• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

DFARS Regulatory Revisions

E-mail Print PDF

Recently I took an opportunity to criticize the do-very-little CAS Board for doing so very little to implement Congressional direction (issued via public law) to do something. The CAS Board, of course, is not the only regulatory rule-making body to suffer from inertia, though it is a very prominent one.

In the September, 2020, issue of The Nash & Cibinic Report, George Washington School of Law Professor Emeritus, and the man credited for founding the academic discipline of government contracts law (along with the late John Cibinic), felt compelled to write about the current rule-making environment in comparison to the one under the pre-FAR/DFARS Armed Services Procurement Regulation (ASPR) system. Professor Nash wrote—

The members of the ASPR Committee were senior officials in their services—reflecting the idea that procurement regulations deserved the attention of highly competent and experienced people. Devoting significant amounts of such people’s time to the process yielded a far better regulation than the Federal Acquisition Regulation.

It is sad to compare the current system to that one. Today regulations wend their way through the process at a snail’s pace with many of them having to undergo significant alterations after the comments on a proposed regulation are received. Some linger in the system for years before they are abandoned (like the rewrite to the organizational conflict of interest regulation in FAR Subpart 9.5). In this part of the Government procurement process we have regressed rather than improved.

So look, it’s not just Apogee Consulting, Inc. It’s pretty much everybody, from consultants to contracting officers to the most esteemed legal minds. We are all saying that the system is broken, and one of the main areas in which it’s broken is in the regulatory rule-making process.

Nonetheless, from time to time some rule-making does escape from the clutches of the bureaucrats and gets issued. Sometimes we get CASB Staff Discussion Papers; other times we get FAR or DFARS proposed rules. Infrequently, we get final rules. (Often months if not years after the underlying statutes were revised.)

Recently, the Defense Federal Regulation Supplement (DFARS) were revised by issuance of seven final rules and one proposed rule. Among the seven final rules, two of them eliminated something. The remaining five rules implemented something.

We’re not going to discuss all five. But here are a couple of important ones for your information.

  1. DFARS Case 2019-D041 (Assessing Contractor Implementation of Cybersecurity Requirements) was issued as an interim rule. This means that the rule goes into effect without the benefit of public comments; however, the public may submit comments and the interim rule may be altered as a result. (See Professor Nash’s thoughts on that aspect of the rule-making process in his quote above.) The interim rule implements the new Cyber-Security Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) and assessment approach. As most defense contractors know by now, DOD is going to be looking for CMMC assessments and certifications. This is not new news; however, the interesting aspect is that the clauses are being implemented in solicitations and contracts before the CMMC Accreditation Board knows how it is going to assess contractors.

  2. DFARS Case 2019-D036 (Inflation Adjustment of Acquisition-Related Thresholds) was implemented as a final rule. As the title indicates, certain thresholds were increased to account for inflation. Follow the link if you want to know which ones were increased.

  3. DFARS Case 2019-D029 (Treatment of Certain Items as Commercial Items) was issued as a final rule. The final rule implements several public law revisions from the 2017 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). The 2017 NDAA was signed into law in December, 2016. Yes, that was four years ago. (Talk about a “snail’s pace”….) Anyway, this one is important because it (a) permits certain items valued at less than $10,000 to be treated as commercial items if purchased to inventory destined for multiple contracts, and (b) permits both goods and services acquired from non-traditional defense contractors (as that term is defined in DFARS) to be treated as commercial items. There is also something in the background that says “provide that a contract for an item using FAR part 12 procedures shall serve as a prior commercial item determination, unless the appropriate official determines in writing that the use of such procedures was improper or that it is no longer appropriate to acquire the item using commercial item acquisition procedures” but we could not see where the DFARS was revised to implement that Congressional direction, so we’re not claiming that’s what the DFARS now says.

As does Professor Nash, we lament the current Federal acquisition rule-making system; however, when some change does slip out, we try to bring it to our readers’ attention. So here you go.

 

New CASB Staff Discussion Paper Asks Questions for Future Actions

E-mail Print PDF

In a shocking display of activity, the CAS Board recently published a new Staff Discussion Paper (SDP) addressing possible revisions to Standards 404 and 411. As has been the recent trend, CASB published the news on the Federal Register but forgot to actually, you know, publish the SDP. But a link to the SDP was included! The link took one to the OMB site on whitehouse.gov, where it turned out the SDP hadn’t actually been uploaded yet.

