In Which a Question on Cost Allowability is Answered
Not every contractor is an uber-sophisticated business, chock-full of accountants, lawyers, and internal auditors who review every single accounting transaction for cost allowability. Not every contractor can afford the kind of dedicated indirect staff to review every single transaction before it is recorded to ensure it’s being recorded properly, then check it again as it’s being recorded, and then check it one more time after it’s been recorded—just to make sure. It’s simply not feasible even for the biggest DoD contractors; and it’s well-nigh impossible for the smaller ones.
So companies muddle through, somehow. They do stat samples and they look at risky accounts, and they hope that not too many unallowable costs slipped through the cracks. They hire one or two ex-DCAA auditors and they send a couple of people to a seminar every other year. Those folks become the SMEs that the rest of the company turns to in order to make the proper call regarding cost allowability.
And when DCAA questions a transaction and those company SMEs can’t figure out what the company’s position should be, then they turn to outside consultants for help.
Hello, pleased to meet you.
Recently we received a question on cost allowability. We answered it. The company didn’t offer to pay us and we didn’t bill them. As a result we gave them a quick-and-dirty, two sentence answer. But there was a longer answer that we might have given, had we been under a consulting contract. We thought we would publish the longer answer here.
Why didn’t we give this longer answer to the person who emailed us the question? Not likely. They got the answer they paid for. It’s not like we charged ‘em for it.
Here is the question:
The DAR Council said that if the cheapest ticket is non-refundable (NR) then that is the ticket to be booked. Well of course NR tickets are the cheapest so that's what we book. But say we don't take the flight for whatever reason? Is the cost/expense of the ticket still an allowable and billable cost? My resident DCAA office has always been of the opinion that if the flight isn't taken then the cost cannot be billed to the Government. The Federal Register announcement of the January 2010 update discussed allowability of change fees but not of NR tickets that aren't used.
What are your thoughts on the allowability of unused NR tickets?
Before we share our thoughts on the question, what are your thoughts? Is the resident DCAA office correct that “if the flight isn’t taken then the cost cannot be billed to the Government”? Yes or no? Please support your answer.
Giving the longer, consultant-type, answer required a bit of analysis. To that end, let’s unpack the airfare allowability requirement a little bit.
Federal Acquisition Circular (FAC) 2005-38, published December 10, 2009, contained a final rule implementing FAR Case 2006-024, which revised Cost Principle 31.205-46 (Travel Costs). At the time, the Civilian Agency Acquisition Council and the Defense Acquisition Regulations Council (the FAR Councils) provided the following rationale for the revision—
The travel cost principle at FAR 31.205-46(b) currently limits allowable contractor airfare costs to ‘the lowest customary standard, coach, or equivalent airfare offered during normal business hours.’ The Councils are aware that this limitation is being interpreted inconsistently, either as lowest coach fare available to the contractor or lowest coach fare available to the general public, and these inconsistent interpretations can lead to confusion regarding what costs are allowable.
The Councils believe that the reasonable standard to apply in determining the allowability of airfares is the lowest priced airfare available to the contractor. It is not prudent to allow the costs of the lowest priced airfares available to the general public when contractors have obtained lower priced airfares as a result of direct negotiation.
As required, the FAR Councils solicited, considered and responded to public input. Here are some relevant portions of the public comments, and responses thereto, published along with the final rule.
Comment: Does ‘lowest priced coach class’ mean the cost of ‘non-refundable’ tickets when they are available and their cost is lower than refundable tickets?
Response: If the lowest available airfare is a non-refundable ticket then it is the allowable cost unless one of the exceptions in FAR 31.205-46(b) applies.
Comment: Please address whether or not costs associated with cancelling or changing restricted tickets will be allowable; alternatively, insert the word ‘unrestricted’ into the phrase, i.e., ‘lowest priced coach class unrestricted or equivalent airfare available to the contractor.’
Response: The Councils believe that the revision does not impact the allowability of costs associated with cancelling or changing restricted tickets or a forfeiture of air travel tickets purchased in good faith but later determined to be unsuitable to the mission requirements. To answer the Commenter's questions, the costs before and after the revised cost principle should be allowable.
As can be seen from the foregoing, the original question we received was not entirely factually accurate. First of all, it was not the DAR Council that issued the rule revision, it was both of the Councils that were publishing the rule and “saying” what the rule meant. Second, the FAR was published in December, 2009 – not January, 2010 – though it had a January, 2010 effective date, so maybe that’s a bit nitpicky.
But the biggest error was in the comment that the FAC discussed the allowability of change fees but not the allowability of tickets not used. As can plainly be seen, the FAR Councils absolutely discussed both situations and clearly stated that both “should be allowable.” That’s half the answer.
