Big 4 Ethics Scandals
Did you hear about the KMPG scandal? According to news reports, six firm accountants, three of whom were former employees of the PCAOB, were charged by the SEC with leaking sensitive confidential data to help the accounting firm clear regulatory inspections. By knowing in advance which public company audits the PCAOB would select, KPMG could scrub its audit files and identify any gaps in workpaper documentation before the reviewers showed up. According to the criminal indictments, KPMG allegedly recruited at least one of the regulators at a time when nearly 50 percent of audits reviewed by the PCAOB were found to have deficiencies. Another showed up with more information, and (allegedly) both firm accountants received additional information from a PCAOB employee who was seeking employment with the firm.
Francine McKenna quoted Jim Ulvog, as saying, “From my auditor’s perspective, this situation has the feel of a ‘red flag’, meaning something that seems odd on the surface and which is actually a warning sign there could be a far more serious problem, potentially systemic and possibly quite material.” Indeed, this is not the first time KPMG has been in the news in a less than positive fashion. Readers may recall a certain tax shelter case from years ago.
But it’s not just KMPG. Each of the other Big 4 firms has had its own ethical challenges. For example, Deloitte paid $2 million in 2013 for violating Sarbanes-Oxley and PCAOB rules. Going back a few years more, the firm’s Vice Chairman, Tom Flanagan, was charged with providing insider information on the companies he audited to traders. Those charges were settled in 2010.
And let’s not forget that EY had several employees and a partner barred from performing public audits by the PCAOB, because they “created, backdated, and added documentation to an audit file when they learned it would soon be inspected by the board.”
What about PwC? It’s had its own problems, including allegations of theft of trade secrets and allegations that it provided unlawful tax avoidance advice. (To our knowledge the firm has not admitted any liability in those matters.)
The point is, these four bastions of professional accountancy have each had ethical breaches. Perhaps that’s to be expected. Any large population of individuals is going to have a Bell curve of distribution of ethical behavior. And some of those individuals are going to fall on the tails of the distribution. On the other hand, partners are supposed to be vetted before ascension, and one would like to think that ethical concerns would be a barrier to partnership. Perhaps that’s just wishful thinking, but still…
When you evaluate your company for ethical concerns, remember these anecdotes and allegations. No company is immune from ethical concerns.
No company. Not even your company.
The first line of defense against fraud and corruption is not your six DFARS Business Systems. No. The first line of defense against employee fraud and ethical breaches is the corporate culture. As part of your evaluation of your company for ethical concerns, do not forget to evaluate the corporate culture. A weak corporate culture, with ineffective or inconsistent discipline for wrongdoing, is the first sign that there could be wide-spread or even systemic corruption.
Note, if you will, that several of the allegations discussed above could pertain to a government contractor undergoing review of a DFARS Business System. For example, if you knew a CPSR was coming up, it would sure be helpful to know exactly which procurement files the reviewers were going to select, wouldn’t it? And if you got to those files first, and you found gaps, how would you deal with the temptation to correct those gaps? Would you create missing documents? If you did, would you backdate them? Would your management encourage you to do those things—potentially violating the False Statements Act—or would your management discipline you for doing them?
Perhaps you are not in the Big 4. Perhaps you are not in the accounting profession. Maybe you’re just a run-of-the-mill government contractor. If so, you might think you have nothing in common with those big, expensive, firms.
But you’d be wrong.
There is a lot to be learned from those big, expensive, professional accounting firms, if you have the awareness to see it.
Timekeeping Fraud and Mandatory Disclosures
Just a reminder that Nick Sanders – that’s me! – will be speaking at an upcoming meeting of the San Diego Chapter of the Association of Government Accountants. I’ll be speaking on February 14th – Valentine’s Day – at lunchtime.
Here’s a link to event registration, if you’re interested. Registration closes on February 8th. That’s tomorrow!
