Researching DFARS
Most of us would agree that the FAR is hard enough. But sometimes you have to go into the DFARS; and it turns out that is harder than it needs to be.
Recently I team-taught a class in England that was, essentially, an introduction to the FAR and the DFARS. A company had received multiple subcontracts from various US prime contractors, each of which contained a lengthy list of FAR and DFARS clauses—most of which had been incorporated by reference. Meaning that there was a clause number and a clause title and a date. And that was it.
An important exercise was looking up the clauses and their prescriptions. (For those who don’t know, the prescription tells the contracting officer when the clause is to be incorporated into a contract.) We also looked at the clauses themselves in order to identify whether the clause was a mandatory flow-down and, if so, then under what circumstances.
We taught the class that some DFARS clauses implemented a FAR clause while other DFARS clauses supplemented a FAR clause. (For your information, an implementation augments the FAR rule while a supplementation adds additional stuff not found in the FAR.) There are specific conventions that identify implementing clauses versus supplementing clauses, but you’re already bored so we’re moving on now.
In short, there was a lot of moving back and forth between the FAR and the DFARS, so as to see whether the FAR clause controlled, or if it had been modified somehow by the DFARS.
How did we do that? We did it electronically, using various websites.
Now, you might think that only one website would be necessary. Effective 30 September 2019, “Acquisition professionals and vendors will … have a single website to access and search the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) and supplemental regulations.” And that website is www.acquisition.gov.
If you go to that site, on the very top of the page is a button marked “Regulations,” and clicking that button brings up all the various government acquisition regulations, from the FAR to the DFARS and even the military service supplements. The list of acronyms is amazing! Do you know what the DOLARS is? What about the LIFAR? Or the NRCAR? You get the picture.
Thus, if the site is to be believed, it’s a one-stop shop and one need go nowhere else. Yet we hardly used it.
Sure, as far as FAR research went, it was fine. But when navigating the DFARS, the site was lacking. It just didn’t work. The links between the DFARS clauses and their prescriptions didn’t. Or at least, they didn’t (link) consistently. The lack of effectiveness of the DFARS section of www.acquisition.com made me long for the days of farsite at hill.afb.org. That website worked and it was easy to navigate. But sadly, it’s no longer in existence.
So what did we do instead? We used the electronic Code of Federal Regulations website at www.ecfr.gov. Once you know that the FAR is Title 48 of the CFR and that the DFARS is Chapter 2 of Title 48, then you’re good to go. And the eCFR has really cool search features that turned out to be really useful.
We needed strong search features because of this little ditty buried in the DFARS clause 252.244-7000 (“Subcontracts for Commercial Items,” June 2013). That clause states:
-
The Contractor is not required to flow down the terms of any Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement (DFARS) clause in subcontracts for commercial items at any tier under this contract, unless so specified in the particular clause.
What does that mean? It means that the only DFARS clauses that are mandatory flow-downs for subcontracts for commercial items are those clauses that expressly require flow-downs to subcontracts for commercial items. Let me give you an example. Suppose a clause states “Contractor must flow this clause down to all subcontracts.” That clause would not be a mandatory flow-down to a subcontract for commercial items because it does not expressly say “… all subcontracts, including those for commercial items.”
That’s right. “All” does not mean “all.”
Right. That blew my mind as well. But there you go.
I know, you’re thinking I’m crazy. Here’s an example of what I’m talking about. If you look at the DFARS clause 252.229-7014 “(Taxes-Foreign Contracts in Afghanistan,” December 2015) you see this clear direction to contractors that have received contracts that incorporate that particular clause: “(e) The Contractor shall include the substance of this clause, including this paragraph (e), in all subcontracts, including subcontracts for commercial items.” (Emphasis added.) If you see that direction, then you know the clause is a mandatory flow-down for subcontracts for commercial items. If you don’t see that, then the clause is not a mandatory flow-down.
If you think this is crazy hard (and you should), you should have seen the faces of the British folks we were training. (It took a couple of days, but they all got it in the end.)
Fortunately, we had the eCFR site so we could search for the clauses that needed to be flowed-down. Because if we had relied on the www.acquisition.gov site for the training, it would have been impossible.
DCAA Statistics
As we come to the end of 2019, I first wanted to thank readers for their patience. This has not been the most productive year as far as blog posts are concerned. In fact, it’s been the least productive in the 10 years the blog has been active. That’s not to say that we haven’t been productive in other areas, but focus on those other areas has meant that blog output has suffered. So thank you for hanging in there.
Now: to the blog post.
Over the past 10 years, the most popular articles have always been about the Defense Contract Audit Agency. Many people seem to be interested in what we have to say about DCAA. Contractors, contracting officers, and even DCAA auditors themselves seem to want to learn more about our thoughts on what DCAA is up to and how the audit agency is doing.
From time to time, we publish DCAA statistics. You can see the statistics manifested in the previous two blog posts. Where do those statistics come from? They come from official government publications—primarily the Department of Defense Office of Inspector General’s Semi-Annual Report to Congress, and from DCAA’s own Annual Report to Congress. We have been tracking audit-related statistics for many years and now have 13 years’ worth, which makes for interesting trend analysis.
