractor refuses to provide protected documents—and this is with respect to an ongoing audit where no wrong-doing has been alleged. But on the other hand, DCAA has declared that its own internal communications (where no attorney was present) are privileged and should not be provided even in the midst of on-going litigation, where the contractor might use those communications to its advantage.
The hypocrisy burns, doesn’t it?
Judge Lettow explained the situation thusly—
Germane to Sikorsky’s statute of limitations defense is the string of e-mails (identified as ‘Exhibit P,’ …) at the nexus of the current dispute. Exhibit P comprises exchanged e-mail messages between Mr. Robert Boyer, an auditor, and Ms. Janice Berardi, his superior at the Defense Contract Auditing Agency (‘DCAA’), regarding audits of Sikorsky. The exhibit has an extensive history in this litigation. It was originally produced to Sikorsky by the government on February 17, 2011, more than eighteen months ago, as part of an unremarkable (and unremarked) set of discovery responses. … Five months later, on July 20, 2011, Sikorsky deposed Mr. Boyer and questioned him about Exhibit P, without any contemporaneous objections from the government. … At the end of Mr. Boyer’s deposition, however, counsel for the government stated, ‘[i]t’s come to my attention that [Exhibit P] may be the subject of deliberative process privilege, because it . . . refers to an ongoing DCAA audit. So I would like to request that [Exhibit P] and the deposition transcript be sealed for now, until this deliberative process issue can be determined.’ … Sikorsky agreed to the government’s request. ….
Sikorsky’s counsel spent the next six months trying to get the Government to determine whether it would or would not be asserting “deliberative process privilege” over the Exhibit P e-mails, to no avail. Meanwhile, DCAA was wrestling internally with establishing procedures regarding when and how the deliberative process privilege would be asserted. Finally, on December 19, 2011, DCAA Director Pat Fitzgerald “officially delegated the authority to assert the deliberative process privilege to certain subordinates. … A month later, on January 19, 2012, DCAA Regional Director Ronald C. Meldonian asserted the deliberative process privilege over, among other documents, Exhibit P.”
Let’s digress here and delve into the concept of “deliberative process privilege,” courtesy of Judge Lettow. He wrote—
The deliberative process privilege protects ‘documents reflecting advisory opinions, recommendations and deliberations comprising part of a process by which governmental decisions and policies are formulated.’ … The deliberative process privilege asserted here is one of the several branches of ‘executive privilege.’ Those branches relate to a range of executive functions and actions and may be considered as having a hierarchical ranking in importance. The strongest branch of executive privilege consists of what may be termed the ‘Presidential privilege,’ which rests in large part on the constitutional separation of powers, affords the President of the United States considerable autonomy and confidentiality, and gives ‘recognition to the paramount necessity of protecting the Executive Branch from vexatious litigation that might distract it from the energetic performance of its constitutional duties.’ … Still another branch of the executive privilege consists of the ‘state secrets’ or ‘national security’ privilege, which protects from disclosure the executive branch’s military, diplomatic, and foreign policy secrets. … Other aspects of executive privilege include a quasi-judicial privilege that protects the mental processes of executive officials when acting in a judicial capacity… the informer’s privilege, which protects the identity of criminal informants … and the law enforcement investigatory privilege, which protects information produced pursuant to investigations of potential violations of the law. … The deliberative process privilege ‘was created to encourage ‘open, frank discussion between subordinate and chief concerning administrative action,’ and to ‘prevent injury to the quality of agency decisions.’’ … The privilege is a creation of federal common law and thus is recognized under Fed. R. Evid. 501. … The privilege is delineated by several procedural and substantive requirements. Procedurally, the privilege can only be invoked by an agency head or his or her subordinate after careful, personal review … and that head or designee must identify the specific information that is subject to the privilege and provide reasons for maintaining the confidentiality of the pertinent record … Substantively, the government must demonstrate that the allegedly privileged material is both pre-decisional and deliberative. Material is pre-decisional if it addresses activities ‘antecedent to the adoption of an agency policy.’ … ‘Subjective documents which reflect the personal opinion of the writer, rather than the policy of the agency are considered privileged information because they are predecisional.’ … Material is deliberative if it addresses ‘a direct part of the deliberative process in that it makes recommendations or expresses opinions on legal or policy matters.’ … Thus, the privilege does not protect purely factual material, ‘except as necessary to avoid indirect revelation of the decision making process.’ ….
