CAS Board Makes More Changes to Rules
Roughly four months ago, we noted that the CAS Board had jumped back into action by adding a single word (“certified”) to the 48 CFR 9903-201-1(b)(15) list of CAS exemptions. It took the CAS Board a full seven years to make that one-word change.
Seven years.
Still, we were happy to see evidence—any evidence—that the CAS Board was moving forward. Even if the speed at which the Board was moving resembled molasses flowing over ice at the North Pole.
Now comes additional evidence that the CAS Board is continuing to move forward. Forgive us if you’ve already seen this, but we don’t think many people have.
On July 17, 2018, the CAS Board published a Federal Register notice announcing a final rule that revised the CAS exemption for contracts and subcontracts for the acquisition of commercial items. Previously, the exemption at 48 CFR 9903-201(b)(6) exempted “firm fixed-price contracts and subcontractors for the acquisition of commercial items.” The problem with that language was that government acquisition folks were awarding commercial item contracts that were other than firm fixed-price. Read literally, it was only a subset of commercial item contracts (and subcontracts) that were exempt from CAS; however, as the Board explained, that was never the intent. The Board stated—
An inconsistency has developed between the list of contract types recognized for use in acquiring commercial items set forth in paragraph (b)(6) and that commercial item exemption and contract types reflected in FAR 12.207. For example, FAR 12.207 allows the use of firmed fixed price contracts in conjunction with award fee incentives or performance or delivery incentives, known as fixed-price incentive (FPI) contracts, when the award fee or incentive is based solely on factors other than cost. However, the (b)(6) exemption does not expressly recognize FPI contracts on the enumerated list of exempt contracts. Because of this discrepancy, some commenters on a prior CAS Board rulemaking expressed concern that these types of FPI contracts might be excluded under a literal reading of the (b)(6) exemption. See 72 FR 36367.
The Board went on to state that, when read in proper context—i.e., by reading the CAS Board’s “authorizing statute at 41 U.S.C. 1502(b)(1)(C)(i) as well as the language in section 4205 of the Clinger-Cohen Act”—a reasonable person wouldn’t reach the conclusion that only a subset of commercial item awards were exempt from CAS. But some people might not be reasonable, and therefore the Board acted to clarify the (b)(6) CAS exemption.
To keep things simple, the Board decided to stop listing contract types and just refer to FAR Part 12 (Acquisition of Commercial Items). In the Board’s words: “… this final rule amends the language at 9903.201–1(b)(6) to exempt contracts and subcontracts authorized in 48 CFR 12.207 for the acquisition of commercial items.”
In other words, if the contract or subcontract is a commercial item contract as authorized by FAR 12.207, then it is exempt from CAS.
Period.
Seems pretty simple, right?
It took the CAS Board nearly six years to go from proposed rule to final rule.
Six years.
Still, it was faster than the prior regulatory action.
Perhaps that molasses is flowing a bit more quickly these days.
Capitalization and Expensing Part 1
One of the many barriers that keep commercial companies from becoming government contractors is the requirement to convert their accounting “books” from Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) to FAR and CAS-based values. In theory, GAAP and FAR/CAS are closely intertwined but, in reality, there are some treacherous chasms that must be crossed successfully in order to pass government audits; and it is those chasms that create the barriers.
Most companies that successfully cross those chasms do so through gaining knowledge and understanding of the applicable requirements. From the other side of the chasm, most companies understand that FAR Part 31 controls the allowability of costs (i.e., whether costs may be priced into cost estimates or included in invoices) whereas CAS controls the measurement, assignment, and allocation of costs. Most companies have learned that, fundamentally, GAAP applies unless a FAR or CAS requirement supersedes a GAAP requirement. FAR and CAS rules frequently supersede GAAP rules. Thus, successful government contractors must learn the FAR and CAS rules so that they understand where they apply and supersede GAAP rules, and where they do not apply, such that GAAP accounting is acceptable for use.