Yes, you read that correctly. The Federal Register notice contained a link that took you nowhere.

Nice.

But a couple of days later, the SDP appeared. Yay!

Now you might think a complaint about a couple of days of missing SDP is just nitpickery. But remember, there is only a 60-day comment period available. Even a loss of two or three days can be enough to impact the public’s ability to comment. Therefore, in our view it’s not nitpickery; it’s a legitimate complaint that the CASB’s decision to publish the SDP outside of the Federal Register is a decision to undermine the public’s right to provide comment. This is especially important when the entire purpose of the SDP is to solicit public input.

Indeed, after literally six months of no apparent CASB activity, the SDP promised by the previous (March 13, 2020) SDP finally showed up. Just in time for the CASB to claim credit for doing something in GFY 2020.

But the new SDP actually doesn’t do anything. It just asks questions about Cost Accounting Standards 404 and 411. The questions are seemingly intended to provide input to the CAS Board about whether GAAP is sufficient (standing alone) to protect the government’s contractor cost accounting interests, or whether the rigors of CAS are necessary. Remember, Congress already directed CASB to conform GAAP with CAS—it’s a public law requirement—but apparently the CASB wants to be really sure that Congress actually meant what it put into the law.

In fairness, the SDP is a required step in the CASB rule-making process. You know, the one required by yet another public law. Apparently, CASB is very focused on complying with that particular public law, even as it delays complying with the more current one.

This second SDP asks questions. If you are a CAS-covered contractor, or think you may become one someday, you should read the questions and respond. Your input is being solicited.

Be advised, however, that if recent history is any predictor of future history, it will be a long time before CASB actually does anything with your input. You need to know that going in. CASB rule-making is moving at the speed of molasses. Molasses being poured at the North Pole.

One reason the Board may be moving so slowly is that the industry representative has been missing in action since Ms. Schmidgall (Boeing) departed after expiration of her term. From what we’ve been able to gather, there has been absolutely no forward progress made in choosing her replacement. Again, this seems to be the new normal for the CAS Board. Indeed, many observers credit Ms. Schmidgall for most of the recent CASB activity; it’s of little surprise to see CASB stalled after her departure.

Anyway, CAS 404 and 411 Staff Discussion Paper. Asking questions. Which may lead to another SDP or perhaps to an Advance Notice of Rule-Making (ANPRM). Or not.

Depends on whether CASB feels like doing anything next year.

 

Another Timekeeping Issue

E-mail Print PDF

“Charge what you work; work what you charge.”

If you follow that simple piece of government contracting folk wisdom, it’s tough to get into too much trouble.

Still, too many contractors end up the subject of Department of Justice press releases, announcing multi-million-dollar settlements related to timekeeping “challenges” and related issues.

Recently, the DCAA published a notice of SAIC’s nearly $6 million settlement with DoJ. That published report was a bit of “old news,” as the DoJ published its settlement announcement in June, roughly three months ago. What was the deal?

According to the DoJ announcement—

The United States contended that SAIC employees misused administrative leave by working on contract requirements for a certain project before funding was available and then later clearing those charges by adding extra billing hours that were not worked to a separate project. The United States also contended that SAIC employees were provided charge codes for their hours to be recorded to projects with available funding, while they continued to work on tasks that were not funded. Once the new funding arrived, the employees working on a project that provided the original funding would then charge their hours to the new project.

People who know SAIC and its commitment to internal controls were a bit shocked at the news. There was a decent discussion thread on LinkedIn by those who wondered what went wrong. SAIC, of course, used to be headquartered in San Diego, but now calls Reston, Virginia, home.

More recently, another San Diego entity settled with the DoJ for its own timekeeping “challenges.” According to this DoJ press release, The Scripps Research Institute (TSRI), located in LaJolla, California, agreed to settle false claims allegations by paying $10 million. According to the announcement—

The settlement resolves allegations that between 2008 and 2016, TSRI failed to have a system in place for its faculty to properly account for time spent on activities that cannot be charged directly to NIH-funded projects or are unrelated to the research activities of the NIH-funded project. Consequently, the U.S. contended that TSRI improperly charged time spent by faculty on developing, preparing, and writing new grant applications directly to existing NIH-funded projects, rather than allocating such charges as indirect costs. The U.S. also alleged that TSRI improperly charged NIH-funded projects for time spent by its faculty on other activities unrelated to the funded projects, such as teaching, TSRI committee work, and other administrative tasks.