In a footnote, Judge Lettow reported that the notion of deliberative process privilege can be traced back to the Eisenhower Administration. In other words, it is the creation modern jurisprudence and has no roots in English Common Law. (Let’s note here that we are not attorneys and we are deducing the lack of pedigree solely from Judge Lettow’s decision.)
The Judge spent several pages describing the tests for deliberative process privilege and discussing whether or not the DCAA e-mails met those tests. For example, he wrote—
… Exhibit P consists of communications between two government employees about DCAA audits that were ongoing at the time. In particular, the e-mail chain focuses on the subjective thoughts of a DCAA auditor, Mr. Boyer, regarding the status of the audits. Mr. Boyer uses his opinion of a past event, Sikorsky’s alleged violation of CAS 418 some years earlier, to convey to his superior his opinion about what action the DCAA should take in the ongoing audits. In short, Mr. Boyer’s impressions regarding the events surrounding the prior CAS 418 compliance issue are pre-decisional because the recounting of the past occurrence is subjective and was recited specifically to influence DCAA’s handling of an ongoing audits [sic]. In the same vein, the entirety of Exhibit P also is deliberative. In the commentary to his superior, Mr. Boyer recommends that the agency change course before it issues final audits. … Disclosure of government employees’ correspondence — and a candid assessment of an agency’s ongoing policy-making activities — could lessen employees’ willingness to have a full and frank discussion about the merits of ongoing audits, thereby sapping the process of robust debate and collaborative analysis among audit team members. Overall, because Sikorsky has not demonstrated that its interest in Exhibit P outweighs the government’s interest in preserving the confidentiality of the document, the balance of interests favors the government, and Exhibit P is protected under the deliberative process privilege.
[Emphasis in original.]
Even though Judge Lettow found that the DCAA internal correspondence was protected by the deliberative process privilege, that wasn’t the end of the story. The Judge had to decide whether or not the Government had waived its claim of privilege when it delayed asserting it. The Judge wrote—
Applying the three-part test in Fed. R. Evid. 502(b), the court must determine whether the government’s disclosure of Exhibit P was inadvertent, whether the government took reasonable steps to prevent its disclosure, and whether the government promptly took reasonable steps to rectify the error.
Ultimately, Judge Lettow ruled that “the government did not act with sufficient alacrity to claw back the records produced in this case,” and thus had waived its ability to assert privilege with respect to Exhibit P. He wrote—
… Mr. Boyer’s deposition took place on July 20, 2011, yet the government waited until January 19, 2012, roughly six months later, to assert the deliberative process privilege over Exhibit P. Thereafter, inexplicably and inexcusably, the government waited until May 14, 2012, nearly four months after its assertion of privilege and two-and-one-half months after Sikorsky had used Exhibit P in a brief, to communicate its assertion of privilege to Sikorsky. In total, the government waited almost ten months, from July 20, 2011 until May 14, 2012, to convey its assertion of privilege over Exhibit P. By any measure, that is simply too long a time to try now to resuscitate the privilege. Its spirit has long since entered the Elysian Fields of the public domain.
At the end of the day, Sikorsky won its argument that the DCAA auditors’ e-mail correspondence was not subject to privilege and should be admissible. On the other hand, the fact that the Court of Federal Claims has blessed DCAA’s ability to assert deliberative process privilege over its internal communications may be a blow to those who are seeking to litigate DCAA-related issues.
