Commission Hears Testimony Blaming Contractors' Internal Control Systems
 Federal Times reported on August 11, 2009 that in testimony before the Commission on Wartime Contracting, DCAA Director April Stephenson blamed "faulty accounting, cost-estimating, purchasing and other business systems" for "millions of dollars" of contractor overbillings to the Department of Defense (DOD). The Federal Times article quotes Director Stephenon's testimony: "When a contractor’s business system and related internal controls are inadequate, the data generated by the contractor’s system is unreliable, which in turn, results in the risk of noncompliances with government laws and regulations, mischarging, fraudulent acts and contract overpayments." We have previously noted the Commission's focus on contractor business systems. Thus, we were not especially surprised by Director Stephenson's testimony. What was surprising was the testimony of DCMA Executive Director David Ricci, who reportedly admitted that his agency has allowed contractors to continue using faulty and unreliable business systems. Federal Times quotes Mr. Ricci as saying, "We've not disapproved any of the systems with these contractors." (In context, it is clear that Mr. Ricci was referring to the systems of the three LOGCAP IV contractors that support troops in the battlefield, but the quote could (and likely will) be taken out of context as referring to the business systems of DOD contractors in general.) According to the Federal Times, "Ricci said that if a contractor submits an action plan to correct problems with a faulty business system, such as a cost-estimating system, DCMA cannot disapprove the system unless there is no progress made to fix the problems." Predictably, the Commissioners piled on DCMA, accusing it of "caving to the contractors and not acting properly on the Defense Department’s behalf," according to the Federal Times article, which quotes Co-Chair Shays (a former member of Congress) as accusing DCMA of being "on the contractor's side." According to Federal Times, "Other commissioners also were outraged by DCMA’s failure to halt use of faulty contractor business systems and its failure to withhold payments to them, if necessary." It is well-known that DCAA has come under fire for inadequacies in its audits. Almost immediately after being on the receiving end of intense criticism related to its alleged audit failures, DCAA began a campaign seemingly designed to deflect attention from itself and onto the contractors it audits, as well as the other DOD agency involved in contract management, DCMA. The Federal Times article indicates that the strategy may be working. It is easy to predict a continued DCAA focus on "inadequate" business systems because, so long as the spotlight is turned on the contractors, DCAA can hide in the darkness. Consequently, contractors must invest in their operational control systems in order to avoid the draconian penalties that Director Stephenson advocates. Although one can take issue with DCAA's concepts of "internal control systems" and "system adequacy" it will not be as easy to fight the unpalatable combination of an aggressive DCAA coupled with a hobbled DCMA that is unwilling to disagree with any DCAA recommendation because of the fear of being labeled as being "on the contractors' side." See the Federal Times article here.
DOD Is Too Bureaucratic to Meet Needs of Warfighter, Defense Science Board Tells SecDef
Recently DOD published the final report of the Defense Science Board (DSB) Task Force on Fulfilling Urgent Operational Needs. The DSB Task Force, chaired by Dr, Jacques Gansler, made several conclusions that are surprising for their candor. Among the Task Force's conclusions: -- The DOD is "not geared to acquire and field capabilities in a rapidly shifting threat environment." -- "Current long standing [DOD] business practices and regulations are poorly suited" to the dynamics of a rapidly shifting threat environment." -- "Today, the DOD is saddled with processes and oversight built up over decades, and managers leading them who are often rewarded for risk aversion." -- "All of DOD's acquisition needs cannot be met by the same acquisition processes." Accordingly, the DSB Task Force made several recommendations, including: -- The DOD should have two acquisition paths, one for "rapid" and "urgent" needs, and the other for "deliberate" needs. -- Rapid acquisitions should be funded separately from deliberate acquisitions. -- A new agency, the Rapid Acquisition and Fielding Agency (RAFA) should be created to oversee rapid acquisitions. The existing acquisition agency (DCMA) should focus on deliberate acquisitions. Some observations; 1. If the DSB Task Force rhetoric sounds familiar, it's likely because Dr. Gansler was Under Secretary for Defense (Acquisition, Technology & Logistics) from 1997 to 2001 and participated in a number of acquisition innovations, from implementation of the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act (FASA) to implementation of Performance-Based Payments. Under his leadership, the DOD aspired to "partner" with industry, an approach heavily criticized by others. 2. It is not clear, because the report does not seem to address the issue, how the mission and staffing of the Defense Contract Management Agency (DCMA) would be affected, should the Secretary of Defense implement the recommendations. One may assume that the DCMA would focus on administering "deliberate" acquisitions while the new agency (RAFA) focuses on the rapid acquisitions, but certainly DCMA's budget, staffing and program role would be impacted. 3. The Task Force recommendations to not address the statutory basis for many of the bureaucratic processes it criticizes. Clearly, in order to roll back the oversight and bureaucracy, one must first revise the statutes that require them. 4. Representative Henry Waxman (D-CA) spent the last 6 years criticizing the Bush administration's handling of acquisition issues in Southwest Asia. Moreover, every week the Department of Justice issues a press release reporting the indictment or plea bargain or settlement of somebody who accepted a bribe related to such acquisitions. It is far from clear how such "rapid" acquisitions would guard against such problems. See the entire DSB Task Force report here.
