• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

It Got Even More Complicated, But Northrop Still Won (This Round)

E-mail Print PDF

Nothing_You_Get_Nothing

A long-time reader, who wishes to remain anonymous, recently emailed to urge us to write about this ASBCA decision in which the Board addressed a Government Motion for Reconsideration. By filing the motion, the Government was asking the Board to vacate its prior decision. According to the American Bar Association’s “Practicing Before the Federal Boards of Contract Appeals” legal manual—

BCAs generally grant motions for reconsideration in two circumstances: (1) to allow a party to present significant, newly discovered evidence; or (2) to address the board’s own mistake of fact or law. Do not re-argue positions already presented to and rejected by the board, and do not present arguments that could have been made earlier. When presenting significant, newly-discovered evidence in a motion for reconsideration, attach the newly-discovered evidence to the motion, explain where it came from, why it was not available earlier, and why it is relevant and should alter the board’s decision. If the motion is based on a mistake of fact or law by the board, the party must explain the mistake and why the decision would be different if the mistake was corrected.

We already discussed the original decision, in this article. You need to read that article before this one, because we’re not going to repeat ourselves.

In fact, and as noted in our article, that “original” decision wasn’t really the original decision. It was the second decision. The first decision dealt with “entitlement” and the second decision dealt with “quantum”. The Government won on the first decision—that it was entitled to damages. But the Government lost on the second decision, because the Board found that there were, in fact, no damages. The Government was entitled to nothing.

As part of that second decision (which we quoted at some length in our article), the Board noted that the Government’s position was based on a flawed theory created by DCAA and endorsed by a Contracting Officer, over the objections of DCMA’s own pension experts. Judge Peacock, writing for the Board, stated “The government has failed to sustain its burden of proving that any of the disallowed amount was or will be amortized as part of the transition obligation and claimed during the post-transition years. Its argument is founded on theoretical constructs that have no factual basis or evidentiary support here.”

The Government filed a Motion for Reconsideration of that second decision. It did not fare well.

Judge Peacock, again writing for the Board, stated—

Upon reconsideration, we affirm the quantum decision. There are no inconsistencies among the quantum decision and the Board's earlier entitlement decisions. The government's assertions that the Board contradicted the ‘law of the case,’ i.e., the entitlement decisions, are based on the government's untimely raised and unreasonable ‘interpretation’ of the entitlement decisions. Moreover, the government has ignored the quantum remedy for noncompliance established in FAR 31.201-2(c). In addition, it has misapplied fundamental concepts of cost ‘incurrence’ and ‘disallowance.’

Later in the decision, Judge Peacock wrote—

The gravamen of this dispute has always been whether the government was damaged, i.e., in the words, of FAR 31.201-2(c) whether the contractor claimed (or the government paid) any disallowable ‘excess’ PRB costs as a consequence of appellant's noncompliance. The ultimate overriding fact is that the government did not pay any ‘excess.’ It cannot overcome that basic fact that there was no ‘excess’ by parsing through the entitlement decisions trying to find ‘inconsistencies,’ actual or implied in the supposed ‘philosophy and intent’ of those decisions. …

The concept of cost incurrence ‘by operation of law’ in a government contract accounting ‘allowability’ context is indeed novel, extraordinary, unique and unprecedented. The government has failed to adduce even one analogous case supporting its position. The government contemporaneously exercised common sense during the pre-transition years and knowingly, willingly, declined to challenge appellant's accounting for its claimed PRB costs that resulted in lower costs to the government during the pre-transition years. The ‘common sense’ government position in this regard in the pre-transition years comported with FAR 31.201-2(c). The government now ignores its own regulatory remedy. In doing so it has created an extraordinary new category of costs, incurred not by the contractor's own accounting measurement, accrual or assignment methodology, but allegedly ‘required’ to be incurred by ‘operation of law,’ without regard to NGC's accounting procedures. To the contrary, the operative ‘law’ in this case is the common remedy prescribed for noncompliance in FAR 31.201-2(c). The government's duty is to evaluate costs actually incurred and claimed by the contractor under the pertinent cost principle for compliance. If non-compliant, any ‘excess’ is unallowable, not costs that were never incurred or claimed by the contractor.

(Emphasis in original.)