We think it’s a shame that DCAA would seek to overturn contractor’s ability to rely on privilege while at the same time asserting privilege with respect to its own documents. That seems like the rankest kind of hypocrisy. We think DCAA should be ashamed of itself.
“Don’t Do the Crime, If You Can’t Do the Time”
 In early January, 2012, military leaders at Joint Base Lewis-McCord (JBLM), which is located near Tacoma, Washington, conducted a “routine inventory” and noticed that certain “sensitive” military hardware was missing—and they determined that the hardware had been stolen. The missing equipment included “laser-targeting gun sights, night-vision goggles, and weapons scopes with a ‘high-dollar value’ in the ‘six-figure range,’ according to the JBLM spokesperson quoted by Reuters in the article. Leaders at JBLM confined roughly 100 soldiers of the 4th Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division to their barracks in a “lockdown,” to facilitate the investigation into the stolen equipment. The 4th Brigade was one of JBML’s three combat Stryker brigades, and had been deployed to Iraq twice. Currently, the brigade is preparing for a near-term deployment to Afghanistan. The Reuters article reported—
A lockdown means the soldiers are confined to barracks and office areas of the unit, so the troops are not permitted to go home if they have families residing outside the barracks, the Army said. On Saturday, the restrictions were loosened to allow soldiers' families to visit them in confinement, [the JBLM spokesperson] said. A criminal investigation has been launched, and a $10,000 reward offered.
As the lockdown continued for six days, further details emerged. Apparently, the hardware had been accounted-for in the December 2011 inventory—and it appeared that the optics had been stolen over the Christmas holidays, when the majority of soldiers were off-base. Meanwhile some of the enlisted soldiers accused their officers of “incompetence” and asserted that the entire brigade was being punished for the negligence of a few officers. That assertion turned out not to be entirely correct. In February the Army charged 22 year-old Private Nicholas Solt with the theft of “$630,000” worth of equipment for the purpose of resale. The NewsTrib reported---
Solt faces 59 years in prison if he’s convicted on six charges including larceny of military property, entering a government building with the intent to commit a crime, attempting to sell optical and targeting equipment, threatening to kill another person, possessing narcotics and possessing steroids. The Army says it recovered 98 percent of the gear Solt allegedly stole by collaborating with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
Eventually, the Army prosecuted two other enlisted soldiers for the theft, and they have been convicted, according to this recent story at The NewsTrib. The article reported—
Spc. Joshua Chandler, 21, was convicted July 11 of larceny of government property and conspiracy to commit larceny. He was sentenced to 10 years in prison, forfeiture of all pay and reduction in rank to private and was dishonorably discharged. Spc. David Green also pleaded guilty to charges of larceny and conspiracy to commit larceny. He was sentenced to one month of confinement and a reduction in rank to private and received a bad-conduct discharge.
Solt’s case is still pending. A court-martial date was not reported. In previous blog articles we have criticized military leaders for failures in internal control. We have also criticized what we saw as overly light sentences meted-out to those who betrayed their uniforms. In this story, however, we are pleased to applaud the military leaders of JBLM who took quick, decisive, action to investigate the missing equipment and who quickly identified the (alleged) culprits for prosecution. And we are pleased to see lengthy sentences for those found guilty. We are very sorry that these young men, who served their country in a time of war and who risked their lives to accomplish the nation’s national security objectives, made very poor choices that led to their lives being ruined. But we think such examples need to be made, when those who wear their country’s uniforms ignore their duty and betray the trust placed in them. Soldiers considering similar misdeeds in the future may think twice if they know the downside of getting caught.
|
Reverse Auctions
 In a reverse auction, the traditional roles of buyer and seller are reversed. The sellers compete to obtain business by offering progressively lower prices. Wikipedia notes:
A reverse auction is different in that a single buyer offers a contract out for bidding (by either using specialized software or through an online marketplace). Multiple sellers are then able to offer bids on the contract. As the auction progresses, the price decreases as sellers compete to offer lower bids than their competitors whilst still meeting all of the specifications of the original contract. As the buyer is able to see all of the sellers’ offers, and to choose any of them, a reverse auction is not a true auction.