FAR 31.201-2(a) provides five tests for cost allowability, and one of them is that a cost must comply with CAS requirements “if applicable;” otherwise, a cost must comply with “generally accepted accounting principles and practices appropriate to the circumstances.” But that’s not all. It’s not that straightforward. For example, contractors that are exempt from CAS are still subject to CAS.
FAR 31.201-2(b) discusses that seeming contradiction. It states—
Certain cost principles in this subpart incorporate the measurement, assignment, and allocability rules of selected CAS and limit the allowability of costs to the amounts determined using the criteria in those selected standards. Only those CAS or portions of standards specifically made applicable by the cost principles in this subpart are mandatory unless the contract is CAS-covered (see Part 30). Business units that are not otherwise subject to these standards under a CAS clause are subject to the selected standards only for the purpose of determining allowability of costs on Government contracts. Including the selected standards in the cost principles does not subject the business unit to any other CAS rules and regulations. The applicability of the CAS rules and regulations is determined by the CAS clause, if any, in the contract and the requirements of the standards themselves.
Thus, even contractors who are exempt from CAS (e.g., small businesses) are subject to certain CAS requirements. If they fail to comply with those CAS requirements, the resulting costs may be determined to be unallowable (to the extent they exceed the amount of costs that would have resulted, had the CAS requirements been followed).
Clear? Let’s recap:
GAAP controls, unless it doesn’t. If there is a FAR Part 31 cost principle that addresses the cost in question, then that FAR cost principle controls. If that FAR cost principle invokes a CAS requirement as a condition of cost allowability, then the CAS requirement controls. Further, if there is any conflict between CAS and FAR requirements (which is a very rare thing), then the CAS requirements trump the FAR requirements.
Companies that have successfully crossed the chasm of converting their GAAP-based financial records to FAR/CAS-based records have learned all that.
But even so, many companies still stumble when trying to address the capitalization versus expensing decision within the government contracting environment. And that’s what we want to explore in this series of articles.
Let’s start with the basics. An expense is a current period offset, or reduction, of revenue. That’s as basic as we can get. You pay a bill, you record an expense associated with that bill payment. You had some cash (which is an asset on your balance sheet); your amount of cash was reduced (which lowered the asset value); and you recorded an expense equal to the amount that your asset (cash) was reduced. (Of course this ignores accruals and pre-paids and a whole lot of stuff, but just go with us here; we are at the most basic level.) When you expense something, you are saying that you have consumed the value of that thing. Moreover, the payment for that thing should reduce—or perhaps offset—your income (revenue) associated with that thing. Your profit is your income less your expenses, so the more expenses you have, the less profit you have. Which can sometimes be a good thing, as many tax accountants will tell you.
On the other hand, when you capitalize something, you reduce your cash balance the same way—because you are still paying for that thing. But instead of creating an expense, you create another asset, such that the value of the asset (basically) equals the amount of cash you just paid. You now have two assets, cash and the capital asset, and the assets on your balance sheet are the same as before you made the payment.
Instead of recognizing the full expense at the time of payment, you recognize an expense ratably over time. That expense is called depreciation (or sometimes amortization). You recognize depreciation as the value of the capital asset is reduced over time, through wear and tear. The reason for capitalizing and depreciating an asset is to better match the recognized expense to the revenue associated with it. This is particularly important for purchases of property and equipment, where a company may spend a very large amount up front so that it can generate a stream of revenue over time. Thus, capitalization and depreciation match that expenditure to the stream of revenue; whereas a simple expensing of the expenditure would create an imbalance. At least, that’s the theory.
Under GAAP, the decision to capitalize versus expense is often a matter of judgment—and many companies (large and small) do not always make the correct decision. Some companies simply make a mistake that needs to be corrected. But other companies deliberately decide to misstate their books. That’s not good.
