Thinking Cyber—Threats, Security, Testing
We’ve
posted about this before but you need to hear it again. The next big
war between nation states probably won’t be fought using tanks and
planes; it will probably be fought in cyberspace. The war could be
over before a single shot is fired, with the winner being the first to
shut down the other side’s electrical and information grids. The
soldiers of the next war are in training now. And the United States is
way behind other nations in training and equipping its cybersoldiers.
In this article, we told you about French Rafale fighters being grounded because the Conflicker
worm invaded the French Navy’s mission planning system via an infected
thumb drive, and we reported that the British Ministry of Defense and
its aircraft carrier HMS Ark
Royal were similarly attacked by computer viruses. In response to
pervasive cyber threats, in June 2009 the Pentagon established USCYBERCOM as a subordinate unified command under the U.S. Strategic Command.
"My
own view is that the only way to counteract both criminal and espionage
activity online is to be proactive. If the US is taking a formal
approach to this, then that has to be a good thing. The Chinese are
viewed as the source of a great many attacks on western infrastructure
and just recently, the US electrical grid. If that is determined to be
an organized attack, I would want to go and take down the source of
those attacks." – Lt. Gen. Keith Alexander, nominated USCYBERCOM Commander, May 2009 (quoted here)
In another article, we told you about
the U.S. Cyber Challenge, where children as young as high-school age
are invited to participate in “contests” (that look an awful like
training exercises) in which their nascent skills in cyber attack and
defense are “nurtured and developed”. Those participants who stand out
from the rest will be offered grants, scholarships, advanced training,
and/or full-time employment, in order to become full-fledged
“cyber-security practitioners, researchers, and warriors.” We noted
that the impetus for this effort was the fact that the U.S. had
belatedly recognized how far behind China it had fallen in this area.
More recently, media outlets
carried reports of China’s apparent involvement in a sophisticated
attack on Google, in which “the e-mail accounts of several Chinese
human rights activists had been compromised.” This Reuters article discusses China’s Hong Ke (Red Visitors) and
quotes a blogger as saying, “China may not be where the U.S. is
militarily, but it clearly has invested a lot of brainpower in
developing capabilities that can offset the U.S. advantage in
force-on-force conflict.”
The foregoing is but a bit of background to the discussion of the Comprehensive National Cyber Security Initiative, the Department of Homeland Security’s National Cyber Security Center, and DARPA’s National Cyber Range. It is in these arenas that the United States is developing its offensive and defensive doctrines for fighting the next war.
The Comprehensive National Cyber Security Initiative (CNCI)
dates back to 2008, when then-President George W. Bush issued National
Security Presidential Directive 54 to improve how the Federal
government protects sensitive information from hackers and nation
states trying to break into agency networks. Much of the details
surrounding CNCI are classified, but reports indicate that its
multi-year budget may be as much as $40 billion.
Apparently, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is the lead CNCI agency. Reports assert that DHS uses an automated system known as Einstein
to collect security information, such as notifications of intrusions
via sensors deployed in agencies’ networks, and reporting that
information to the U.S. Computer Emergency Readiness Team (US-CERT).
In addition, one article reported that “Defense and intelligence
agencies were assigned an operational role, particularly for computer
systems and networks deemed more sensitive to national security. Those
agencies were expected to focus on counterterrorism efforts.”
The National Cyber Security Center (NCSC) is tasked with protecting the Federal government’s communication networks from domestic and foreign threats. After a rough start in which the NCSC head quit over allegations of undue influence by the National Security Agency (NSA), the NCSC has lowered its profile under the direction of long-time Microsoft Executive Phil Reitinger. In a rare interview posted on Govinfosecurity.com, Mr. Reitinger let drop some tidbits about the NCSC. He said, “I was talking before about the National Cybersecurity Division, which is part of cybersecurity communications. The National Cybersecurity
Center is an even smaller group that will be growing form perhaps
somewhere in the neighborhood of five people to perhaps 25 by the end
of the year, so it is going to be much more than doubling but it is a
smaller group of people.”
Finally, let’s discuss DARPA’s National Cyber Range (NCR). According to the DARPA press release:
“The goal of the NCR program is to revolutionize the state of the art
of the Nation’s cyber testing technology, and develop a computer
systems test bed on which cyber scenarios can be evaluated
simultaneously to provide a comprehensive, qualitative and quantitative
assessment of the security of information and automated control systems
that are under development.” DARPA’s vision for the NCR is to
“simulate the entire internet, allowing soldiers to drill in virtual
simulations ranging from a small scale computer virus to a World War
III-sized conflict,” according to this article.