Wikipedia also offers this synopsis of the Government’s use of reverse auctions to acquire goods and services—
In 2004, the White House Office of Federal Procurement Policy (OFPP) issued a memorandum encouraging increased use of commercially available online procurement tools, including reverse auctions. In 2005, both the Government Accountability Office and Court of Federal Claims upheld the legality of Federal agency use of online reverse auctions. In 2008, OFPP issued a governmentwide memorandum encouraging agencies to improve and increase competitive procurement and included specific examples of competition best practices, including reverse auctions. In 2010, The White House Office of Management and Budget cited ‘continued implementation of innovative procurement methods, such as the use of web-based electronic reverse auctions’ as one of the contracting reforms helping agencies meet acquisition savings goals
More recently, the Defense Logistics Agency announced that reverse auctions would henceforth become mandatory for all negotiated, competitive, procurements valued in excess of $150,000. The DLA announcement reported—
The agency has saved more than $34 million through reverse auctions since fiscal 2010, when contracting officers began tracking savings from reverse auctions. Most of the savings stems from about 400 auctions held so far in fiscal 2012, said Charles Howerton, a procurement and systems analyst for the DLA Acquisition Programs and Industrial Capabilities Division. … Reverse auctions were designed specifically to increase competition and reduce government costs, Howerton said, adding that contractors who say the tool diminishes profits are wrong. Rather, it forces contractors to be more efficient and offer items and services at the best possible price. ‘Reverse auctions provide incentive for suppliers who are able to restructure their internal operating procedures and costs,’ he said. It can help them make their operations more efficient and cost effective. It’s a win-win.’ Enabling contractors to see the amount others are bidding often leads to tough decisions on the contractor’s end, Howerton continued. For example, a contractor that’s been doing business with DLA for several years and sees another contractor bidding for the same business at a lower cost will have to reconsider everything from production processes to prices. ‘That contractor will have to ask, ‘Can I make money selling my product at the same price as the lowest bidder or not?’ If they’re thinking long-term and strategically, they’ll make the best choice to get their internal operations as efficient as possible if it means keeping their business,’ he said.
The problem with reverse auctions is that they lack full transparency. The sellers know that somebody is underbidding their proposed price, but not necessarily who is doing so. This situation creates the opportunity for “phantom bids” – i.e., bids submitted by Federal buyers whose sole intent it to generate “savings” for their agency by forcing the prices lower and lower.
How likely is the possibility of Government-submitted phantom bids? It’s difficult to determine because the goal of such behavior is not to be the winning bidder but, instead, to be the next higher bidder. That way their name won’t be disclosed and nobody will know that the price was driven down by fraudulent bids. (The bids are fraudulent, of course, because the Government bidder has no intention of fulfilling the order. Indeed, the Government bidder cannot fulfill the order.)
We are relatively confident that this situation has happened at least once. Writing on the WIFCON blog, “Don Acquisition” reported—
… Although [a contractor] submitted several bids, he ultimately lost the reverse auction. When he checked to see who had won, he was surprised to see that the federal agency that was in need of the required items was the low bidder. In other words, the federal agency was submitting bogus bids in an effort to get the contractor to reduce his bid price. The federal agency then contacted him and offered to purchase the items from the contractor at his lowest bid price. Feeling that he had been duped, he told them to get lost. The tactic employed by the federal agency, called phantom bidding, is not new. Many view the practice as unethical while others see it as a legitimate tactic. In regular auctions, the legality of seller participation in bidding varies from state to state. For those states that allow it, sellers typically must disclose that they reserve the right to participate in the bidding.
“Don Acquisition” also quoted the defrauded contractor as follows—
In this particular case, whenever we resubmitted the bid, we were shown to be in the lead for a short period of time, then lagged again, so ‘Someone’ was entering a bid in response to our reduction. At the conclusion of bidding, we found out there were no other (genuine) bidders.