Let’s unpack paragraph a little bit.

The government alleged that TSRI permitted its faculty to charge non-project efforts to NIH-funded projects. Those non-project efforts included:

  • Efforts to prepare new grant applications (equivalent to Bid & Proposal efforts)

  • Time spent teaching classes

  • Time spent attending committee meetings

  • Time spent on other (non-project) administrative tasks

If the allegations were true, then TSRI had challenges in helping its faculty determine the difference between “direct” and “indirect” time. Direct time, of course, is the time spent on project activities; whereas, indirect time is the time spent on everything else that is not a project activity.

Title 2 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Chapter 200, discusses the cost principles applicable to educational institutions such as TSRI. 2 CFR § 200.413 (Direct costs) states—

Direct costs are those costs that can be identified specifically with a particular final cost objective, such as a Federal award, or other internally or externally funded activity, or that can be directly assigned to such activities relatively easily with a high degree of accuracy. … Identification with the Federal award rather than the nature of the goods and services involved is the determining factor in distinguishing direct from indirect (F&A) costs of Federal awards.

Obviously, TSRI had challenges in complying with the requirements/guidance quoted above. One would think a contractor (or grant recipient) would have the whole direct versus indirect thing figured out before submitting the first proposal. Moreover, it would appear that timekeeping training was lacking as well. Faculty should have received training in how to distinguish direct from indirect labor. If they had questions, TSRI should have provided a help line for them to call.

Now, perhaps TSRI did all that. We don’t know.

But what we do know is that TSRI, a non-for-profit educational institution, just paid out $10 million to resolve allegations related to its timekeeping “challenges.”

One more thing: As with so many other DoJ settlements, this one started with a qui tam suit filed by a former employee. The DoJ press release notes that the qui tam relator will receive $1.75 million (17.5%) of the settlement. As we recently noted, there is evidence showing that contractors with active hotlines or emails see reduced legal settlements. We have also observed that companies with internal reporting mechanism offer their employees a means of reporting concerns or suspected wrongdoing without having to file a lawsuit.

The continuing reportage of legal settlements related to mischarging of labor makes us think that every government contractor should think about these things.

 

Too Much Time on Their Hands

E-mail Print PDF
We had hardly finished typing the last article on timekeeping “challenges” and associated legal settlements when we learned that our old friend, the Department of Energy’s Hanford Site, had generated yet another legal settlement. The DoJ press release reported that—

Bechtel National Inc., Bechtel Corporation (Bechtel), AECOM Energy & Construction, Inc. (AECOM), and their subsidiary Waste Treatment Completion Company, LLC (WTCC), agreed to pay $57,750,000 to the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) to resolve claims that Bechtel and AECOM fraudulently overcharged the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) in connection with its operation of the Hanford Waste Treatment Plant (WTP) project.

Yep, that was a nearly $58 million settlement.

The latest settlement is in addition to a 2016 settlement of $125 million, in which the DoJ reported—

Bechtel National Inc., Bechtel Corp., URS Corp. (predecessor in interest to AECOM Global II LLC) and URS Energy and Construction Inc. (now known as AECOM Energy and Construction Inc.) have agreed to pay $125 million to resolve allegations under the False Claims Act that they made false statements and claims to the Department of Energy (DOE) by charging DOE for deficient nuclear quality materials, services, and testing that was provided at the Waste Treatment Plant (WTP) at DOE’s Hanford Site near Richland, Washington. The settlement also resolves allegations that Bechtel National Inc. and Bechtel Corp. improperly used federal contract funds to pay for a comprehensive, multi-year lobbying campaign of Congress and other federal officials for continued funding at the WTP.

So $58 + $125 = $183 million in WTP-related legal settlements, and that figure excludes such additional costs as unallowable legal fees and the time and expense of internal resources being focused on non-value-added activities such as defending themselves. That’s obviously a lot of money, and where does it come from? It comes from the corporate shareholders, of course. And at the same time, the Bechtel team received $5 million in award fees associated with its 2019 performance—“the best performance evaluation in three years,” according to this news article. We suspect that big award fee payout didn't make up for the costs of the legal challenges.