For example, WorldCom. Remember those guys? WorldCom was once one of the largest phone companies in the USA. Then, in one of the “largest accounting scandals,” the company told the SEC and investors that it had made accounting “errors” that had led to its profits being overstated by $3.9 billion. (Some reports say that the company made as much as $11 billion in errors.) According to WordCom’s public statements, rental fees for communication lines had been booked as capital expenditures and put on the balance sheet, rather than being properly recorded as current period expenses. Because WorldCom avoided recording expenses, it had inflated its profits.
Here’s a link to an article on the WorldCom scandal, for those interested. We will quote from it a bit, just to give some perspective.
'The transfer of obvious expenses into capital expenditures is absolutely fraudulent. There’s no excuse for this kind of misrepresentation. Almost everyone in the industry would agree that if you’re paying a service charge to lease local lines, that’s a clear expense,' says Robert A. Howell …. Such expenses must be immediately recognized in the period incurred, unlike expenditures which can legitimately be capitalized as assets and depreciated over their useful life. WorldCom’s misrepresentation of these expenses led to an artificial inflation of its net income and EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization).
In 2005, WorldCom’s CEO, Bernie Ebbers, was sentenced to serve 25 years in Federal prison. He is still there today. The WorldCom accounting scandal was one of the drivers that led to passage of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act.
Let’s conclude on this thought: the GAAP accounting rules for expensing versus capitalization require judgment, and any mistakes can impact the bottom-line profitability of a company. It’s not easy to get it right. For government contractors, the situation is even murkier and it’s hard to safely navigate all the FAR and CAS requirements, many of which supersede the GAAP requirements. Even if contractors get the GAAP accounting right, they may well trip over the FAR/CAS accounting requirements, which we will explore in the next article.
|
Capitalization and Expensing Part 2
In the previous article we discussed basic GAAP requirements and noted that, for government contractors, GAAP applies unless it does not apply. FAR and/or CAS requirements may supersede GAAP requirements; and government contractors are required to comply with the superseding requirements at the risk of having some or all of claimed costs disallowed.
FAR requirements
In addition to the FAR Part 31 requirements we touched-on in Part 1, the FAR has more specific cost principles with which government contractors must comply. Foremost among them is 31.205-11 (Depreciation). That cost principle establishes that “Depreciation on a contractor’s plant, equipment, and other capital facilities is an allowable contract cost, subject to the limitations contained in this cost principle.” It seems that a contractor can simply comply with GAAP and the resulting depreciation would be 100% allowable. But not so fast.
Before we conclude that compliance with GAAP is sufficient, we have to look at the “limitations” found in the cost principle.
The first limitation is CAS. The cost principle states that contractors that have fully CAS-covered contracts must comply with the requirements of CAS 409 (“Depreciation of Tangible Capital Assets”). If a contractor has a fully CAS-covered contract, then CAS 409 requirements control, not GAAP requirements. However, if a contractor is subject to only modified CAS coverage, or is exempt from CAS coverage, then CAS 409 will not control. In that latter case, “allowable depreciation shall not exceed the amount used for financial accounting purposes, and shall be determined in a manner consistent with the depreciation policies and procedures followed in the same segment on non-Government business.” (Except for certain other limitations that we will touch on in a minute.)
The FAR cost principle establishes a hierarchy of compliance requirements. If a contractor is exempt from CAS (or subject only to modified CAS coverage), then it may (generally) follow GAAP with confidence, so long as it does so in a consistent manner. But if a contractor has fully CAS-covered contracts, then it has to follow the requirements of CAS 409 which, to the extent there is any conflict, supersede GAAP for purposes of government contract cost accounting and pricing.
Let’s talk about limitations that might apply to the foregoing general statement.
First, if the contractor acquires assets from the government at no cost then, regardless of the value it puts on those assets for its GAAP accounting purposes, any resulting depreciation is unallowable.