Now on to DCAA and its erroneous interpretation of the Cost Principle. Assuming the interlocutor accurately conveyed the essence of the DCAA position, we note that the position would conflict with DCAA’s own audit guidance on the Cost Principle revision.
The MRD that provided guidance to DCAA auditors on the rule change stated—
Costs associated with cancelling or changing restricted or non-refundable tickets should be considered an ordinary and necessary business expense unless the contractor’s data show the costs are the result of a history of inadequate advance travel planning procedures.
The DCAA audit guidance, quoted above, clearly shows that the costs of non-refundable tickets that are not used are allowable – unless the contractor has been negligent in its travel planning. Therefore, not only is there support in the promulgating comments for the contractor's position, there is also support in the DCAA audit guidance.
QED
That’s not to say that we entirely agree with every aspect of that piece of DCAA audit guidance. As is unfortunately too often the case, it has some wonky stuff that DCAA seems to have created out of nothing; certainly from nothing found in the FAC.
For example, take a look at the foregoing –
To comply with the revised rule, the contractor’s policies and procedures should provide for advance planning of travel to assure that the lowest priced airfare available to the contractor for flights during normal business hours is documented and utilized as the baseline allowable airfare cost. To determine the lowest airfare available to the contractor for flights during normal business hours, the contractor must now consider nonrefundable airfares and lower airfares negotiated with airlines, travel service providers, credit card companies, etc. …
Ordinarily, with adequate advance planning, documentation substantiating the lowest airfare available takes the form of quotations from competing airlines or travel service providers from which the lowest priced airfare can be selected, giving proper consideration to any potential discounts or credits to the contractor’s cost. There may be instances where only one flight is available for a given mission need and, therefore, only one quote is obtained, in which case the one quotation would substantiate the lowest priced airfare available. However, auditors observing frequent instances in which a single quotation is obtained to support the airfare should assess whether the design or execution of the contractor’s policies and procedures results in unreasonable airfare costs.
As you can see, from the December, 2009 FAC, the DCAA policy folks created a number of checklist items out of whole cloth. For example, all of a sudden a contractor must obtain “quotations from competing airlines or travel service providers” in order to substantiate that it chose the lowest available airfare. From that imaginary requirement comes the likely questioning of air fares for which the contractor did not obtain quotations.
Seems kind of silly to us.
But that being said, a contractor’s travel policy should absolutely require advance travel planning, as well as the booking of airfare at the earliest feasible time, in order to obtain the best fare and also to prevent travelers from gaming the system by booking full fares just before travel in order to get the free upgrades airlines often offer in such circumstances. But all that other stuff is hokum. Pick the schedule, pick the lowest fare for the schedule, and document the other possible fares. Done. You have now substantiated the allowability of the airfare.
Similarly, if you book a non-refundable airfare (and you should) and you end up cancelling the flight, then the cost is allowable. But remember to have the employee process an expense report – as if the flight was actually taken – documenting business purpose as well as the reason the trip was cancelled. If you don’t do those things then you might well find DCAA questioning the airfare; not because it was a non-refundable trip that wasn’t taken, but because you failed to provide the business purpose for the trip. Two different things.
So there you go. Here’s a real consulting-type answer to the question, one reserved for when clients actually engage Apogee Consulting, Inc., and pay us for our time.
ASBCA Teaches Small Business about Cost Allowability and Statute of Limitations
In a recent decision at the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals, Administrative Judge O’Sullivan taught Coherent Logix, Inc. (CLX) a couple of important lessons. Readers should review the Judge’s decision and learn those lessons for themselves. In the meantime, here's an article on some of those lessons.
CLX is small business, located in Austin, Texas. “Its principal business focus is on creating technology for high performance data processing using a scalable embedded processor platform.” Whatever that means. Our point is: CLX is the kind of small, agile, innovative technology company that the DoD has focused on courting. One of the lessons here is that, unless the DoD starts to relax some of the regulatory requirements applied to these small, agile, innovative technology companies, it’s going to lose them. But that’s not really the focus in this article.
CLX submitted its annual final indirect cost billing rate proposal for its FY 2007 on August 13, 2008. Apparently it sat fallow for a long time, but eventually auditors from the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA) got around to reviewing it for adequacy. We strongly suspect it was found to be inadequate, but we don't know for sure. In any case a revised proposal was submitted on June 19, 2013—nearly five years after the original submission. DCAA audited the proposal and found it included unallowable costs. $82,396 of those unallowable costs were expressly unallowable – namely, $68,894 for legal fees associated with patents, plus “costs of exhibition at trade shows (advertising costs), travel costs exceeding per diem, undocumented first class airfare, and costs of meals determined to be entertainment.”
