• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

Another DoDOIG SAR – Another DCAA Report Card

E-mail Print PDF

Every six months the Department of Defense Office of Inspector General (DoDOIG) issues another Semi-Annual Report (SAR) to Congress. The latest one was issued May 29, 2018. It covered the first half of GFY 2018—i.e., October 1, 2017 through March 30, 2018. As we do every six months, we looked at Appendices E and F to see how DCAA has been doing, in terms of productivity and quality. It’s a report card on the audit agency, if you will. For comparison purposes, the last time we reviewed DCAA’s report card was in December 2017—you can find that report card here.

How is DCAA doing?

We’re at the point where simply reporting on the number of DCAA audit reports issued is now a misleading metric. This is because 75 percent of all audit assignments were completed without issuing an audit report, according to the SAR. Thus, if we reported that DCAA issued a paltry 1,176 audit reports in the latest six month period, and then compared that number to the 1,243 reports it issued in the same period last year, or to the 1,480 reports it issued in the same period in 2016, or to the 2,267 reports it issued in the same period in 2014, or to the 14,760 reports it issued in the same period in 2007, you might be misled into thinking that auditor productivity continues to drop.

But that would be misleading, because we’re at the point were three-quarters of all audit assignments are completed without issuance of a report that could be subject to a GAGAS (or GAS) compliance review. So let’s not do that.

Instead, let’s look at total assignments completed. DCAA completed 4,727 assignments in the first six months of GFY 2018. In comparison, DCAA completed 4,634 assignments in the first six months of GFY 2017. That’s much better, isn’t it? That metric shows that auditor year-over-year productivity actually increased by two percent. Nice.

Let’s keep happy thoughts and not compare assignments completed to the first half of GFY 2010, when DCAA completed 8,293 audit assignments in the first six-month period. Because that might cool the warm feeling of accomplishment we just enjoyed. Let’s stop dwelling on ancient history and get back to the present.

Similarly, total dollars examined increased year-over-year by nearly 10 percent. That’s got to feel good, right? And questioned costs are up year-over-year as well, by nearly 18 percent. Even sustention rates are holding steady at just about 30%. Those are all good numbers and DCAA should be proud of them.

DCAA’s focus on completing 10100 “incurred cost” audits (by whatever means necessary, including closing them without actually auditing contractors’ claimed dollars) is paying off for the audit agency. We may all see a point where the ICS backlog is down to manageable levels.

It will be interesting to see what a “steady state” DCAA looks like, in a year or two. We expect that we will see increasing numbers of post-award “defective pricing” and CAS-related audits. We may even see the return of the post-award accounting system audit for major contractors, once the latest audit program is polished and released.

So—all in all, a decent report card. Sure, standards have fallen since the olden days, but haven’t they done so everywhere? Why should DCAA be exempt from the phenomenon? When you look at recent performance, the first half of GFY 2018 looks good. And that portends a solid future for the audit agency.

 

You’ve Been Acquired—Now What?

E-mail Print PDF

The exit strategy for many small businesses is to be acquired by a larger entity. The exit strategy for many businesses owned by private equity or venture capital is to be acquired by another (typically larger) entity. At bigger companies, sometimes two rivals merge (think Lockheed + Martin Marietta or Boeing + McDonnell Douglas).

It’s a big deal when two companies join together, and it’s an even bigger deal when two government contractors come together. The acquisition (or merger) day is the result of many months of detailed planning by cross-functional teams. The process involves reviews by many levels of management, and sometimes reviews by government entities are required. The number of moving pieces required to come together in order to execute a corporate acquisition is huge and it’s a big deal for everybody involved, whether target or buyer.

Yet, most acquisitions don’t achieve the promised results. One website asserts that “a KPMG study indicates that 83% of merger deals did not boost shareholder returns” but the so-called “link” to that KPMG study goes to a news site, not to KPMG, so we think the assertion needs better support. In our experience, most acquisitions don’t achieve the results promised when the deal was brought to management for review. We’re not saying it is 83% but it’s north of 50%--based solely on what we’ve experienced. Most acquisitions “fail” to deliver the promised ROI and some actually deliver negative ROI.