For those who are not attending, I’ll be covering the following topics:
-
Risks and mitigating controls—i.e,, what are circumstances where timekeeping fraud is likely to be found, and what might you do to detect and/or prevent it?
-
Quantification and Audit Support—i.e., if you choose to disclose instances of timekeeping fraud, how do you quantify the government’s damages? How do you convince an auditor that you did it correctly?
|
Small Business and Socioeconomic Stuff
FAR Part 19 deals with small business programs. It includes policy positions and size standards, and it establishes rules for small business “set-asides”—which are competitions reserved exclusively for small business participation. FAR Part 19 establishes the rules for prime contractor’s small business subcontracting programs. It discusses 8(a) programs and HUBZone programs and SDVO small business programs and WOSB programs. It is full of important information and, if you are dealing with those topics, you had better read it.
But FAR Part 19 doesn’t tell you everything you need to know.
Smart contractors know that there is other very important information found in the regulations of the Small Business Administration, over at Volume 13 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Over at 13 CFR Part 125, you can find many details regarding how small business programs work. Smart contractors know to look there for information that supplements FAR Part 19 stuff. If you are dealing with these topics, you need to read both FAR Part 19 and the SBA rules in 13 CFR to get the real nitty-gritty information.
One might reasonably wonder how conflicts between the FAR and the SBA rules are resolved. Further, one might reasonably wonder how conflicts between the many FAR Agency Supplements and the SBA rules are resolved. Good questions. Such conflicts are the stuff of many bid protests and other disputes.
As the result of confusion and some protests and some litigation, the GFY 2017 NDAA transferred “the responsibility for issuing regulations relating to ownership and control for the Department of Veterans Affairs verification of Veteran-Owned (VO) and Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned (SDVO) Small Business Concern (SBC)” to the SBA. Subsequently, the SBA has issued a proposed rule that would address those issues within 13 CFR Part 125.
The SBA describes the proposed rule-making as creating “one definition of ownership and control for these concerns, which will apply to the Department of Veterans Affairs in its verification and Vets First Contracting Program procurements, and all other government acquisitions which require self-certification.” If you are concerned with small business issues related to contracting with the VA, you might want to check it out—and consider submitting comments, if warranted.
On a related note, the Section 809 Panel discussed concerns with DoD’s small business subcontracting programs in Section 6 of its First Report. The Panel wants to “Refocus DoD’s small business policies and programs to prioritize mission and advance warfighting capabilities and capacities.” To attain that objective, the Panel issued a Recommendation (#21, including 21a, 21b, and 21c) to “Refocus DoD’s small business policies and programs to prioritize mission and advance warfighting capabilities and capacities.”
The Panel stated—
The Department of Defense’s (DoD) small business policies and programs do not align with DoD’s strategic priorities, including the Third Offset Strategy and building a more lethal force. DoD is not fully capitalizing on small businesses’ innovativeness. Instead, DoD appears to focus its small business policies and programs on acquiring goods and services based on meeting societal goals not related to mission. Complexity and slowness in the acquisition system, an uncoordinated outreach process, a lack of clear points of entry into the defense market, and contract compliance requirements deter and appear to prevent small businesses from working with DoD. Small business programs enabling research, development, and innovation have the greatest potential to positively affect DoD and the small business community. …
Contracting officers and program managers, not DoD’s small business specialists, are held accountable for ensuring small businesses receive contracts, small business requirements are met, and goals are achieved. As a result, small business programs focus almost exclusively on the amount of money and number of contracts awarded to small businesses. … Multiple experts with whom the Section 809 Panel spoke indicated most DoD small business contracts go toward procuring basic services and commodities, given an almost singular focus on the aggregate dollar value of small business contracts. It is easier and less risky for contracting officers to meet their contracting goals by acquiring basic commodities and services than it is to conduct market research and find new small businesses with which to work; available data confirm this assertion. …