Oops!
We’ve written about expressly unallowable costs before. We wrote—
… it is important for contractors to ‘scrub’ their proposals to establish final billing rates (also known as ‘incurred cost proposals’) to ensure that they are not claiming expressly unallowable costs. They are required to certify that they have excluded such costs and, if the Contracting Officer determines that the proposal contained expressly unallowable costs despite that certification, then penalties and interest may be imposed.
Accordingly, readers will be unsurprised to learn that—
On 21 November 2014, the Defense Contract Management Agency (DCMA) administrative contracting officer (ACO) issued his final decision finding that CLX had included expressly unallowable costs in its 2007 submission, consisting of the $68,894 in patent legal fees and $13,204 in other expressly unallowable costs. The ACO assessed a Level One penalty of $73,912 on the portion of these costs allocable to covered contracts, and added interest of $17,239, for a total of $91,151. He also stated that while he had carefully considered CLX's request for waiver of the penalty under FAR 42.709-S(c), he had determined that CLX's request did not meet the FAR criteria for waiver of the penalty. In particular, the ACO stated that the unallowable costs were not inadvertently incorporated into the proposal, but were included because CLX believed them to be allowable.
CLX disputed the ACO’s Contracting Officer’s Final Decision (COFD), asserting that the ACO erred in failing to waive the penalties and, in any case, the ACO’s COFD was barred by the Contract Disputes Act’s six-year Statute of Limitations (CDA SoL).
Judge O’Sullivan first addressed the CDA SoL argument. She noted that Judge Dyk’s ruling in Sikorsky had converted the CDA SoL argument from one of jurisdiction to one of an affirmative defense. Judge Dyk’s decision, which Judge O’Sullivan was bound to follow, had the effect of flipping the burden from the Government to the appellant (in this case, CLX). Instead of requiring the Government to show why the Court had jurisdiction, CLX was required to show why it did not. CLX’s arguments did not persuade the judge.
CLX argued that DCAA had audited prior years’ final rate proposals and had never taken exception to any legal costs (which included patent costs), nor had DCAA objected to any IP Amortization costs (which also included legal fees associated with obtaining the patents). Judge O’Sullivan found that simply including patent-related in legal fees or in IP Amortization expense did not provide the Government with adequate notice that CLX was incurring expressly unallowable legal costs. With respect to an affidavit submitted by Gary Baggett (CLX Controller), Judge O’Sullivan wrote, “Notably, Mr. Baggett states only that CLX made books and records available in prior years that showed its patent-related legal costs, but not that patent-related legal costs were included in CLX's final indirect cost rate proposal for any year prior to its 2007 proposal.”
The Judge was persuaded instead by the Government’s counter-argument, which was—
[The Government’s] claim could not have accrued before 1 August 2013, when CLX provided the General Ledger detail showing the patent legal costs to the DCAA. Diane Chang, a DCAA auditor, provided an affidavit in which she states that DCAA requested the General Ledger detail from CLX on 24 July 2013 and received it on 1August 2013. Ms. Chang also states that she has searched the DCAA files and did not find General Ledger detail anywhere in CLX's 13 August 2008 submission. She further states that the only information CLX provided on legal costs prior to 1 August 2013 was the single line item identifying only generic ‘legal services’ in the amount of $89,196.
So one lesson here is that contractors should provide maximum General Ledger account detail along with submission of their proposals to establish final billing rates, even down to transaction level detail if feasible. We realize that for any company larger than the very smallest size, that’s going to be a ridiculously difficult task, but we think it’s going to be the only way to defeat the Government’s argument (which has now succeeded in two CDA SoL cases) that it never knew of allegedly unallowable costs until the auditor requested and saw the transaction detail.
With respect to CLX’s second argument, which was it included the expressly unallowable costs because it didn’t know any better, Judge O’Sullivan was similarly unpersuaded. CLX argued that it relied on a lack of audit findings in prior DCAA audits and, once it learned its legal fees associated with patents were not allowable, it implemented remedial measures to prevent a future recurrence of such costs. The Judge found that those arguments simply did not meet the prerequisites for penalty waiver found at FAR 42.709-5(c).
In that respect, her decision followed the same logic as was used by Judge James in his August, 2012, decision on the appeal of Inframat Corporation. We discussed that decision in this article. The lesson there is that negligence does not equate to “inadvertence” with respect to penalty waiver. In order to receive a waiver, the contractor must demonstrate “to the contracting officer’s satisfaction” that expressly unallowable costs were included as the result of “unintentional error, notwithstanding the exercise of due care.” In other words, here’s another area where having robust internal controls (including employee training on the requirements of the FAR Cost Principles) would not only tend to reduce the probability of inclusion of unallowable costs, but would also tend to increase the probability of receiving a penalty waiver should they be included.