|
Commission on Wartime Contracting to Hold Hearings on Contractor Internal Controls
We previously reported on the Commission on Wartime Contracting's Interim report. At that time we noted the Commission--headed by Michael Thibault (former Deputy Director, DCAA) and Christopher Shays (former member of Congress, Republican)--not only lambasted DOD for its management of contractors deployed on the battlefield, but also took aim at "inadequate" contractor business systems as well as a perceived lack of accountability associated with the use of subcontractors. GovExec.com reports that the Commission will hold hearings on August 8, 2009 regarding "contractor business systems and subcontracting rules." According to GovExec.com, the Commission "found investigators had deemed half the [contractor] systems for billing and compensation inadequate and prone to unallowable costs. Panel staffers uncovered somewhat smaller problems with the [contractor] systems used for accounting, budget, electronic data processing, indirect and overhead costing, labor and purchasing." The Commission's hearing will reportedly focus on the activities of three contractors: KBR, DynCorp International, and Fluor -- each of whom were awarded a large Logistics Capability ("LOGCAP IV") contract to support warfighters in the battlefield. GovExec reports that April Stephenson (Director, DCAA), David Ricci (Director of Contract Business Operations, DCMA) and Jeff Parsons (Director of the Army Contracting Command) will also testify at the hearing. The GovExec.com story can be found here. It is ironic that, at the same time Congress and taxpayers are upset at the costs of major weapon systems, contractors are under pressure to develop expensive operational control systems that, arguably, add no real value to the warfighter. There are plenty of controls already in place to penalize contractors who knowingly or inadvertently include unallowable costs in proposals, billings and/or claims submitted to the Federal government. Adding more layers of bureaucracy would not seem to be the right answer, unless perhaps one lives inside the Beltway.
New DCAA Audit Guidance Targets Contractors' Unallowable Health Benefit Costs
Continuing a trend started in late 2008, DCAA audit guidance issued August 4, 2009 spells trouble for Government contractors. The guidance warns DCAA auditors of contractors that are "inappropriately charging" costs associated with ineligible dependents and/or spouses to the Government. The audit guidance directs that auditors should question costs associated with ineligible dependents in both forward pricing rate proposals and annual incurred cost submissions. Ineligible dependents/spouses include those that are (1) too old to receive benefits, (2) divorced or deceased, or (3) covered by another plan but did not notify the contractor of that fact. Auditors will be developing tests to assure that only spouses and dependents that are eligible for benefits in accordance with the contractor's policies are receiving benefits. The guidance notes that some contractors offer employees "grace periods" in which to report status changes, and directs that _all_ costs associated with ineligible dependents should be questioned, even if incurred during grace periods that are otherwise consistent with company policy. Contractors that offer employees such grace periods must calculate the "cost impacts" associated with their practice "even if the contractor will not seek restitution from the [ineligible] employees." Where contractors refuse to calculate those impacts, DCAA auditors are directed to "develop a reasonable estimate" of the unallowable health benefit costs and "suspend the costs until the contractor provides a cost impact and/or an audit is complete." Moreover, the audit guidance asserts that costs associated with ineligible spouses/dependents are not only unallowable, they are expressly unallowable, and thus subject to the penalty provisions of FAR 42.709. Court decisions on this matter tend to favor a contractor, basically saying that penalties should not be imposed where there are reasonable differences of opinion about the allowability of certain costs.(Ref. _General Dynamics Corp._, ASBCA No. 49372, June 2002.) That being said, it is far from clear that inclusion of costs associated with patently ineligible dependents in claimed health care expenses results from a matter of judgment or opinion. (The "grace period" issue may be subject to more judgment.) In any case, who wants to litigate the issue? There are other troubling aspects of the audit guidance: -- DCAA auditors are advised that many contractors use third-party plan administrators. When auditing health plan costs, auditors are directed that the contractor must provide "the same level of access to the third party service provider records that he or she would receive from contractor maintained records." Auditors are reminded to initiate "access to records" procedures should a contractor deny them access to the third party's records. Previous DCAA audit guidance imposes a course of action that can lead to suspended costs, for an unresolved "access to records" issue. (Ref. MRD 08-PAS-042(R) dated 12/19/2008.) -- DCAA auditors "should verify that contractors have adequate procedures to ensure payment of insurance premiums or claims are only being made related to employees and their eligible dependents." A contractor's failure to have adequate procedures in this area will treated as "an internal control deficiency in the contractor's accounting system and a CAS 405 noncompliance, if applicable." Further, inclusion of costs related to ineligible dependents/spouses in cost estimates may be teated as inadequacies in the contractor's estimating system. Previous DCAA audit guidance (MRD 08-PAS-403(R), dated 12/19/2008) directs that a single control objective failure should lead to a recommendation o system inadequacy. An inadequate estimating system is a nuisance, but an inadequate accounting system can prevent a contractor from receiving any cost-reimbursement contract. (Ref. FAR 16.301-3(a)(1).) Accordingly, a threat to the adequacy of a contractor's accounting system internal controls must be taken very seriously. Finally (as if the above was not sufficient to cause worry), the audit guidance reminds DCAA auditors that the cognizant Administrative Contracting Officer (ACO) should be "notified of any potential risks related to ineligible dependent care costs in prior fiscal years" so as to "ensure that active negotiations of open incurred cost years are put on hold until any necessary adjustments are made." In other words, an audit finding in a current year can affect the finalization of prior years' indirect cost rates, which could delay final contract close-outs and submission of final invoices. Given the foregoing, contractors should immediately review their procedures associated with verifying dependent eligibility and shore them up as appropriate. To the extent costs associated with ineligible dependents/spouses are identified, they should be treated as unallowable costs. Contractors should also consider consulting with legal counsel to determine their position regarding DCAA access to the records of any third party service providers. In cases where it is decided to grant access to those records, it may be necessary to renegotiate or even amend existing service agreements. See the troubling audit guidance here.
|