Second, once an asset has reached the end of its service life and has a net book value (NBV) of zero, then no further depreciation is allowed. However, if a government customer wants to use an asset with a zero NBV, then the contractor may charge a “reasonable” rental fee for that use. The cost principle states that “In determining the [value of the] charge, consideration shall be given to cost, total estimated useful life at the time of negotiations, effect of any increased maintenance charges or decreased efficiency due to age, and the amount of depreciation previously charged to Government contracts or subcontracts.”
Third, sale and leaseback arrangement are subject to special cost allowability rules. (See 31.205-11(g)(3) and (h)(1).)
Fourth, capital leases that are amortized over time are covered by this cost principle. Generally, the amortization charges are allowable—but see 31.205-11(h) if you are dealing with capital leases.
Fifth, in business combinations, when the value of purchased assets is changed to fair market value, “the allowable depreciation and cost of money shall be based on the capitalized asset values measured and assigned in accordance with 48 CFR 9904.404-50(d), if allocable, reasonable, and not otherwise unallowable.” For intangible assets, “allowable amortization and cost of money shall be limited to the total of the amounts that would have been allowed had the combination not taken place.”
Other FAR cost principles that are (or may be) relevant to this topic include—
-
31.205-10 (Cost of Money)
-
31.205-16 (Gains and Losses on Disposition or Impairment of Depreciable Property or Other Capital Assets)
-
31.205-26 (Material Costs)
-
31.206-36 (Rental Costs)
-
31.205-37 (Royalties and Other Costs for Use of Patents)
-
31.205-40 (Special Tooling and Special Test Equipment Costs)
-
31.205-52 (Asset Valuations Resulting from Business Combinations)
We may come back and visit one or two of the cost principles listed above, but let’s move this along and talk about CAS requirements.
CAS Requirements
As noted above, the depreciation cost principle (31.205-11) expressly invokes the requirements of CAS 409. A government contractor with fully CAS-covered contracts must comply with CAS 409 requirements; if it doesn’t then, to the extent the resulting costs exceed those that would have been recorded in accordance with CAS 409, the excess costs are unallowable.
CAS 409 (Depreciation of Tangible Capital Assets) establishes “criteria and guidance for assigning costs of tangible capital assets to cost accounting periods and for allocating such costs in cost objectives within such periods in an objective and consistent manner.” The Standard establishes four fundamental rules, as follows—
-
The depreciable cost of a tangible capital asset shall be its capitalized cost less its estimated residual value.
-
The estimated service life of a tangible capital asset (or group of assets) shall be used to determine the cost accounting periods to which the depreciable cost will be assigned.
-
The method of depreciation selected for assigning the depreciable cost of a tangible capital asset (or group of assets) to the cost accounting periods representing its estimated service life shall reflect the pattern of consumption of services over the life of the asset.
-
The gain or loss which is recognized upon disposition of a tangible capital asset shall be assigned to the cost accounting period in which the disposition occurs.
Those rules establish the capitalization value (how much) and the assignment of resulting depreciation costs to future years (when). The next set of four rules establish how the depreciation expense is to be allocated to cost objectives. They are:
-
Depreciation cost may be charged directly to cost objectives only if such charges are made on the basis of usage and only if depreciation costs of all like assets used for similar purposes are charged in the same manner.
-
Where tangible capital assets are part of, or function as, an organizational unit whose costs are charged to other cost objectives based on measurement of the services provided by the organizational unit, the depreciation cost of such assets shall be included as part of the cost of the organizational unit.
-
Depreciation costs which are not allocated in accordance with paragraph (b) (1) or (2) of this subsection, shall be included in appropriate indirect cost pools.
-
The gain or loss which is recognized upon disposition of a tangible capital asset, where material in amount, shall be allocated in the same manner as the depreciation cost of the asset has been or would have been allocated for the cost accounting period in which the disposition occurs. Where such gain or loss is not material, the amount may be included in an appropriate indirect cost pool.