Meeting small business goals by acquiring basic commodities and services, rather than obtaining innovative products and support from small companies, will ultimately hurt DoD’s ability to maintain warfighting dominance. Research shows small businesses can provide advanced capabilities and support to DoD; however, data show DoD is not prioritizing working with small businesses to acquire innovation and technology. …
To better understand barriers to entry into the defense market for small businesses, the Section 809 Panel met with more than 50 small companies. Of those companies, at least 30 explicitly stated that doing business with DoD is too complex and burdensome. Many of these companies also stressed that the slowness of the acquisition system presents challenges. …
That’s good stuff, right? (Assuming you read it all, which you definitely should.) But the Section 809 Panel wasn’t done. They had this to say—
Based on data gathered from Section 809 Panel interviews with small companies, many that pursue business with DoD for the first time either are unaware of or underestimate the potential effects of audits, paperwork, and other processes on their companies’ ability to operate. … Another challenge for small companies is the required audit of the firm’s accounting systems and procedures. DCAA performs this function for DoD SBIR participants. According to DCAA, SBIR small businesses potentially are subject to two audits: a preaward audit of the financial system and a postaward audit of the contract. During a roundtable held by the Section 809 Panel, Army contracting officers identified the requirements for DCAA audits and the onerous contracting process as a substantial impediment to SBIR participants. Audit compliance, (see Section 2), is often burdensome and costly, especially for small businesses.
To sum this up, the FAR and SBA rules covering small business participation, small business plans, and socioeconomic reporting are complex and nuanced. The DoD is subject to many of those rules. Those rules, plus other factors identified by the Section 809 Panel, have actually impeded DoD’s ability to make the best use of small businesses. In other words, the results have been counter-productive to the rules’ objectives. That’s not so good.
Perhaps the DoD will use the Section 809 Panel’s recommendations as a springboard for reform. We’ll have to wait and see whether that’s the case.
DoD Makes Changes to Commercial Item Procurements
Readers know that the Department of Defense has long struggled with “commercial item” procurements. The tension between accepting market pricing as the barometer of price reasonableness and delving into contractor “cost and pricing” data has been a tough challenge for contracting officers. Congress has been “helping” DoD with the challenge, by passing various bits of acquisition reform legislation, going back at least to 1994 (the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act). The message has been, “buy commercial.” But the message didn’t seem to percolate through the acquisition bureaucracy, as reports have surfaced that DoD’s acquisition of commercial items has actually declined, rather than increased as Congress intended.
As the Section 809 Panel recently stated—
DoD’s commercial buying has stagnated for multiple reasons. The acquisition workforce has faced issues with inconsistent interpretations of policy, confusion over how to identify eligible commercial products and services, and determining that prices are fair and reasonable. DoD contracting officers have received increasing criticism and oversight from both the DoD Inspector General (IG) and the Government Accountability Office (GAO). This confusion has resulted in frequent promulgation of legislative revisions as Congress seeks ways to encourage DoD to access the commercial marketplace, as well as agency-level policy and local guidance intended to improve the workforce’s ability to buy commercially.
(Vol. 1, Section 1, page 17. Internal footnotes omitted.)
In 2016, DCMA created six Commercial Item Centers of Excellence in order to help its contracting officers navigate the shoals of commercial item procurements. The six CoE’s (located in Tampa Bay, Denver, Indianapolis, Phoenix, Boston, and Philadelphia) are collectively known as the Commercial Item Group. (That link, by the way, contains other links to a number of helpful resources.) DCMA told GAO that the new CoEs were helping, and that 94 percent of all Commercial Item Determinations (CIDs) submitted to one of the CoEs were found to be legitimate and that the items in question met the FAR definition of a “commercial item.”