But we keep doing them, don’t we?

This article discusses some of what we’ve seen. This isn’t the first article on M&A activities: you can check out this one, if you’d like to. This article is going to be written from the viewpoint of the target company, the one being acquired. For the buyer, we don’t expect much is going to change; but for the target the future will be all about change and change management.

The first and most important question is how the acquired entity is going to be run. Will it be fully integrated into the ongoing structure and systems of the buyer, or will it be allowed to run as a “stand-alone” subsidiary? Until you’ve answered that question, you can’t move forward very much.

The first problem is that you probably answered the first question incorrectly.

No matter how you answered it, you probably got it wrong.

Because there is no such thing as a stand-alone operation—at least, not in our experience.

A pure stand-alone operation would not participate in any benefit plans. A pure stand-alone operation would not participate in any shared back-office services, such as payroll processing or accounts payable check-writing. A pure stand-alone operation would have its own policies and procedures, and its own legal staff, and its own HR staff. Accounting consolidation would consist of the target sending the buyer a file each month that contained the financial results, as recorded on the target’s books and records. It would be up to the buyer’s accounting department to map the file to its own books and records.

Could it all happen that way? Sure. But in our experience, never. We have never seen an acquisition or merger where the target didn’t merge—at least to some extent—with the buying entity. If nothing else, benefit plans were shared. But usually there is a lot more integration going on.

And that integration is the tricky part.

Somebody is looking at employee benefit plans, not only the medical coverage but also the retirement plans.

Somebody is looking at facility and individual security clearances.

For that matter, somebody is looking at facilities costs to see if consolidation is feasible.

Other people are looking at the indirect rate structure—at both the target and the buyer—trying to see if merging them makes sense.

Lots of other people are looking at the business systems—not just at the ERP system(s), but also at the six DFARS business systems—trying to see if merging them is more trouble than its worth.

And those activities are just the tip of the iceberg.

If you are being acquired, we recommend addressing the above issues (and all the myriad other issues) head-on, as early as possible. We recommend being forthcoming about such topics as—

  • Last year of settled indirect rates, and status of submitted but not yet settled rates.

  • Status of business systems and associated command media.

  • Status of open purchase orders (commitments) and identification of strategically sensitive suppliers.

  • Status of government furnished property.

  • Status of unbilled receivables and recent financial metrics (e.g., DSO, aged payables, etc.).

  • Recent CPARS ratings (and their implications to future contract awards).

Et cetera.

We think it’s important to approach the above subjects with the right attitude. We would recommend not being defensive and not being stuck on “this is the way we’ve always done it.” Be open to change. In fact, the buyer might implement important changes that benefit the target in ways that are not clear at the moment. Instead, approach the above subjects with a realistic “cost versus benefit” perspective. What are the risks? What will it cost to address them? What are the expected benefits? Develop an ROI for the changes, and use that ROI as a lever to pry people from their comfort zones.

Being acquired is a time of uncertainty. People are (naturally) worried about their jobs and how the buyer is going to create efficiencies. Embrace that feeling. Tackle it head-on. Develop cross-functional plans that achieve optimum outcomes for both buyer and target. If both sides don’t approach the acquisition from the perspective of achieving the optimum outcomes, then they are almost guaranteed to achieve sub-optimum outcomes.

 

Defense Industrial Capability

E-mail Print PDF

Each year the Department of Defense issues a report to Congress analyzing the defense industrial base. Here is a link to the 2017 report, released in April 2018. What does the report tell us?

Workforce

61% of the aerospace/defense workforce is over the age of 45. About half the workforce is at traditional retirement age. However, “there is incredible competition to find qualified candidates with the required skills in engineering, manufacturing, and other STEM proficiencies in the market. A&D companies are being faced with a shortage of qualified workers to meet current demands as well as needing to integrate a younger workforce with the ‘right skills, aptitude, experience, and interest to step into the jobs vacated by senior-level engineers and skilled technicians’ as they exit the workforce.” Despite those challenges, the DoD continues to put unreasonable caps on the amount of compensation contractor employees may be paid.

