• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

Mandatory Disclosure Program, Six Months Later

E-mail Print PDF
In December 2008 the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) was revised to require contractors to report to the GSA and/or DOD Inspectors General any "credible evidence" that an employee had violated statutes or regulations related to contract fraud, bribery, acceptance of gratuities, conflicts of interest, or submission of false claims.  Failure to report can lead to suspension or debarment from Federal contracting.  In addition, the new rule established requirements for contractor ethics programs and for controls related to investigations and reporting of wrongdoing.
 
On August 27, 2009 GovExec.com carried a report on the status of the new mandatory contractor disclosure rule.  The article stated that the DOD IG has received 56 reports from contractors, but fewer than 10 of those disclosures have been referred to investigative agencies--meaning that the vast majority of them have been resolved administratively, the same as they would have been before imposition of the new rules.
 
The article quotes Lynn McCormick (manager of the new disclosure program) as saying that most of the disclosures have been related to inaccurate labor charging.  The article quotes Ms. McCormick's supervisor as saying,

"The preponderance have been related to single employee misconduct, say where someone was found not to have shown up to work or to have erroneously billed to one contract instead of another or the employee was found surfing the Internet for three or four hours a day for the last three months, or something like that.  So they have to adjust the billing in order to credit the government back for that employee's labor time."

Because of the volume of the disclosures, the DOD IG has had to add staff in order to ensure that Government stakeholders, including Department of Justice Attorneys as well as the various DOD buying agencies and contract administration offices, are properly briefed and agree to the proposed disposition of each disclosure.

In sum, the first six months seem to indicate a trend where contractors are erring on the side of caution by disclosing every small transgression, even those that would normally be handled administratively.  The IGs are receiving the disclosures and adjudicating each one through coordination with numerous Government stakeholders.  The vast majority of disclosed matters is being handled administratively, just as they would have been before the new rule took effect.  The only difference is, now the contractors are spending more to disclose the issues and DOD IG is spending more to process them.  As is often the case, the only winners seem to be the attorneys involved in the process.

 

New DCAA Audit Guidance Underscores Need for Lean Proposal Preparation Processes

E-mail Print PDF

When thinking of Lean principles (which is the common name for the principles of the Toyota Production System), most people think of single-piece manufacturing flow and continuous improvement of manufacturing processes.  Other people realize that Lean can be applied to other back-office processes such as accounting and finance.  Still others are considering how Lean can be applied to program management and supply chain management.  We’ve yet to see Lean applied to proposal preparation, even though everybody agrees that the existing processes take too long and cost too much.  Recent DCAA audit guidance that directs auditors to question (as being unsupported) subcontractor bids for which the higher-tier contractor fails to perform cost and price analysis underscore the need to apply Lean principles to the proposal preparation process—particularly with regard to managing subcontractor bids.

Performing Cost and Price Analysis on Subcontractor Proposals

FAR 15.404-3(b) requires that a prime contractor perform cost or price analysis on proposals received from prospective subcontractors in order to establish that the subcontractors’ proposed prices are reasonable in amount.  Price analysis is the process of examining and evaluating a proposed price without separating evaluating individual cost elements and proposed profit/fee amounts.  There are different price analysis techniques available; however, most involve comparison of the proposed price with another price, generally through obtaining competition.  In contrast, cost analysis is the review and evaluation of separate cost elements and proposed profit/fee in an offeror’s proposed price, and the use of judgment to determine how well the proposed costs represent what the contract costs should be, assuming reasonable economy and efficiency.  It is focused on a single bid.  Generally, this effort involves examination of “cost or pricing data” or “information other than cost or pricing data”.  “Cost or pricing data” is a term of art, defined at FAR 2.101, and indicates that the offeror is under a duty to disclose all relevant facts and verifiable data, as required by the Truth-in-Negotiation Act (TINA).  A prime contractor whose proposal is subject to TINA requirements may also have to submit its analyses of the subcontractors’ cost or pricing data as part of its cost or pricing data submission – meaning that there may be three sets of data to which it is certifying under TINA:  (1) its own cost or pricing data, (2) the subcontractors’ cost or pricing data, and (3) its analyses of the subcontractors’ cost or pricing data.  That’s quite a bit to keep track of. 

It’s also quite a bit to evaluate, assess, and certify to.  As part of the prime’s proposal process, it must determine which aspects of the work will be subcontracted (via a make-or-buy analysis), tell the subcontractors what they should propose on (and either obtain competition for price analysis or obtain sufficient data for cost analysis), determine which subcontractor proposals will be subject to TINA requirements, perform and document the required analyses, and prepare the required submissions to the Government.  That’s a lot to get done in the short proposal preparation timeframe.