Northrop Grumman won the Phase I concept design work, but contracts for
Phase II efforts, which include building and evaluating “prototype
ranges and their corresponding technology,” were awarded to John
Hopkins University-Applied Physics Laboratory and to Lockheed Martin.
While Aviation Week & Space Technology magazine is excited about the Next Generation Jammer (NGJ),
focusing on new techniques in Electronic Attack and Electronic Warfare,
the real future of warfare is already taking shape behind computer
screens and in large-scale testbeds
and laboratories. For example, the January 18, 2010 edition of
AW&ST describes that the future of electronic attack weapons as
including “a magazine filled with electron pulses, information
scrambling data streams and invasive algorithms.” That may well be
true, but if the planes that carry the NGJ and its science fiction
weapons can’t take off because the military command and control
structure has been hacked from abroad, or if the mission planning and
guidance maps have been altered via undetected intrusion, then those
weapons will avail us very little. Instead, AW&ST might want to
think about getting excited about cyber.
The Post-1998 Defense Spending Surge: Can We Do More with More?
On January 18, 2010, Defense-Aerospace.com carried an interesting story, which was really a lead into an analysis of Defense spending over the past decade by the organization, Project on Defense Alternatives (PDA), which is policy think-tank associated with The Commonwealth Institute. The PDA report, entitled “An Undisciplined Defense Understanding the $2 Trillion Surge in US Defense Spending,” is a copyrighted report. Because it’s copyrighted, we’ll avoid too much cut-and-pasting, and stay within “fair use” limits—even though the entire report can be downloaded from here.
Why
consider an analysis from some policy wonk that may well have a
political axe to grind? Well, for starters, every forecast of
near-term defense spending seems to point to a flat—or even
declining—budget, which has obvious implications for Defense
contractors. We’ve posted a number of articles on the tightening
budgetary environment (for example, here),
but this report struck us as exceedingly (almost painfully) detailed.
Detail is good. Detail creates credibility. So even if the author is
biased—and we have no reason to suspect he is—the detail in the report
is worth examining.
The Defense-Aerospace.com story notes that, in 1998, DOD’s budget was $361.5 billion. (Note: all values in this article are 2010 equivalent US Dollars—i.e., adjusted for inflation. We’ll omit references to 2010 equivalency in our quotes.) As the article reports, “If
we treat the 1998 budget level as a “baseline” and project it forward
to 2010 (adjusting for inflation), we find that the total amount of
funds that have been given to DoD above this level during the years 1999-2010 is $2.15 trillion.” The article continues—
The
rebound in annual defense spending reached its recent peak in 2008:
$696.5 billion – which is 92.7% above the 1998 level. The portion
unrelated to contingency operations (the so-called ‘base’ budget) was $503 billion that year – which is 41% higher in real terms than in 1998. Total DoD
budget authority receded slightly in 2009 and 2010. But it now seems
likely that 2011 will set a new high – somewhat over $700 billion in DoD’s authority to spend.
In other words, current Defense budget levels are nearly double
what they were a decade ago, even after adjusting for inflation.
Ignore the reasons why that is for a moment, and dwell on the fact that
the Pentagon is currently spending at twice the rate it was ten years
ago. And for giggles, remember that it is spending at these levels
while having cut back significantly on DCMA contracting officers,
Contracting Officer Technical Representatives, Quality Assurance
Specialists, and DCAA auditors. It is any wonder DOD program execution
is under fire?
The article (and the PDA report) uses that historical perspective to assess the near term Defense budget horizon. As the article reports—
Looking forward, the Obama administration’s 2010 budget plan allocates an average of $545 billion per year to the DoD
base budget for 2011-2017. In addition, it set aside a “place keeper”
sum of $50 billion per year for military operations, recognizing that
actual war costs will vary. (And, indeed, the Pentagon already is
expected to request at least $163 billion for contingency operations in
2011.) … All told, the Obama administration plans to spend at least $5
trillion (2010 USD) on defense during 2010-2017, which is 5% more in
real terms than the Bush administration authorized for 2002-2009.
If Obama
Defense spending is reaching a plateau, that plateau is at least 5
percent higher than recent history in inflation-adjusted dollars. So
where is the budget squeeze coming from? The PDA report suggests
that one source is the sheer expense of the current war. As
Aerospace-Defense.com reports, “Measured in 2010 dollars, the Korean
conflict cost $393,000 per person/year invested; the Vietnam conflict
cost $256,000; and the Iraq and Afghanistan commitments, $792,000 so
far.”