Let’s look at those trends.
First, audit reports. Audit reports mean that contractors have to respond. Audit reports mean that contracting officers have to disposition and decide whether or not to sustain. Audit reports can lead to disputes and litigation. The following chart shows audit reports by type by year.

An interesting thing happened circa 2010. DCAA started tracking a metric called “assignment completed”—which meant that a certain number of assignments were completed without issuing an audit report. Typically, those assignments were closed via a Memorandum (either to the contracting officer or to the DCAA’s files). A completed assignment is what you get when DCAA chooses not to audit your proposal to establish final billing rates (aka incurred cost submission). A completed assignment is what you get when there are no findings and the exit conference is via telephone. As a rule, contractors like completed assignments with no audit report. So do DCAA auditors, as it means it’s harder to find GAGAS violations. We’re sure it was a coincidence that DCAA starting moving to the “completed assignment” metric at about the same time the audit agency was coming under heavy criticism for GAGAS violations.
The following chart shows the percentage of assignments completed without an audit report since DCAA started tracking that metric.

As you can see from the chart above, in GFY 2019 nearly three-quarters (74%) of all DCAA assignments were completed without issuance of a formal audit report.
Another interesting metric is the value of dollars examined by DCAA auditors each year. The following chart compares dollars examined against staff years. We don’t have GFY 2019 staffing yet (it’s typically published in March of the following year) so the chart tracks only through 2018.

The chart above shows that DCAA was at its most productive in 2008, when about $113 million was examined per auditor (or per audit staff year, depending on what data was being reported). On the other hand, that focus on productivity was blamed for audit quality failures. (There was no evidence showing that was the case, mind you. But that’s what people said and that’s what Congress glommed on to.) Consequently, audit productivity fell as the agency focused on quality. (Which tended to manifest as a lot of management reviews.) According to DoD OIG reports, audit quality did not significantly increase as the result of the focus on process instead of productivity. Nonetheless, the data indicate a dramatic loss of productivity.
At about the same time, audit staff headcount (or staff years) started to vary. GFY 2018 audit headcount is about 10 percent below the highs reflect in 2010 and then again in 2014. (Again, the data is a bit fuzzy because sometimes it’s reported as headcount and other times as staff audit years, which we assume includes audit hours performed on overtime. But you get the picture.)
It is only recently – GFY 2018 – that auditor productivity has returned to 2008 levels. In GFY 2018, auditors were examining about $99 million per head. Since we don’t have GFY 2019 staffing levels, we can’t conclude anything, but we can state that total dollars examined in GFY 2019 was lower than in 2018 ($365M vs. $410M). Consequently, unless headcount dropped significantly, it seems likely that GFY 2019 productivity will be below GFY 2018 levels.
What does this all mean?
Well, it may mean nothing. Or it may mean that DCAA’s strategy of completing assignments without issuing an audit report (but counting those assignments as dollars examined) may lead to a perception of increased auditor productivity.
Thus, as Apogee Consulting, Inc., blog productivity has declined in recent years, it appears that DCAA’s audit productivity is on the increase. Maybe our strategy should change to align with DCAA’s strategy? If so, then we will start posting blogs with no content and then claiming a completed blog post.
Yeah, that’s the ticket.
|
Good-Bye 2019, We Hardly Knew Ye
Last blog post for the year, and what a year it’s been.
There were eight Federal Acquisition Circulars (FACs) published. They included both proposed and final rules. In addition, there were several proposed and/or final FAR revisions published outside of the official FACs. Looking back, not many of the rules—whether proposed or interim or final—seemed especially significant. The definition of “commercial item” was expanded. The prohibition on obtaining certified cost or pricing data was restricted (but not for all agencies). Procurement of telecommunications equipment from Huawei Technologies Company or ZTE Corporation was prohibited. In summary, not a particularly eventful year.
DCAA published three Memoranda for Regional Directors (MRDs), continuing its unfortunate trend of hiding a lot of its audit guidance behind agency firewalls. However, what was published contained potentially significant changes to how DCAA uses materiality in its audits of contractor final billing rate proposals (aka incurred cost submissions). In addition, DCAA continued to build its “Selected Areas of Cost Guidebook” (which replaced what used to be Chapter 7 of the Contract Audit Manual); and DCAA also revised quite a few of its audit programs—most notably the 11070 audit program for performing Accounting System audits. Thus, it’s not fair to judge DCAA solely on its output of MRDs; one should strive to look at the total output.
Speaking of DCAA output, we’ve devoted a few recent blog articles to discussing DCAA productivity. In Government Fiscal Year 2019 (which ended 30 September 2019), the audit agency examined $365.2 billion using procedures that resulted in a GAGAS-compliance audit report. If we subtract out audit reports related to audits of contractor proposals, that figure drops to $246.3 billion. (Since the audit agency only issued audit reports in 26 percent of the assignments it completed, we can infer that roughly $950 billion was examined in non-proposal audits, in total).