Recent DCAA Guidance

On June 30, 2009 the DCAA issued audit guidance entitled “Audit Guidance on Performing Audits of Subcontract Forward Pricing Proposals.”  Much of the guidance focuses on how auditors might review subcontractor proposals before the prime contractor has completed its proposal efforts.  This aspect of the guidance is relatively benign, unless one was to take issue with DCAA’s definition of a subcontractor.  (DCAA uses the FAR Part 44 definition, which is expressly limited solely to activities covered by FAR Part 44 and thus does not apply to activities covered by FAR Part 15.)  Other aspects of the audit guidance are more troublesome.

The guidance instructs auditors to “(1) determine if the prime contractor completed the required cost or price analyses of its subcontractors and (2) review the adequacy of the prime contractor’s analyses.  For those analyses that are not completed, determine the contractor’s completion schedule.”  Importantly, the guidance directs auditors to question as being unsupported any proposed subcontractor costs for which the prime has not completed the required cost or price analysis.  According to the audit guidance,

“The contractor’s estimating system should have policies and procedures in place to conduct the required cost or price analyses and provide it to the Government negotiator prior to negotiation of the prime contract price.  If, due to time or other constraints, the prime contractor cannot complete the required analyses prior to the submission of its prime contract proposal, the prime contractor should have policies and procedures in place to ensure a plan is implemented to complete the analyses prior to the prime contract negotiation. “

In addition to questioning proposed costs, the audit guidance directs that, for those contractors that continually fail to perform cost or price analysis, a “flash” audit report should be generated documenting the estimating system deficiency.  For “major contractors,” this will lead to a “limited scope” audit to confirm the control failure.  If confirmed, the DCAA auditor is to recommend that the contractor’s estimating system should be determined to be inadequate.  Accordingly, contractors will need to focus on obtaining the necessary data from their proposed subcontractors and performing the required cost/price analyses, in order to avoid a significant amount of questioned costs and to maintain the adequacy of their estimating systems.

Commentary on the DCAA Audit Guidance

A couple of points on the DCAA audit guidance may help put it into perspective.  First, when DCAA “questions” costs, it does not mean that the costs are unallowable or that the customer will not pay them.  It does provide a strong position from which the customer can negotiate, and it means that negotiations will be harder than they otherwise would be.  It’s not a position to aim for, and it will require hard work to overcome, but it is not fatal.

Second, an inadequate estimating system is not the end of the world.  Although a good Government contractor should have at least ten adequate control systems, estimating is not as important as, say, the accounting or billing systems are.  That said, it will be difficult to be considered to be a “low risk” contractor—particularly when an ID/IQ contract will require multiple task order proposals—if the estimating system cannot be trusted.  As with the questioned costs situation, it’s not a position to aim for, and it will require hard work to overcome, but it is not fatal.

Finally, a word about TINA and the term “cost or pricing data”.  The term “cost or pricing data” is defined at FAR 2.101.  The DCAA audit guidance appears to conflate the terms “cost or price analysis” with “cost or pricing data” but they are not at all the same thing.  TINA is a disclosure requirement.  Contract actions subject to TINA (see FAR 15.403-4 and 15.403-5) need not be based on cost or pricing data; the cost or pricing data need merely to be disclosed in an organized fashion.  Moreover, the proposal itself is not cost or pricing data.  The prime’s cost or price analyses are performed on the proposal(s) submitted by the subcontractor(s), not necessarily on the subcontractors’ cost or pricing data.  It is true, however, that where the prime is subject to TINA, its subcontractor cost or price analyses become part of its cost or pricing data to be disclosed to its customer.

Lean Proposal Preparation

Many prime contractors do not have time to solicit multiple subcontractor bids and evaluate them properly during the proposal preparation process.  There is simply too much happening in to short of a timespan, and B&P budgets rarely permit the kind of robust staffing required to comply with the FAR requirements.  Given the DCAA audit guidance and potential consequences associated with a continued failure to perform subcontractor cost or price analysis, it is more important than ever to establish a process where more can be accomplished in less time and for less money.  The answer, as with most process improvement initiatives, lies with applying Lean principles to the proposal preparation process.

Lean is about avoiding waste.  Waste comes from many sources; commonly, waste in the administration process comes from the repetition of (1) prepare, (2) review, comment and return for rework, and (3) repair and resubmit.  Any time this cycle can be broken will create process efficiencies.  With respect to proposal preparation, it is important to work with subcontractors in the early stages of the proposal process to flesh out objectives, risks, and budgets.  There is no time to return subcontractors’ proposals as being inadequate, or too expensive; the program team must operate as a single team by collaborating from day one in order to get it right the first time.