Another metric reported in the PDA analysis is DOD spending per uniformed service member. According to the analysis, “For
2007-2010, [DOD budget authority] averaged $459,000 per full-time
person in uniform. This is 78% higher than the Reagan peak, 95% higher
than in 1989, and nearly three times the inflation-adjusted peak during
the Vietnam era.” In addition, “During the 20-year period 1981-2000,
budget authority for personnel varied by only a few percent around an
average of $73,200 (2010 USD) per person.
It then rose by 46% between 2000 and 2010. The increase was enough to
bring total personnel expenditures back up to Cold War levels – for a
military only 69% as large.”
The
report discusses a number of other factors that drive Defense budgetary
spending, from the all-volunteer force to the increasing reliance on
contractors to support operations. As the report notes, “between 1989 and 2005, the pool of DoD contract labor has grown more than the pool of uniform and civilian employees has declined.”
To
conclude, this seems to us to be a worthwhile analysis that provides
good insight into how the Defense budget got to where it is today, and
also provides some clues regarding where it may be going in the
future. We encourage interested readers to read it in detail.
|
Obama Administration: Tax Scofflaws Cannot Receive Government Contracts

Since
at least 2004, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) has issued
reports finding that “thousands of federal contractors, tax exempt entities,
and Medicare providers” receive funds from the Federal government while
owing overdue Federal taxes. According to the various GAO reports, the
primary area of delinquency was in the timely remittance of payroll taxes. (For example, see this GAO report.) And according to this GAO report—
Our
analysis of data provided by CMS and IRS indicates that over 27,000
health care providers (i.e., about 6 percent of all such providers)
paid under Medicare during calendar year 2006 had payroll and other
agreed-to federal tax debts totaling over $2 billion. The $2 billion in
unpaid tax debts only includes those debts reported on a tax return or
assessed by IRS through its enforcement programs. This $2 billion
figure is understated because some of these Medicare providers owed
taxes under separate tax identification numbers (TIN) from the TINs
that received the Medicare payments or they did not file their tax
returns.
In another
report, GAO asserted that “Eighty-three of the 100 largest publicly
traded U.S. corporations in terms of 2007 revenue reported having
subsidiaries in jurisdictions listed as tax havens or financial privacy
jurisdictions. Sixty-three of the 100 largest publicly traded U.S.
federal contractors in terms of fiscal year 2007 federal contract
obligations reported having subsidiaries in such jurisdictions.” GAO estimated that “more than $5 billion in unpaid taxes” are owed the government from its contractors.
Needless
to say, Congress was not pleased to learn that Executive Branch
agencies were paying contractors good money while, at the same time,
those contractors were scheming to illegally avoid, delay, or underpay
required taxes. In response to the series of GAO reports, the FAR was revised
in 2008 to address tax delinquency as a matter of contractor
responsibility as well as a cause for suspension/debarment. (See the
solicitation provision at 52.209-5 for non-commercial acquisitions and
at 52.212-3 for commercial item acquisitions.)
Effective with that FAR revision, a contractor can be suspended or
debarred for “delinquent taxes” in amounts as little as $3,000. (The
definition of “delinquent taxes” is found in the regulations.)
In
addition to the action above, in 2006 the Tax Increase Prevention and
Reconciliation Act (P.L. 109-222) required Federal, State, and local
government entities to withhold 3 percent when making payments to
contractors, to cover the delinquent income taxes owed by them. (Note
that the delinquent area was payroll taxes, not income taxes, but apparently that was too hard for Congress to deal with.) See the proposed rule for more details. As currently amended,
the rule is scheduled to go into effect January 1, 2012, negatively
impacting prime contractors’ cash flow. (Note the rule does not affect
prime contractors’ payments to their subcontractors.)
Critics
of the tax withhold point out that the 3 percent decrement would be
applied to the bottom line of the invoice amount, not to profit, which
means that—in some circumstances—contractors would not be receiving
sufficient payments to cover incurred costs. For construction
contractors, the impact to cash flow may lead to higher bonding costs.
However onerous they may appear to be, the foregoing actions did not satisfy the Obama Administration. On January 20, 2010 a Presidential Memorandum was issued to the heads of all Executive Branch departments and agencies, directing
the Commission of Internal Revenue “to conduct a review of
certifications of non-delinquency in taxes” and to report on the
accuracy of those certifications. In addition,
the Memorandum directed the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), in
conjunction with other Cabinet officials, to “evaluate practices of
contracting officers and debarring officials” and to recommend process
improvements designed to ensure that contractors owing taxes “are not
awarded new contracts.”