Thus, dear readers, there are many broadly applicable lessons to be learned in this ASBCA decision. Perhaps the most fundamental lesson is that contractors, regardless of size or sophistication, must invest in internal controls and training, and in having deeply experienced personnel who understand the complex requirements of the FAR Cost Principles and how to support a DCAA audit. Some innovative, agile, technology companies are not willing to make that investment – preferring, instead, to focus on their technology (and perhaps on their marketing). Those contractors should not do business with the DoD, nor should the DoD woo them. If the DoD wants to attract such companies – as it says it does – it needs to carve-out contractual, regulatory (and perhaps statutory) exemptions for them.
In the meantime, contractors should consider the lessons offered by Judge O’Sullivan’s decision and make necessary changes to their operations in order to better assure compliance or, in the case of a legal dispute, victory.
|
A Point of View
When this blog first started, back in 2009, we weren’t quite sure how it would work out. We did a test run in early 2008 and, quite frankly, it was a lot of work. It was a lot of work to work a full day and then muster the energy to write a thousand words or so about a topic that we found interesting and (we hoped) would be of interest to like-minded individuals.
Our first model was Bob Antonio’s WIFCON news feed, where he linked to current events and news stories geared to acquisition professionals, as well as IG audit reports and GAO reports and Legislative hearings. Accordingly, our early articles (which you can still find if you are so inclined) are little more than links to other stuff. That was okay, but it felt somehow less than fully satisfying. So we quickly moved on from that model and started talking about what was on the other side of the link..
Our position was, and still is, that we want to do more than simply link to other articles or to other topics of interest. We want to express an opinion about those articles.
How boring it would be, we thought, if we only reported FAR Cases or IG audit reports via a link to those items. How boring it would be if we only repeated what was published in the Federal Register or in the current National Defense Authorization Act. How boring it would be if we only linked to new DCAA MRDs without noting what was important about them.
It would certainly be easier on us to post a link and be done with it. We could link to the topic and let the reader do all the work. Indeed, that’s what the majority of “bloggers” do—especially those “bloggers” who work for firms where branding is considered to be important and therefore all online content is reviewed and edited to ensure that nothing controversial, which might impair the firm brand, is ever posted. We see it all the time on LinkedIn, where certain practitioners “publish” links to Government reports or Washington Post news stories without offering a single word of commentary.
Yes, that’s clearly the easier approach. That’s clearly the approach that reduces the risk that something published is going to offend some reader somewhere, perhaps one in a position of power or one in a position to decide which consulting firm gets work and which one does not. That is clearly the prudent course of action and most level-headed businesspeople would counsel it.
But that was not that path we chose to follow.
Early on we decided to voice an opinion. We decided to add value in the form of commentary. We thought it would be consistent with our consulting philosophy to not just report the events of interest, but to attempt to place them in historical context and to describe what we liked (and disliked) about them. It was perhaps a riskier approach, but one aligned with our philosophy of adding value to our clients.
Sometimes it’s worked to our advantage; other times perhaps not so much. So be it.
One more thing: in addition to voicing a point of view about the stuff we chose to write about, we also had to decide how we would articulate that point of view. Or to put it another way, we need to choose the point of view we would use in the blog articles. In this second meaning of “point of view” we refer to the literary point of view, articulated by Robert J. Sawyer in this brief article for beginning writers of science fiction.
Sawyer asserts that “Over ninety percent of all modern speculative fiction is written using the same POV: limited third person.” In the limited third person point of view, the writer uses a lot of third-person pronouns, (e.g., he, she, it). Another approach would have been to write in first-person, which would mean use of a lot of “I” because “I” was expressing the point of view. We’ve written a couple of first person POV articles, but not very many.
Instead, we’ve made the deliberate choice to write in the “royal we” – first person plural -- which has been also called the “editorial we.” It’s been called a “pompous pronoun choice” that is better left unused by authors—unless those authors are in fact members of royalty. Nonetheless, we picked it because the third person felt too impersonal and the first person felt too personal.
Sometimes the use of “we” fools people, such as the news source who quoted one of our articles (without permission but with attribution) and described Apogee Consulting, Inc., as a group of accounting specialists. Well, that part was mostly true—Apogee does have a few SMEs on call should the need arise. But most of the work is done by just one person, the Principal Consultant, who is also the President.