Another area to address is to avoid treating the subcontract as if it was a transaction.  If viewed as a transaction, then all the process steps need to be performed for each subcontract action or for each proposal.  In contrast, treating the subcontract as part of an alliance or partnership creates opportunities to perform some process steps once and once only, and then leverage from those steps for future activity.  For example, competing precision casting shops once and then awarding a long-term subcontract to the winner, for all precision casting activity over, say, a five-year period, avoids wasteful recompetition and permits the pricing to be evaluated once and then used again and again.  Problem solved.

There is much more to say about applying Lean principles to proposal preparation processes.  The foregoing hopefully gives the reader a taste of what can be done with the right attitude and desire to streamline and improve.  The recent DCAA audit guidance clearly spells out what will happen to those contractors who do not focus on this area.

 

 

Can ALICE Save the Day?

E-mail Print PDF

"I dare say you haven't had much practice. When I was your age, I always did it for half an hour a day. Why, sometimes I've believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast.”

(Alice in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll)

 

As this fragment of a technical paper presented at an August 2009 conference points out:”Currently, propellants used for Earth to orbit and orbit-to-orbit missions are expensive. Thus, there is quite a need for new-generation propellants which can be used in the booster stage as well as possess characteristics which make them storable in Low Earth Orbit (LEO).” Recent advances in nanoscale aluminum-water combustion have led to the first reported launch of a test rocket fueled by a combination of aluminum powder and water ice, or ALICE (ALuminum/ICE). If ALICE works out as advertised, we may be hearing more about this innovative propellant.

NASAScientists have studied aluminum-water combustion since the 1960s, since “the Al-H20 reaction liberates a large amount of energy … as well as green exhaust products,” according to the paper presented to the 45th Annual AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference by a team of scientists from Pennsylvania State University and Purdue University (link above). More recently, studies have focused on aluminum combusting with frozen oxidizers, such as water ice.

AFOSROn August 25, 2009 news media carried stories reporting that a nine-foot long test rocket using the ALICE propellant “achieved a thrust of 650 pounds, accelerated to a speed of 205 MPH, and soared 1,300 feet into the sky” near Purdue University. A NASA scientist was quoted as saying that ALICE is “an environmentally-friendly propellant that can be used for flight on Earth and used in long distance space missions.” According to several reports, ALICE, when optimized, it could have a higher performance than conventional propellants. According to the U.S. Air Force Office of Scientific Research (AFOSR), “The propellant has a high burn rate and achieved a maximum thrust of 300 kg during the test.” One of the lead researchers, Dr. Steven Son, was quoted as saying, “The ALICE propellant can be improved with the addition of oxidizers and become a potential solid rocket propellant on Earth. Away from this planet, on the Moon or Mars, ALICE can be manufactured in those locations instead of being transported at a large cost."

So ALICE has promise. It may not need to be carried on deep space missions (since it can be manufactured from local materials found on the Moon or Mars, thus lowering the fuel weight and cost. It is environmentally friendly (unlike current solid rocket propellants). What’s not to like? ALICE seems to be a huge advance over current propellants. However, NASA has an unfortunate history of redirecting funds away from promising technologies in favor of large, congressionally supported programs. Let’s hope ALICE doesn’t get stood up by her patrons, and fulfills the promise of early tests.

VIDEO OF ALICE LAB TEST:

The ALICE flight-vehicle accelerated to a speed of 205 mph and reached an altitude of nearly 1,300 feet. credit: Dr. Steven F. Son, Purdue University

ALICE Rocket

 

 

 


 

Aviation Week Discusses Upcoming Workforce Challenges in A&D Industry

E-mail Print PDF

The the latest edition of AW&ST (dated August 24/31, 2009) there is a great article on workforce challenges in the A&D industry, containing enough facts to make one anxious and enough positive spin to make one hopeful.

Upcoming Troubles for the A&D Industry

We have previously discussed looming troubles for the A&D industry as the Obama administration juggles budget priorities and the Department of Defense wrestles with the fact that it has more programs underway than it can possibly fund, even without any Whitehouse-imposed cutbacks.  Recent news of layoffs at both Northrop Grumman and Lockheed Martin may be warning signs of industry reactions to program terminations, cutbacks, and delays.  AW&ST reports that "the layoffs will almost certainly continue into 2010 as backlogs decline and the impact of weak demand intensifies."  AW&ST suggests a downsizing of perhaps 10% of the A&D workforce, which is much less than the dramatic 40% cuts seen in the early nineties after the fall of the Berlin wall and the end of the Cold War.