In that second set of rules, we see that depreciation expense is normally an indirect expense, unless charged as a direct expense “on the basis of usage and only if depreciation costs of all like assets used for similar purposes are charged in the same manner.” Thus, a government contractor has some flexibility (within strict limits) on how to allocate depreciation expense. In addition to exercising judgment regarding whether to expense or to capitalize, judgment may also have to be exercised regarding whether to charge depreciation as a direct or indirect expense.
Further, CAS 409 recognizes that judgment and estimates are involved in the details. The Standard states “Determination of the appropriate depreciation charges involves estimates both of service life and of the likely pattern of consumption of services in the cost accounting periods included in such life.” The Standard provides guidance intended to help the contractor with those estimates.
The Standard also allows use of GAAP treatment in most cases. It states “The method of depreciation used for financial accounting purposes (or other accounting purposes where depreciation is not recorded for financial accounting purposes) shall be used for contract costing unless: (i) Such method does not reasonably reflect the expected consumption of services for the tangible capital asset (or group of assets) to which applied, or (ii) The method is unacceptable for Federal income tax purposes. If the contractors' method of depreciation used for financial accounting purposes (or other accounting purposes as provided above) does not reasonably reflect the expected consumption of services or is unacceptable for Federal income tax purposes, he shall establish a method of depreciation for contract costing which meets these criteria.” Thus, at the end of the day, it is very possible that GAAP or IRS-compliant depreciation lives may be acceptable for government cost accounting and pricing purposes.
Looking briefly at CAS 404 (Capitalization of Tangible Assets), we see that CAS establishes firm guidelines regarding the expensing versus capitalization decision. The Standard states that contractors must have a written policy that establishes the decision criteria. Contractors have some flexibility with respect to those criteria; however, “The contractor's policy shall designate a minimum service life criterion, which shall not exceed 2 years, but which may be a shorter period. The policy shall also designate a minimum acquisition cost criterion which shall not exceed $5,000, but which may be a smaller amount.” So any contractor subject to CAS 404 must capitalize tangible assets when the purchase price exceeds $5,000 and the estimated service life exceeds two years. The resulting depreciation will generally be allowable if it complies with GAAP and/or IRS regulations. The resulting depreciation is normally an indirect expense; however, in certain circumstances it may be treated as a direct contract cost.
Somewhere within The Beltway, a group of people have been meeting to see if we really need CAS 404 and 409. As noted, in many circumstances GAAP and IRS rules are perfectly fine. Section 820 of the 2017 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) required that CAS requirements “be reconciled, to the extent possible, with U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles.” See our article on that requirement here. Our backchannel tells us that those efforts are not going very well. In particular, we are hearing that the government representatives are not excited to eliminate those two Standards, despite the general agreement that they are not really necessary. As one person stated, “If we can’t reach agreement on CAS 409, there is no hope for reaching agreement on anything else.” So stay tuned for future articles on that topic.
We have now reviewed the basics. We’ve flown over the GAAP requirements at 50,000 feet and we’ve gone into FAR 31.205-11 in some detail. We’ve reviewed CAS 409 and mentioned CAS 404.
In the next and final article, we’re going to tackle the toughest challenge of all: whether the rules on capitalization and expensing--the rules we've just spent two articles discussing--really work in a government contracting environment.
Recent Regulatory Changes
We’ve been noting recent changes to the FAR and DFARS, but have held off writing about them—primarily because nothing we saw seemed earth-shattering. This article will summarize those changes. Perhaps if no one change merits an article, the aggregated changes will.
FAC 2005-99 was published June 5, 2018. The Federal Acquisition Circulars are number from the date of the last loose-leaf publication. Seems to be a bit of an antiquated approach, doesn’t it? We mean, it’s been more than a decade since the last loose-leaf FAR was published; does anybody really expect to see another one any time soon? Only the Federal government would continue to publish—and update—a loose-leaf binder of regulations in this digital age. Might want to rethink your numbering approach, FAR Secretariat. You know, join the 21st Century?