Sector Analysis

The report addressed 10 industrial sectors. We summarize the report into a stoplight chart, based on our interpretation of the sector analyses.

Aircraft Primes: GREEN Lower-Tiers: YELLOW

C4 Primes: GREEN Lower-Tiers: GREEN

ElectronicsPrimes: GREEN Lower-Tiers: N/A

Ground VehiclesPrimes: YELLOW Lower-Tiers: YELLOW

MaterialsPrimes: GREEN Lower-Tiers: N/A

Munitions and MissilesPrimes: RED Lower-Tiers: RED

Radar and Electronic WarfarePrimes: YELLOW Lower-Tiers: RED

ShipbuildingPrimes: GREEN Lower-Tiers: GREEN

SpacePrimes: YELLOW Lower-Tiers: YELLOW

Organic IndustryPrimes: RED Lower-Tiers: N/A

Details can be found in the report (Section 8).

S2T2

We were interested (but not surprised) to note that the Sector-by-Sector, Tier-by-Tier (S2T2) analytical framework has been dropped from the annual report. Once touted as a breakthrough analytical approach, it appears that S2T2 has been relegated to the trash heap of failed bureaucratic initiatives.

Conclusion

If this annual report were not issued, would anything change? We think not.

 

DOE Increases TINA Threshold

E-mail Print PDF

If you haven’t yet revised your command media to raise the TINA and CAS thresholds from $750,000 to $2 million, and if you haven’t yet requested that your existing contracts be modified to implement the new thresholds, then we think you are negligent and that you should get moving before the boss finds somebody else who can stay on top of regulatory changes.

Just sayin’.

On May 31, 2018, the Department of Energy released an official Class Deviation, taking advantage of the CAAC Class Deviation, to implement the increased thresholds. So now both DoD and DOE have provided pathways to increase the thresholds for (1) micropurchases, (2) requiring certified cost or pricing data from subcontractors, and (3) administering CAS on subcontracts.

As the DOE Class Deviation states, “The threshold increase excludes contracts entered into on or before June 30, 2018 [BUT] Contractors may request modifications to earlier contracts (without consideration) to use the threshold increase.”

“Without consideration.” In other words, there’s no reason not to request the modifications.

Why aren’t you taking advantage of the reduced requirements?

 

GFY 2017 DCAA Report to Congress

E-mail Print PDF

 

Dated March 31, 2018, DCAA’s annual report to Congress was released for publication on May 27, 2018. No word on why it took two months to approve release to the taxpayers, the people that DCAA ostensibly serves.

And that’s about as snarky as we want to be. Let’s try reporting the rest of the story by sticking to the facts.

Facts:

  • Headcount increased by 144 auditors; now at 4,167 auditors on staff. To address attrition, this required hiring ~400 heads.

  • Audit sustention rate (incurred cost audits) = 28.7%

  • Audit sustention rate (forward priced proposals) = 66.2%

  • Audit sustention rate (all other audits) = 42.4%

  • Incurred cost backlog now at 2,860, which DCAA estimates to be a 14.3 month backlog. Based on GFY 2017 progress, DCAA estimates that it will have eliminated the backlog completely by the close of GFY 2018. As part of closing-out incurred cost years, DCAA disposed of 3,358 contractor proposals by "memo;" while 1,901 years were closed for "other reasons"--which included contracting-out of audits by non-DoD agencies.

  • DCAA estimates that it will have eliminated the incurred cost backlog by GFY 2018, even though it is taking (on average) 808 days to complete an incurred cost audit and issue a report. But that metric is old math; in the old math scenario the clock starts ticking when the contractor’s proposal is received. Using the new math metric, it only takes DCAA 143 days from the time the audit starts to the time the audit report is issued. So: 143 days it is. That’s much faster.

Nothing more to report about the annual report.

 


Page 50 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.