Anyway, back to the current settlement. This one is a bit harder to understand; it’s not black and white as most timekeeping “challenges” are. In this case, the government alleged that “Bechtel and AECOM management were aware of and failed to prevent inflated labor hours being charged to DOE, and for falsely billing DOE for work not actually performed.” But when you dig a bit deeper, those “inflated labor hours” and the “work not actually performed” were related to craft employees’ “idle time.”

Idle time is time spent not working. Often, it’s for legitimate reasons, such as waiting for paint to dry or for a weld to cure. Maybe somebody is waiting for an inspector to show up before moving on to the next operation. Most construction contractors (including shipbuilders) have some amount of idle time. It’s a known and accepted thing. Obviously, from a schedule management perspective it should be minimized, but there is really no way to get it to zero.

In this case, the government alleged that—

Between 2009 and 2019, Bechtel and AECOM admitted to overcharging DOE for unreasonable and unallowable idle time experienced by craft personnel. Bechtel and AECOM further admitted to failing to schedule and carry out adequate work to keep craft personnel sufficiently occupied and productive, resulting in excessive idle time. Bechtel and AECOM also admitted that Bechtel and AECOM management knew that craft personnel were experiencing idle time due to management’s failure to assign sufficient work, and that this idle time could, at times, last ‘several hours.’ Finally, Bechtel and AECOM admitted that they improperly billed DOE labor costs for the unreasonable idle time and continued doing so for years, even after Bechtel and AECOM knew they were under investigation for the improper billing practices.

Based on the foregoing, we can see that the basis of the allegations was that the cost of idle time was “unreasonable.” Costs that are unreasonable are unallowable. The concept of “reasonableness” is discussed in the FAR at 31.201-3. It’s a bit long-winded and nuanced; but it has to be, because it’s inherently a subjective standard. Despite the subjective nature of the evaluation, the FAR states that “no presumption of reasonableness shall be attached to the incurrence of costs by a contractor. If an initial review of the facts results in a challenge of a specific cost by the contracting officer or the contracting officer’s representative, the burden of proof shall be upon the contractor to establish that such cost is reasonable.”

Thus, when challenged, the burden was on the Bechtel team to show why the incurrence (and amount) of idle time was reasonable and normal for the type of project. Apparently, the Bechtel team couldn’t make a case for the idle time or else couldn’t show that they were actively trying to minimize it. Because the team couldn’t meet their burden of proof, the “unreasonable” idle time costs became unallowable labor costs, and the team was then on the hook for having invoiced unallowable costs to DOE, which led to the allegations that the False Claims Act was violated.

A critical point was that (allegedly) the Bechtel WTP team was on notice that the DOE considered the idle time costs to be unreasonable and unallowable, but kept billing the idle time anyway. The DoJ announcement quoted the DOE Inspector General as saying “[the Bechtel team] engaged in a massive scheme to submit tens of millions of dollars of false claims to the U.S. Government for unallowable and unjustified costs over a period of years – a pattern of conduct that continued even after U.S. authorities notified the defendants that these costs were unallowable.” There is a way to continue to claim disputed costs but, apparently, the Bechtel team didn’t follow it. (See FAR 31.201-6(b).)

In addition to the $58 million settlement, the DoJ reported that—

Bechtel and AECOM also entered into a 3-year independent corporate monitor agreement, which requires Bechtel and AECOM to pay for a full-time independent monitor and assistant monitor selected by the USAO. These monitors will enjoy broad access to Bechtel’s and AECOM’s systems, meetings, personnel, and other information pertaining to labor charging. The monitors will also report directly to the United States. Bechtel and AECOM face additional liquidated damages of up to $10 million if they violate the terms of the monitoring agreement, provide false information, or fail to immediately correct any identified DOE contract issues.

As with many False Claims Act settlements, this one started with qui tam relators filing suit on behalf of the U.S. Government. In this particular matter, the four relators will split $13,750,000—which is about 23 percent of the total amount of the Bechtel team’s settlement.

 

 

Fighting Corruption

E-mail Print PDF

“How do you measure the [ethical] strength of [a] corporate culture?” – Eric Feldman

You can go back on this blog for more than 10 years now. As of this writing, there are 1,326 individual blog articles. Some are short and pithy; others long-winded. In any case, that’s a lot of words. Conservatively estimated, it’s more than a million words.

Did they matter? That’s not for us to say.

But if you look at all the articles on procurement fraud and bribery and product substitution and timekeeping fraud and small business misrepresentation, you might get the sense that there is a hell of a lot of corruption in this world of public procurement. It’s always puzzled us that there are so many people and so many companies that think they are going to get away with something; obviously, some do, but so many others do not.