This is a good time to remind readers of the Executive Branch requirement that the Federal Acquisition System will “conduct business with integrity, fairness, and openness.”
To conclude, we have a couple of thoughts about DLA’s decision to mandate use of on-line reverse auctions for competitive, negotiated, procurements valued at $150,000 or more. First, since the rationale for that decision is to continue to generate reported savings from use of that approach, we hope that the DLA has made sure the reported savings amounts weren’t increased by use of fraudulent bids. Second, we are concerned about use of reverse auctions for more complex items and services (i.e., those valued in excess of $150,000) because using price as the sole criterion skips over such key evaluation criteria as past performance and technical quality. Third, as DLA moves out on this initiative we sincerely hope agency leadership issues policy guidance to buyers, prohibiting them from employing such nefarious tactics as submitting fraudulent “phantom bids” with the sole purpose of driving down the price, and generating savings that will look nice on monthly and quarterly reports.
For-Profit Education and the False Claims Act
 The United States government has intervened in a qui tam suit brought under the False Claims Act against ATI Enterprises, Inc. (which does business as ATI Technical Training Center, ATI Career Training Center and ATI Career Training) and which “operates career college campuses in Texas, Florida, Oklahoma and New Mexico,” according to this announcement by the Department of Justice.
The complaint against ATI alleged that—
ATI Enterprises knowingly misrepresented its job placement statistics to the Texas Workforce Commission in order to maintain its state licensure, and therefore its eligibility for federal financial aid under Title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965, as amended. On Aug. 9, 2011, the Texas Workforce Commission revoked licenses for several of ATI’s programs at the three campuses after a third party audit of ATI’s reported placement statistics.
The DOJ press release provided some more details. It reported—
… ATI employees at the three campuses knowingly enrolled students who were ineligible because they did not have high school diplomas or recognized equivalents; falsified high school diplomas, including five Dallas Independent School District diplomas for students who later defaulted on their federal student loans; fraudulently kept students enrolled even though they should have been dropped because they had poor grades or attendance; and made knowing misrepresentations to students about their future employability. [Allegedly.] The alleged misrepresentations included telling students that a criminal record would not prevent them from getting jobs in their fields of study, quoting higher salaries than the students would be likely to earn and reporting inflated job placement statistics both to the students and the Texas Workforce Commission. The complaint alleges that the executive directors at each campus, as well as various ATI corporate officers, including the chief operating officer, chief executive officer, executive vice president of operations, national director of career services, regional director of education, regional director of career placements and vice president of recruitment were aware of and in some cases encouraged the alleged conduct. The complaint further alleges that ATI engaged in these practices in order to induce students to enroll and thereby increase the school’s receipt of federal dollars at the expense of students, who incurred long-term debt, and the taxpayers.
This is not the first time that DOJ has initiated a False Claims Act suit against a for-profit educational entity. For instance, in December, 2009, the DOJ announced that the University of Phoenix had settled a False Claims Act suit for $67.5 million. In that qui tam action, two former University of Phoenix employees alleged that “the university accepted federal student financial aid while in violation of statutory and regulatory provisions prohibiting post-secondary schools from paying admissions counselors certain forms of incentive-based compensation tied to the number of students recruited.” Notably, the U.S. Government did not intervene in that suit, yet the two whistleblowers ended-up splitting some $19 million (before attorney fees).
This Crowell & Moring list of FCA settlements indicates that ATI and the University of Phoenix are not alone in feeling the wrath of the Federal government in the past decade. We saw the Oakland City University. Westwood College, Alta Colleges, Grand Canyon Education, and the Maine Department of Education all listed as making settlements pursuant to the FCA. Another company, Nelnet, Inc., settled a case for $57.5 million.
Our point is this: while Health Care fraud and Procurement-related fraud certainly comprise the largest pieces of the FCA settlement pie, settlements related to for-profit and other educational institutions are far from unknown.
|