FAR Case 2017-009, containing a proposed rule to “expand special emergency procurement authorities for acquisitions of supplies or services that facilitate defense against or recovery from cyber attack, provide international disaster assistance under the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961, or support response to an emergency or major disaster under the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act” was published June 26, 2018. The comment period is still open, for those interested.
Four final DFARS rules were issued on June 29, 2018.
DFARS Case 2015-D024 impacts definitization of Undefinitized Contract Actions (UCAs). It addresses how COs should use the Weighted Guidelines to determine how much profit the contractor should be entitled to. It’s a bit of a confusing rule. On one hand it directs COs to “document their consideration of the reduced risk” for actual costs incurred during the period between UCA award and definitization. On the other hand, it directs COs to “consider the reasons for any delays in definitization in making their determination of the appropriate assigned value for contract type risk” and permits the CO to add an additional one percent profit to the contract type risk factor in the Weighted Guidelines. If you are definitizing a UCA, or have just received one and will need to definitize it, then read the new rule.
DFARS Case 2018-D030 eliminated “the DFARS clause 252.216-7010, Requirements, the Alternate clause, the associated clause prescription at DFARS 216.506, and a cross-reference to the clause at DFARS 247.271-3(p),” because they are “duplicative of an existing Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) clause.” Glad they figured that out, finally.
DFARS Case 2018-D032 eliminated “the DFARS clause 252.215-7000, Pricing Adjustments, the clause prescription at DFARS 215.408, and the associated cross-references at DFARS 208.404, 212.301, 214.201, 216.506, 225.870, and introductory text for various 252.215 clauses to adjust clause prescription references,” because they are also “duplicative of an existing Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) clause rendering the DFARS clause unnecessary.”
DFARS Case 2015-D028 finalizes (with changes) an interim rule on determining price reasonableness for indirect offset costs in an FMS transaction. (Short answer: accept the contractor’s price.) If you are involved in FMS sales and/or offset agreements, this is a rule you’ll want to review. Otherwise, pass.
On the same day, six proposed DFARS rules were published for public comment. We are not going to link to them. Google is your friend. However, we will list them. They are—
-
DFARS Case 2016-D032, Electronic Submission and Processing of Payment Requests and Receiving Reports
-
DFARS Case 2017-D010, Inapplicability of Certain Laws and Regulations to Commercial Items
-
DFARS Case 2018-D009, Only One Offer
-
DFARS Case 2018-D025, Modification of DFARS Clause Surge Option
-
DFARS Case 2017-D014, Use of Commercial or Non-Government Standards.
-
DFARS Case 2017-D005, Submission of Summary Subcontract Reports.
Some of those proposed rules are fairly interesting and have implications that may be worthy of a comment or two (e.g., “only one offer”).
In addition to the official regulatory changes noted above, there were also a couple of less formal pieces of guidance issued.
The DoD issued Class Deviation 2018-O0016 on June 26, 2018, entitled “Defense Commercial Solutions Opening Pilot Program.”
The DoD also issued Class Deviation 2018-O0017 on June 29, 2018, entitled “Determining Contract Type for FMS Contracts.”
Finally, the Director of Defense Pricing/Defense Procurement and Acquisition Policy issued a guidance memo entitled “Negotiations of Sole Source Major Systems for U.S. and U.S./FMS Combined Procurements” on June 28, 2018.
Looking over the list of regulatory changes, we see a bit of an emphasis on Foreign Military Sales. If you are a contractor that plays in that sandbox, you may want to take note.
But for the rest of us, meh. Small steps….
As always, we are deeply indebted to Bob Antonio and his WIFCON website, who tracks and publishes regulatory changes as they happen. Without him, much of this blog—and certainly this article—would simply not happen. If you are not visiting WIFCON (“Where in Federal Contracting”) on a regular basis, you are missing out on a tremendous resource.
|