But wait. There’s more stuff to quote. Read this part about what a cost disallowance is (or should be):

The term ‘disallowance’ presupposes that the contractor has sought an ‘allowance’ for the cost in question, i.e., it has included those costs in contemporaneous cost-related filings and claimed, charged or been reimbursed for said costs. Here, the government has ‘disallowed’ costs for which the contractor has never sought an ‘allowance.’ The contractor has not and will never claim the costs in dispute here for the reasons detailed in the underlying opinion. The ‘excess,’ if any, is to be derived from cost/pricing, payment, and reimbursement submissions, including incurred cost data transmitted to the government from the contractor. There is no mention in any of these foundational, core documents that appellant ever incurred the costs in dispute, much less claimed their reimbursement. There was no ‘excess’ to disallow …

(Emphasis added.)

Do we need to inform you that the Motion for Reconsideration was denied?

Our anonymous reader concluded his email with the following thoughts—

After the LMIS case published last year the DCMA issued guidance to only question costs based on a cost principle or contract clause. The Northrop case started way before LMIS was decided. I wonder if DCMA will reissue their guidance again with some minor tweaks. Such as, don’t demand repayment for a ‘cost’ that was never billed.

Well, we don’t know the answer to that question. In fact, we were unaware of the DCMA “guidance” in question until our anonymous reader mentioned it. If you have a copy (or a link) to that document, please send it to us!

As a final point, let’s remember that, although there have been at least three decisions already issued in this dispute, the parties still have appeal rights. This brouhaha may not be over. We could see another decision on this dispute issued by the Federal Circuit.

 

 

Statute versus Regulation, Part 2

E-mail Print PDF

In a recent article, we discussed the quandary faced by contractors (and perhaps by contracting officers) who might seek to implement the many acquisition threshold changes mandated by the 2018 NDAA. We tried to walk the tightrope between acknowledging the quandary and our views on how to deal with it. We clearly noted that some individuals (and entities) were going to be more conservative than others.

We wrote: “You can wait for [the FAR Councils] to complete the revision process, if you’d like. Or you can lean forward and adopt statutory changes as they are enacted into law.”

Now comes evidence that the right approach is to lean forward—to implement the statutory thresholds without waiting for the FAR Councils to open and close their FAR Cases. The evidence is a Class Deviation issued by the Civilian Agency Acquisition Council (CAAC), that authorizes civilian Agency level Class Deviations to implement threshold changes in advance of official rule-making.

Remember, the changes were focused only on agencies covered by the NDAA, so the fact that the CAAC has jumped on them is a very good sign that they are going to be adopted. Well, not all of the changes, but most of them. You need to review Attachment A and Attachment B of the CAAC Class Deviation to see what will be changing in the FAR versus what will be changing in selected agency supplements (e.g., DFARS and NFARS).

For example, it’s clear that the micro-purchase threshold will be moving to $10,000 across all agencies, both civilian and non-civilian. Further, it’s clear that the Simplified Acquisition Threshold (SAT) will be moving to $250,000 across all agencies (except where it’s higher for certain listed circumstances).

Also note that for some certifications, the requirement for inclusion remains $100,000, because they were set by different statutes. For example, check the Byrd Cert, the Anti-Lobbying Cert, and the Anti-Kickback Cert. We think those will stay at $100K even as the SAT moves to $250,000. If you have contract writing software that tied certs to the SAT rather than to the underlying statutory requirement(s), then you are going to have a problem.

Interestingly (to us), no mention was made of the changing TINA limits, which will now be $2.0 million going forward. Perhaps that was outside the scope of the CAAC Class Deviation, and it will be covered by a future communication.

To summarize: the thresholds are changing. If you are one of the conservative individuals (or entities), who is waiting for the regulations to be officially revised before implementing them, then you are missing an opportunity to reduce workload. The time to update policies, procedures, and practices is now.

 

Accounting for Unallowable Costs

E-mail Print PDF

It’s relatively basic stuff that every government contractor should know. You have to identify and then segregate “unallowable” costs from your proposals, billings, and other things (like claimed indirect cost rates). It’s right there in FAR 31.201-6 (“Accounting for Unallowable Costs”). Every contractor selling non-commercial items has to comply. It’s basic government compliance—like blocking or tackling in (American) football.