And truth be told, every single article ever written and published on this website was written by that same individual. “I” am Nick Sanders and I’m the sole author (and editor) of more than 800 individual articles. Like ‘em or hate ‘em – it’s all on me. Not we. Me.
UPDATE: Investing Advice
Nearly two years ago – on August 26, 2013, to be exact – we published an article that had nothing to do with government contracts, cost accounting, compliance, or the aerospace/defense industry. In a total departure we offered our readers investing advice. Not only was it a unique topic not otherwise found in our oeuvre of blog articles (or expertise!) we also offered it in the first person point of view, which we rarely use on this site.
(An article on point of view and the use of pronouns is being written and will soon be published, as if you need yet another article not related to anything else on this site.)
We caveated the hell out of the original article, writing “To be clear: I claim no insight or insider knowledge or any expertise in this area whatsoever. So feel free to ignore my investing advice. I really have no business writing about the topic.” That caveat still stands. We claim no expertise and no special insight into the world of investing, and you may want to skip this article because, quite candidly, what the hell do we know?
Not much! Let us be the first to tell you.
But still ….
In that original article we discussed how one could create a fairly well-diversified portfolio without investing a lot of money. We created a hypothetical portfolio of 100 shares each of three American companies, the lot of which could be purchased that day for less than $6,000 total (excluding commissions). We wrote –
I’m not rich—you too can buy 100 shares of Ford right now for $1,700 or so. You can buy 100 shares of Bank of America for $1,500 or so. You can buy 100 shares of Cisco Systems for $2,400 or so. So for less than $6,000, you can have a stock portfolio that includes an American auto manufacturer, a finance company, and a technology company. That’s not too shabby, in terms of diversification.
We did not recommend those stocks in any way whatsoever. That was just a hypothetical example intended to show “what if?” Obviously we were not offering investment advice and we went far out of our way to make that very clear.
But still ….
What if you had taken our advice on August 26, 2013? Where would you be today if you had invested your $5,500 as we had shown?
Just for giggles, we went looked at how you would have fared.
Had you purchased 100 shares of Cisco stock on August 26, 2013, you would have paid $2,383 (excluding commission). As of April 3, 2015, that stock was worth $2,713, so you would have made $330 had you sold it on that day.
Similarly, 100 shares in Bank of America would have cost you $1,449 and you could have sold them for $1,554 on April 3, 2015, for a price appreciation of $105.
Our hypothetical investment in Ford would have cost you $1,641 and you could have sold those 100 shares for $1,603 on April 3, 2015 – which would have been a loss of $38.00.
In sum, your August 26, 2013 investment of $5,473 was worth $5,870 on April 3, 3015. You would have made $397.00.
But that’s not the end of the story. As we told you in the original article, “the other way to make money is through income, or payment of dividends. Many stocks pay dividends to their shareholders.” The math above does not include any dividend payments; and each of those three stocks paid dividends.
The table below shows the total picture (excluding commissions) on the hypothetical investment of $5,500.

As the table shows, even though you would have lost $38.00 on Ford’s share price, at the same time you would have made $90.00 in dividend payments—cold, hard cash paid directly into your bank account by Ford Motor Company. Factoring dividends into the picture shows that you would have made a return on your investment of more than 3 percent.
Similarly you would have seen an ROI of nearly 9 percent on your Bank of America stock, and a whopping 19.35 percent ROI on your Cisco stock. Overall, you would have made $637 for a ROI of nearly 12 percent.
Moreover, since you held on to the stock for more than a year, you would have received favorable capital gain treatment on the stock sale.
Compare that to your fully taxable interest earned from your $5,500 Certificate of Deposit.
One final note:
In the original article we discussed our experience with Apple stock, wherein we bought 10 shares at $650.00 each ($6,500 total investment). At the time we wrote the article, Apple was selling at $503 per share, so we had lost nearly $1,500. On paper. Kind of a bummer.
What happened since then?
Well, first of all Apple split 7/1 so our 10 shares become 70 shares.
Apple did okay and was selling on April 3, 2015 for $125.32 per share. Our original investment of $6,500 was worth $8,772.40, for a gain of $2,272 or 35 percent. Not too shabby.
In addition, Apple has paid $192.60 in dividends on those 10 (now 70) shares.
So in total, while we were down $1,500 when we wrote the original article, our ROI today, should we have sold on April 3, 2015, would have been $2,465 or nearly 40 percent.
So how’s that CD looking now?
Again, we are not offering investment advice nor are we advocating purchasing any shares in any particular company. We’re just talking hypotheticals here.
But still ….
You may want to get serious about investing. It really doesn’t take all that much money to start and, as we hope we’ve shown, even a small initial investment can return some fairly tasty returns.
|