 

Brights Spots in the Gloom

Despite the foregoing, AW&ST also reports that A&D executives have learned from some of the mistakes of the nineties, and are approaching their workforce cuts more strategically this time around.  For example, companies are taking into account the voluntary attrition rate of their "baby boomer" workers when evaluating potential reductions in force.  AW&ST noted that roughly six percent of the A&D workforce retired in 2008, which is treble the percentage of retirements in 2007.  AW&ST estimates that up to 20% of the entire A&D workforce will be retirement eligible by 2013.  Further, use of contract "job-shopper" workers has more than trebled from a year ago, from two percent to seven percent of the workforce.  These jobs will obviously be the first to go in any mass layoffs.

AW&ST also reports that the leaner workforces of the new millennium mean there are fewer heads to cut.  Comparing 2008 to 1990 (and adjusting for inflation), AW&ST says that sales are down six percent (according to Aerospace Industries Association data)--but A&D employment has declined by 40% in the same period, meaning that workers today are much more productive than 20 years ago.

In sum, the near-term future for the A&D industry is not rosy.  Challenges lay ahead.  On the other hand, A&D companies today have their previous experiences to learn from, and they seem better positioned to deal with the upcoming challenges than before.  A&D workers, take note.
 

DOD to Contractors in the Battlefield: You'll Be Paid When We Get Around to It

E-mail Print PDF
The Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR), at Part 32.9, implements the Prompt Payment Act of 1982 (Public Law 97-177), which was enacted to "require Federal agencies to pay their bills on a timely basis, to pay interest penalties when payments are made late, and to take discounts only when payments are made by the discount date."  The purpose of the Act, and its implementing regulations in the FAR, was to protect contractors from a government bureaucracy that was notoriously slow to pay, and from the cash flow hardships caused by such slow payments.  These contractors, who generally must follow all direction given to them by authorized government representatives, and who generally must continue to perform their government contracts regardless of any losses they may be incurring, had little if any recourse available to them for such contract breaches, short of litigation.  But under the Prompt Payment Act, contractors could typically expect to receive payment for properly prepared invoices within 30 days (often sooner), or else receive an additional interest payment automatically--i.e., without making another request.  Such robust protection is one reason that interest on financing, as well as bad debt expense, are considered "unallowable costs" under government regulations.  Contractors shouldn't need to incur such expenses because the Federal government is such a good customer with respect to making on-time payments, so they can't claim the costs on proposals, invoices, or claims.

But no longer.

On August 19, 2009 the Director of Defense Procurement and Acquisition Policy (Mr. Shay Assad) promulgated a memorandum to all military services that implemented a "class deviation" from the requirements of FAR Part 32.9 with respect to contractors involved in "emergencies ... military contingency operations ... and the release or threatened release of hazardous substances. ..."  In that memo, which can be found here, Mr. Assad stated that the Department of Defense would no longer be bound by the promise to pay a contractor within 30 days of receipt of a proper invoice, or to automatically add an interest payment when due dates were inadvertently missed, for any payment that is "either certified for payment in an operational area, or ... contingent upon receipt of necessary supporting documentation (i.e., contract, invoice, receiving report) emanating from an operational area."  His rationale for exempting these actions from the requirements of the Prompt Payment Act is that "It is clear that ... the operational area can be so fluid and dynamic that carrying out normal business practices can be extremely challenging [and] this deviation will provide the [Defense] Department with needed flexibility in limited circumstances."

What a shame.

Mr. Assad is discussing the very contractors deployed on the battlefields of Southwest Asia and elsewhere, the contractors supporting recovery operations in New Orleans and elsewhere, and the contractors who respond to terrorist attacks and accidental spills of hazardous substances.  He is saying that the companies of these brave and dedicated individuals, who often risk their lives along with the military servicemen and women they support, cannot be assured of timely payment from the U.S. Government.  Although those companies still need to make their payroll each pay period, and fly personnel to and from operations, and purchase supplies and equipment (and pay their suppliers on time), they should not expect timely payment from their Government customers.

The Commission on Wartime Contracting has blasted LOGCAP IV contractors and their business systems. It seems patently unfair for the DOD to forgive itself its inadequate business systems while pointing the finger at the contractors' business systems.  Moreover, if you wanted to disincentivize contractors from supporting contingency and emergency operations, if you wanted to severely limit competition to the few biggest companies who might have the resources to take this cash flow hit, while keeping smaller (more agile and potentially more responsive) companies out of the bid process ... well, this would seem to be an outstanding way of doing so.
 


Page 272 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.