Determining exactly which costs are “unallowable” is a lot trickier. You need to thoroughly review FAR Part 31, paying special attention to the list of selected costs at 31.205. You need to know a few court cases and, perhaps, read a few books on the topic. It’s tricky because it requires an application of judgment.

And, if you want to get into even harder stuff, you also need to identify and segregate “directly associated” unallowable costs. Further, as we’ve explained before, there’s a difference between garden-variety unallowable costs and “expressly” unallowable costs, in terms of penalties for failing to properly exclude those costs from your rate calculations, proposals, and/or billings.

So yes, the topic of “unallowable” costs is both broad and deep, but government contractors still need to know about it, and comply with the requirements. In order to comply, some small contractors hire consultants to review their books and to find the unallowable costs—which is not a bad plan because those consultants have the expertise to support their judgments. Other small contractors have outside bookkeepers who are also supposed to identify unallowable costs—which is a risky approach unless you are sure those bookkeepers (or CPAs) have the right expertise. (We don’t believe that knowledge of FAR Part 31 is tested on the CPA exam.)

As contractors grow and can afford additional staff, they hire accountants or billing specialists or Controllers or compliance folks who review accounting transactions for allowability in a more timely manner. Those professionals are hired for their expertise, and it’s usually a good investment—because it’s cheaper to pay (allowable) salaries and benefits than it is to pay unallowable penalties and interest (or lawyers' fees, in extreme cases).

But here’s the thing: No matter what compliance approach you choose as a contractor, you cannot possibly afford to pay for every single transaction to be reviewed by somebody with the requisite expertise.

You cannot afford to pay for every expense report to be reviewed (along with all the receipts) in order to check if somewhere, sometime, somebody got reimbursed for a beer at dinner—and then to see if the cost of that beer was identified and properly recorded as an unallowable cost. You can’t afford to pay for somebody to review every single check request, or vendor invoice, or accounts payable transaction. You simply can’t.

Instead, what you do is have robust policies and procedures and guidance. You have training for employees and supply chain managers and buyers and expense report processors and accounts payable staff, and you have additional training for supervision and management who review and approve transactions. You have special focused training for program managers and for business development folks. You very clearly tell your people what costs are reimbursable, and then which of those costs are going to be allowable and which are going to be unallowable.

You have to do all that because, no matter how hard you try, if you rely on “SMEs” to identify your unallowable costs, something is going to slip through. Anybody you hire from the outside is going to rely on some kind of transaction sample in order to calculate a percentage of unallowable costs (which they are permitted to do). Your employees are going to be looking at a bigger sample of transactions—and you may think it’s 100 percent—but something is going to slip through. That’s just human nature. We’re all fallible and that’s the way it is.

Finally, your own employees may point out to management that an error has been made somewhere in the many upon many accounting transactions that make up a year’s general ledger. The employees may report their concerns and it would behoove you to listen to those concerns, and to make corrections to any cost that was misclassified as an allowable cost when it should have been an unallowable cost.

With all that as background, let’s look at this Department of Justice press release.

The press release announced that Integral Consulting Services, Inc. (Integral or ICS), a “self certified small disadvantaged business” and a “economically disadvantaged women owned small business” (according to this webpage), had settled a False Claims Act lawsuit filed by a former employee for “over a half-million dollars” (actually $505,838). That’s a relatively trivial amount, as such things go. But remember that Integral is a small business, reportedly with only 80+ employees and just over $6 million in annual revenues (as per the previously linked webpage). So $500K is a pretty huge hit to the company’s bottom-line—and that doesn’t take into account the attorney’s fees paid to negotiate the legal settlement with DoJ.

What did the company do wrong? According to the press release—

The civil settlement agreement resolves allegations that from on or about May 1, 2012 through June 27, 2014, ICS took costs and expenses it and its employees incurred in connection with litigation arising out of a teaming agreement with another contracting company and included the costs and expenses in the General and Administration ('G&A') indirect cost pool that was spread amongst ICS’s various government contracts … and submitted to the United States government. The inclusion of such costs had the effect of inflating the claims paid by the Army to ICS.