Meanwhile, subcontractors struggle to convince prime contractor buyers that their items meet the FAR definition as well. While prime contractors can ask their government contracting officers to submit the CID to the Commercial Item Group for resolution, subcontractors do not seem to have a similar path of appeal. They lack recourse when a prime’s buyer says “no,” and demands certified cost and pricing data. Changing standards regarding what support is required for a prime’s CID by DCMA CPSR review teams don’t help things, since prime contractor buyers believe they are risking their system adequacy with every CID they make.
It’s a tough situation, but recent changes might help us all.
Let’s discuss.
First, we have a brand new final DFARS rule (DFARS Case 2016-D006) that was issued on January 31, 2018. Entitled “Procurement of Commercial Items,” the rule revision incorporates various Congressional “fixes” going all the way back to the GFY 2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). The rule makes changes to DFARS rules in Parts 202, 212, 215, 234, and 239. It adds a new solicitation provision in Part 252 (252.215-7010) entitled “Requirements for Certified Cost or Pricing Data and Data Other Than Certified Cost or Pricing Data” and an Alternate 1 to that provision. The provision implements the new regulatory language in Part 215.
Without rehashing the long rule, let’s summarize. Readers are encouraged to review the rule carefully for nuances our summary will inevitably gloss over.
Contracting officers are encouraged to obtain no more information than they need in order to determine that a price is fair and reasonable. In the absence of adequate price competition, the preferred method for determining price reasonableness is a comparison to market prices (meaning “current prices that are established in the course of ordinary trade between buyers and sellers free to bargain and that can be substantiated through competition or from sources independent of the offerors”).
But if that’s not sufficient, then “the contracting officer shall consider information submitted by the offeror of recent purchase prices paid by the Government and commercial customers for the same or similar commercial items under comparable terms and conditions … if the contracting officer is satisfied that the prices previously paid remain a valid reference for comparison.”
If that’s not sufficient, then the contracting officer should request “Prices paid for the same or similar items sold under different terms and conditions; [or] Prices paid for similar levels of work or effort on related products or services; [or] Prices paid for alternative solutions or approaches; [and/or] Other relevant information that can serve as the basis for determining the reasonableness of price.”
If all that doesn’t work, then the contracting officer may request cost data from the prospective offeror. However, “no cost data may be required in any case in which there are sufficient non-Government sales of the same item to establish reasonableness of price.”
Contracting officers are also told that prior CIDs are to be accepted when evaluating whether an item is or is not a commercial item. Further, items and services provided by “non-traditional defense contractors” (defined as “an entity that is not currently performing and has not performed any contract or subcontract for DoD that is subject to full coverage under the cost accounting standards … for at least the 1-year period preceding the solicitation of sources by DoD for the procurement”) as commercial items. As readers know, once an item (or service) has been accepted as being a commercial item, then the contracting officer is prohibited from requiring certified cost or pricing data from the contractor.
So that happened. Seems like good news for some contractors.
In addition, DoD recently issued its final Commercial Item Handbook (Version 2.0), link here. It comes in two volumes. Part A is for Commercial Item Determinations and Part B is for Pricing Commercial Items. Skimming the new Handbook, we liked how it clearly explained expectations. For example, it tells contracting officers that, when determining price reasonableness, the first data source should be government resources; the second source should be public/market resources other than the contractor; and only as a final resort should the contractor be expected to provide resources and information. Without a detailed review, we may have missed something. But what we have seen so far seems clear and unobjectionable
Finally, let’s not forget the Section 809 Panel’s first report, which devoted an entire Section to Commercial Buying. The Panel made four recommendations in this area, including: (1) Revise definitions related to commercial buying to simplify their application and eliminate inconsistency; (2) Minimize government ‐unique terms applicable to commercial buying; (3) Align and clarify FAR commercial termination language; and (4) Revise DFARS sections related to rights in technical data policy for commercial products.
Those recommendations, if enacted and implemented in the manner intended by the Section 809 Panel, might further clarify and streamline the murky waters of commercial item procurement. In the meantime, we have the new DFARS rules and the new Commercial Item Handbook, which should help all parties.
|