If there is one theme that permeates all the fraud-related articles it is this: companies that invest in internal controls designed to detect and/or prevent employee wrong-doing are making smart investments that have quantifiable returns, in terms of reduced litigation expenses.

We were reminded of this theme once again as we wrapped-up our annual compliance and ethics training, courtesy of the Society of Corporate Compliance & Ethics (SCCE).

In that training we were exposed to the 2020 Report to the Nations, recently published by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. It covered more than 2,500 instances of occupational fraud reported globally in 2018 and 2019. The Report supported what we have been long saying.

  • Across the globe, corruption (which includes offenses such as bribery, conflicts of interest, and extortion) was the most common fraud scheme, other than asset misappropriation (theft)

  • 43% of fraud was detected via tip; 33% of fraud was reported via hotline email or telephone account

  • The presence of anti-fraud controls is associated with lower losses and quicker detection

  • Median fraud losses at companies that had did not have hotlines were nearly double the median losses at those companies that did

As was explained during the training, the conclusions from the AFCE report are clear:

  • Internal controls pay for themselves

  • Hotlines work

  • Use of hotlines is a sign of an ethically healthy company

We also learned that Artificial Intelligence (AI) has advanced to the point where anybody who is not using it in anti-fraud activities is really missing a cheap and effective means of detecting anomalies. At this point, one can use AI to “risk-score” every single accounting transaction in an entity. Every expense report and every Accounts Payable transaction can be risk scored. Employee addresses in a vendor master file can be detected; indeed, employee addresses adjacent to a vendor’s address can be identified. Vendors can be compared to one another: all suppliers of the same commodity can be compared to see if any stick out in terms of average payment size or frequency of payments. If a supplier sticks out, that supplier can be correlated with the buyer to see what’s going on. At this point, there is really no excuse for failing to deploy AI in anti-fraud activities.

This article is not the first time we’ve mentioned some of these ideas, but it’s the first time the return on investment of internal controls has been so clearly shown.

And it’s becoming more important than ever to be focused on detecting instances of corruption. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners also recently published another benchmarking report: “Fraud in the Wake of COVID-19.” The ACFE received 1,851 survey responses. According to that report:

  • As of May, 2020, 68% of respondents “had already experienced or observed an increase in fraud levels, with one-quarter saying the observed increase had been significant.”

  • “Frauds perpetrated by vendors and sellers … are also a top risk … 86% of respondents expect to see more of this type of fraud over the coming year, and 68% have already seen an increase in these schemes.”

  • Ten percent of respondents “expected a reduction in their anti-fraud staffing over the next year” and eight percent “anticipate budget cuts to affect their anti-fraud programs and initiatives.”

It seems that one impact from the COVID-19 crisis is an increased in perceived fraud risk and a potential decrease in corporate resources used to detect/prevent fraud. That’s not good.

At a macro level, the U.S. Government is gearing up to fight COVID-19 related fraud. At a recent webinar presented by Ernst & Young, we learned that the CARES Act created three separate oversight bodies: (1) The Pandemic Response Accountability Committee (PRAC), (2) the Congressional Oversight Commission, and (3) The Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (SIGPR). At least two of those three oversight bodies have both civil and criminal referral authority to the Department of Justice. According to EY, “SIGPR has entered into Memorandums of Understanding with the U.S. Attorney’s Offices of Massachusetts and Eastern Virginia to investigate and prosecute fraud related to CARES Act funds such as loans, loan guarantees and other investments.”

EY also reported that, at a June 2020 speech, the Principal Deputy Assistant U.S. Attorney General told the audience that—

  • The DOJ’s Civil Division will energetically use every enforcement tool available to prevent wrongdoers from exploiting the COVID-19 crisis.

  • The division will use the False Claims Act to prosecute fraud related to the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP), the Main Street Lending Program and other programs.

Let’s wrap this up: the corruption risk environment is increasing, anti-fraud resources may be at risk, and the U.S. Government is gearing up for intense scrutiny. We know that anti-fraud internal controls pay for themselves. In particular, we know that hotlines work, and that companies that have healthy avenues for employee referrals should expect to have reduced losses and reduced legal settlements.

Given all that, we have to ask you to reflect upon your company’s dedication to fighting corruption. Is it a priority? If not, should it be?

 


Page 17 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.