As best we understand the situation from the above brief description, Integral claimed certain legal costs made unallowable by 31.205-47 as allowable costs. (See FAR 31.205-47(f)(5).) That cost principle states—

Costs of legal, accounting, and consultant services and directly associated costs incurred in connection with the defense or prosecution of lawsuits or appeals between contractors arising from either—

(i) An agreement or contract concerning a teaming arrangement, a joint venture, or similar arrangement of shared interest; or

(ii) Dual sourcing, coproduction, or similar programs, are unallowable, except when—

(A) Incurred as a result of compliance with specific terms and conditions of the contract or written instructions from the contracting officer, or

(B) When agreed to in writing by the contracting officer.

Thus, legal costs incurred in connection with litigation arising out of a teaming agreement were not allowable. They may well have been expressly unallowable. Somebody at Integral didn’t review an invoice from outside counsel, and thus didn’t properly classify the cost as unallowable.

What’s interesting about this situation is that, normally, this is handled via an administrative remedy and not by a lawsuit. DCAA finds the cost and tells the ACO, and the ACO tells the contractor to pay the appropriate penalty and interest. It’s not particularly fun, but it’s not a big deal, either. What makes Integral’s situation different is that an employee noticed the misclassification of the cost, and filed a qui tam suit on behalf of the government—and then got a bounty of more than $90,000 for doing so.

We don’t know why the employee felt the need to file a suit. Did they try to report it and get rebuffed by company management? It’s certainly possible. Looking at Glassdoor, the company has decidedly mixed reviews. Many people love it but many people also had negative comments about management style and a perceived lack of integrity. It’s possible that somebody tried to report the misclassification and was rebuffed—just as it’s possible that the transaction was simply missed by those charged with the responsibility of making sure only allowable costs were claimed in proposals, rate calculations, and billings.

One more thing: missed unallowable costs in G&A expense pools can be bad things, because G&A is allocated to all active cost objectives. Under the False Claims Act, each invoice submitted under each contract becomes a separate claim. Thus, if the G&A rate is “inflated” through inclusion of unallowable costs, then every invoice submitted under each contract was also inflated. The current FCA states each false claim may create a liability ranging from $5,500 to $11,000. That’s per claim. And that’s regardless of the dollar value of the “inflation” as allocated to each claim. Readers need to carefully think about that, before they do a superficial sample of G&A expense pool transactions as part of identification and segregation of unallowable costs.

 

 

DCAA Implements Congressionally Mandated Audit Timing

E-mail Print PDF

We posted several blog articles about the 2018 National Defense Authorization Act. Interestingly (at least to us), the most popular of those articles was not the one about mandated changes to how DCAA audits contractors. Nope. The most popular article was about “acquisition stuff.” Go figure.

You, our readers, are a source of constant surprise.

Nonetheless, we are here today to discuss one of the Congressionally mandated changes to how DCAA audits contractors. We are going to discuss Section 803 of the 2018 NDAA (again). Section 803 is a long and somewhat messy provision. It requires a number of changes to be implemented over varying timelines. But § 803(g)—called “Timeliness of Incurred Cost Audits”—is relatively clear and direct. It states—

  1. The Secretary of Defense shall ensure that all incurred cost audits performed by qualified private auditors or the Defense Contract Audit Agency are performed in a timely manner.

  2. The Secretary of Defense shall notify a contractor of the Department of Defense within 60 days after receipt of an incurred cost submission from the contractor whether the submission is a qualified incurred cost submission.

  3. With respect to qualified incurred cost submissions received on or after the date of the enactment of this section, audit findings shall be issued for an incurred cost audit not later than one year after the date of receipt of such qualified incurred cost submission.

  4. Not later than October 1, 2020, and subject to paragraph (5), if audit findings are not issued within one year after the date of receipt of a qualified incurred cost submission, the audit shall be considered to be complete and no additional audit work shall be conducted.

  5. The Under Secretary of Defense (Comptroller) may waive the requirements of paragraph (4) on a case-by-case basis if the Director of the Defense Contract Audit Agency submits a written request. The Director of the Defense Contract Audit Agency shall include in the report required under section 2313a of this title the total number of waivers issued and the reasons for issuing each such waiver.

(Emphasis added.)

Let’s ignore the fact that they are not “incurred cost audits” (because they are audits of final billing rate proposals), and summarize the above:

  • Effective right now, DCAA has 60 days from the time the contractor submits the incurred cost submission to determine adequacy and notify the contractor of its determination.