Among
the improvement ideas is the intention to “make contractor
certifications available in a Government-wide database”—though it is
not immediately clear how creating such a database will help to ensure
that contracting officers don’t award contracts to entities that are
delinquent in paying their tax bills.
If
we are forced to opine on this issue, we would say that the problem
here is a lack of training and/or discipline by the Government
contracting officers. They need to review the certifications executed
by contractors, and make sure that the FAR is followed with respect to
the information disclosed on the certs. Moreover, there are already plenty of teeth in the law, which could be applied to any entity that knowingly falsifies a certification. For example, a violation of the False Statements Act (18 U.S.C. 1001) can lead to a fine and up to 5 years in prison.
So
it’s a bit of a mystery why the Obama Administration thinks the Memo is
going to do what the FAR rules cannot. In any case, this is an area
that continues to be a sore spot with Congress and, about two years from
now, is going to be a sore spot with contractors, when they see their
cash flow decremented by 3 percent.
Praise the Lord, and Pass the Ammunition
It’s
no secret that some companies put “hidden” biblical messages on the
products they sell. Alaska Airlines places a Bible scripture card
under every meal tray it serves to passengers.

Forever
21 reportedly puts “John 3:16” on its bags. Perhaps better known is
the tradition of In-N-Out Burgers, who put several bible verses on
their wrappers. The authoritative snopes.com states that—

· Soda cups bear the notation John 3:16
· Milkshake cups list Proverbs 3:5
· Hamburger/cheeseburger wrappers show Revelation 3:20
· The “Double-Double” wrappers list Nahum 1:17


More
recently, news outlets reported that a Michigan-based defense
contractor has been including similar biblical “codes” on high-powered
rifle sights that it sells to the Defense Department. According to ABC News, Trijicon has a $660 million multi-year contract to provide Advanced Combat Optical Guides (ACOG) to the Marine Corps. and U.S. Army. ABC News reports—
One
of the citations on the gun sights, 2COR4:6, is an apparent reference
to Second Corinthians 4:6 of the New Testament, which reads: "For God,
who commanded the light to shine out of darkness, hath shined in our
hearts, to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the
face of Jesus Christ." Other references include citations from the
books of Revelation, Matthew and John dealing with Jesus as "the light
of the world." John 8:12, referred to on the gun sights as JN8:12,
reads, "Whoever follows me will never walk in darkness, but will have
the light of life."
The
company spokesman noted that the biblical citations “have always been
there” and said there was nothing wrong or illegal about them. Others
aren’t so sure. The story reports Mikey Weinstein of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation as saying, “It's wrong, it violates the Constitution, it violates a number of federal laws." In
addition, Weinstein noted, “It allows the Mujahedeen, the Taliban, al
Qaeda and the insurrectionists and jihadists to claim they're being
shot by Jesus rifles." He added, “This is probably the best example of
violation of the separation of church and state in this country."
Putting
aside Mr. Weinstein’s hyperbole, it is not clear if there is anything
that the DOD can do about the situation, at least retroactively. Once
the ACOGs have been inspected and accepted, only a “latent” defect can
allow the sights to be returned. A “latent” defect is a “defect that
existed at the time of acceptance but would not have been discovered by
a reasonable inspection.” In order to show a latent defect, the
Government must prove that the defect existed at the time of final
acceptance, it was hidden from knowledge as well as sight, and could
not be discovered by the exercise of reasonable care. If the defect
was discoverable by a reasonable inspection, it is “patent” and not
“latent” and thus the Government is bound by its inspection and
acceptance of the goods.
Given
that the biblical “codes” were in plain sight and had “always been
there” we think the Government would have difficulty proving they were
a latent defect. On the other hand, there is nothing that would
prevent the DOD from revising the ACOG specifications to eliminate
unnecessary markings. Were the Government to take that action, then Trijicon
would have to change its tooling and machining operations to eliminate
the step of creating the markings—and it would be able to pass on any
increased costs that resulted from the change back to the Government
pursuant to the Changes clause in its contract.
There
is also the question as to whether these sights are uniquely designed
for military use, or are simply commercially produced sights that could
be used for star-gazing, bird-watching, or what-have-you. If the DOD
acquired these sights under a FAR Part 12 “commercial item acquisition,” then it may have little or no recourse whatsoever.
|