Of the $246.3 billion that was reported upon, about $1.94 billion was questioned in an audit report (a figure that excludes “funds put to better use,” which is how DCAA reports findings related to proposal audits). Thus, DCAA questioned less than one percent of all dollars examined.
How did Apogee Consulting, Inc. fare in 2019? Let’s recap.
-
51 blog articles published (counting this one)
-
2 textbooks edited for ThompsonWest/LexisNexis
-
1 six-week adult education class created and taught
-
1 presentation for the Society of Corporate Ethics and Compliance
-
1 presentation for the Association of Government Accountants
-
1 presentation for the National Contract Management Association
-
Participated in roundtable discussion at the Rocky Mountain Compliance Conference
-
Participated in roundtable discussion at the BDO/Deltek Government Contracting Seminar in San Diego
-
1 article drafted for publication (will be submitted in January)
-
Testified in an arbitration proceeding
Thus, while blog article production fell precipitously, we made up for it in other areas.
Looking forward to 2020, we know we will be editing the two textbooks again. We have submitted a proposal to SCCE for another presentation. We expect to teach at SDSU once again. Our first 2020 engagement starts January 6th, and we hope to start another major project in late January/early February. We predict 2020 will be another busy year.
Here’s hoping your 2020 is as rewarding as we expect ours to be.
Business System Stuff
It seems that everybody is talking about business system audits/reviews these days. (For the record, DCAA performs audits and DCMA performs reviews.) Now that DCAA has “caught up” with its backlog of audits of proposed final billing rates, it has reportedly turned its attention back to the more traditional audit areas: Cost Accounting Standards, defective pricing, and business systems. Thus, many people will tell you that your risk in those areas has increased.
But it hasn’t. Not really.
DCAA has always performed some level of CAS, defective pricing, and business system reviews. And DCMA has never stopped performing those reviews. So your company’s risk has always been there, though of course DCAA’s recent strategic changes increase the likelihood that your company will be the recipient of one of those reviews.
What is DCAA doing differently?
Two main things: (1) creation of Headquarters “Truth in Negotiations” audit teams that do nothing but defective pricing audits, and (2) creation of Regional Business System teams that do nothing but audits of Accounting, MMAS, and Estimating Systems.
It’s too early to see the results of those changes but, anecdotally, we know that audits are on the increase. Further, as DCAA does not track its business systems audits separately from its other audits, the official statistics don’t tell the whole story. But we do have statistics on defective pricing and CAS audits:


As the charts above illustrate, it won’t take much of an increase to (say) double or even triple the number of reports that DCAA will be issuing.
Back to Business Systems. While there are not statistics we can find regarding the number of audits/reviews performed, we did find some statistics about system status. What we came across was dated 01 November 2019 – about six weeks ago as this is being written.
As of that date:
-
There were 30 Accounting Systems that had been officially found to be inadequate out of 3,751 evaluated
-
There were 3 MMAS that had been officially found to be inadequate out of 313 evaluated
-
There were 38 Estimating Systems that had been found to be inadequate out of 709 evaluated
Looking just at those three Business Systems (which are the ones that DCAA takes the lead in auditing) we can see that the Estimating System audits are the riskiest. Obviously, the Accounting System audits are the most important; but you are more likely to suffer an Estimating System disapproval. The statistics indicate that you have less than a one percent chance of having your Accounting System found to be inadequate but you have a greater than five percent change of having your Estimating System found to be inadequate. All other things being equal, of course.
A similar analysis on the DCMA-led Business Systems indicates that Purchasing is the riskiest. Forty-six Purchasing Systems have been found to be inadequate out of 876 reviewed; meaning that you have about a five percent chance of having your system found to be inadequate when DCMA performs a review. Both EVMS and Property Systems have a less than one percent inadequate-to-evaluated ratio.
That doesn’t mean you can relax and focus only on your Estimating and Purchasing Systems; but it does tend to indicate that those systems fail reviews at a much higher rate than the others.
What should you be doing about the situation?
We recently spoke at a compliance conference and offered this advice
-
Review your contracts and identify which contracts have which business system DFARS clauses
-
If you have any contracts with both an individual business system clause AND the DFARS general Business System clause (525.242-7005) then your company is subject to payment withholds when a business system is found to be inadequate.
-
For each business system you are required to maintain in an acceptable manner (as defined by the individual business system clause), you need to develop a compliance strategy. The compliance strategy should include:
-
Clear delineation of roles and responsibilities. Who is the individual who is responsible and accountable for the adequacy of the business system?
-
Ensuring that a system description exists and that is it current and complete
-
Ensuring that system policies, procedures, and instructions are well-documented
-
Development of a self-governance approach, including transaction testing to provide assurance that employees are complying with expectations
-
Many companies perform mock audits in preparation for an official government audit/review. For companies that lack resources, an outside firm is often hired.
The above steps can be performed by companies of any size. The same approach can be taken with respect to CAS and defective pricing audits—i.e., first identify the contracts that have the clauses and then figure out how you will comply with the clauses’ requirements.
This approach won’t guarantee that you will pass a government audit/review, but it will increase your chances of doing so.
|