  • Effective “with enactment of this section,” DCAA must issue its audit findings to the contractor within one year after the date of receipt. If it takes DCAA two months to issue the adequacy determination, then the audit agency has 10 months to perform its audit procedures and issue its report.

  • DCAA has 36 months to figure out how to meet those Congressionally mandated deadlines, because, effective October 1, 2020, if it cannot issue its audit findings to the contractor within one year after receipt, then it must stop work.

Now, we’ve pointed out some issues with reducing those directives into practice. (See our previous article, link in the 2nd sentence of the 1st paragraph.) Nonetheless, they are what they are. DoD and DCMA and DCAA must take them seriously or risk losing dispute after dispute, as they try to question costs after expiry of the deadlines.

An early indication that, indeed, DCAA is taking the deadlines seriously is issuance of MRD audit guidance on January 29, 2018. MRD No. 18-PIC-001(R), entitled “Audit Alert on 2018 NDAA Section 803 Timeliness Requirement for Incurred Cost Adequacy Reviews and Audits,” established that the audit agency is implementing the Congressionally mandated deadlines assuming an effectivity date of December, 17, 2017 (the date the bill was signed into law).

We have a copy of the MRD, but you probably don’t, because DCAA hasn’t published it on its website yet. Here are some salient quotes for your edification:

  • … for any incurred cost submission received since December 12, 2017, the audit team must complete the adequacy review and notify the contractor of the results of the adequacy review within 60 days.

  • … completing incurred cost assignments within 12 months of receiving a qualified submission after the date of enactment (December 12, 2017). … For example, you receive a submission on January 31, 2018 and … you complete the adequacy checklist on February 15, 2018 and determine the submission is adequate. … The NDAA requires this example audit to be completed within one year (i.e., by January 31, 2019). The Agency will be providing guidance for complying with the NDAA one-year requirement.

Note, readers, that these deadlines wouldn’t have been much of a challenge for the “old” (pre-2008) DCAA. Back then, the contracting parties worked to operate to a “6-12-6” cycle, where the contractor had six months from the close of its fiscal year to submit the proposal, DCAA had 12 months to issue its report, and DCMA had six months to negotiate final billing rates. So there’s really nothing new here. In fact, it’s a return to the days of normalcy, before DCAA went insane.

We also want to remind readers that the Section 809 panel had lots to say about DCAA and how it could improve audit procedures to be more efficient and effective. We invite you to review our blog article here on that topic. Then you should go and read the entire Section 809 report; or at least Section 2 of that report.

For those too busy (or too lazy) to follow those links, here’s a brief taste of what the Section 809 panel had to say about DCAA’s approach to incurred cost audits:

Many of the required elements of an adequate final indirect cost rate proposal have no bearing on calculating, understanding, auditing, and negotiating final indirect cost rates. This collection of unnecessary data has contributed to DCAA losing its focus on the purpose and scope of contractors’ final indirect cost rate proposal and has created unnecessary work for contractors, DCAA, and especially contracting officers. …

DCAA must refocus on its mission of providing contracting officers with the information they need to do their jobs as prescribed in contracts and by the FAR. DCAA should not be auditing direct contract costs unless requested to do so by the contracting officer as set forth in FAR 52.216‐7(g). Several final indirect cost rate proposal schedules that have no bearing on evaluating or settling final indirect cost rates should be removed.

While we cynically doubt that DCAA will listen to the Section 809 Panel’s recommendations, we are heartened to learn the audit agency seems to be listening to Congress. (Such has not always been the case.) If DCAA, as an agency, follows through on its MRD guidance, then life should get easier for all the contracting parties.

 

 

The New CAM

E-mail Print PDF

We’ve proffered criticism of DCAA regarding the lack of published MRDs and the lack of inclusion in the Contract Audit Manual (CAM). Those were valid criticisms, we thought. But in fairness we should point out that DCAA issued a new and revised CAM in December 2017—though of course it hit the website in early February.

Chapter 7 (Selected Areas of Cost) is missing, as it has been since 2015, when DCAA unveiled its Cost Allowability Guidebook. And Chapter 5 (Audit of Policies, Procedures, and Internal Controls Relative to Accounting and Management Systems) is “currently being rewritten.” That said, the CAM is basically the old familiar one we’ve become used to, except updated through December 2017.

Just thought you would want to know.

 

 


Page 57 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.