Is Corruption in the Public Procurement Process Simply a Part of the Process?
12 February 2010 – The U.S. Department of Justice (DoJ)
announces that “Lincoln Fabrics Ltd., a Canadian weaver of ballistic
fabrics, and its American subsidiary, have agreed to pay the United
States $4 million to settle the United States’ lawsuit against Lincoln
for violations of the False Claims Act in connection with their role in
the weaving of Zylon fabric used in the manufacture and sale of
defective Zylon bullet-proof vests.” According to the DoJ press
release—
The United States alleged that the Zylon in these vests lost its
ballistic capability quickly, especially when exposed to heat and
humidity. The United States further alleged that Lincoln was aware of
the defective nature of the Zylon by at least December 2001, but
continued to sell Zylon for use in ballistic armor until August 2005,
when the National Institute of Justice issued a report that Zylon
degraded quickly in ballistic applications. At that time, all American
body armor manufacturers stopped using Zylon in body armor. … This
settlement is part of a larger investigation of the body armor
industry’s use of Zylon in body armor. As part of today’s agreement,
Lincoln has pledged its cooperation in the Government’s on-going
investigation. The United States previously has settled with six other
participants in the Zylon body armor industry for over $54 million.
Additionally, the United States has pending lawsuits against Toyobo
Co., Honeywell Inc., Second Chance Body Armor, Inc. and First Choice
Armor Inc.
16 February 2010 – The
DoJ announces
that “An Italian subsidiary of a U.S.-based company has
agreed to plead guilty and to pay a $2.29 million criminal fine for
participating in a conspiracy to rig bids, fix prices and allocate
market shares of marine hose sold in the United States and elsewhere.”
The DoJ press release
explained—
A one-count felony
charge was filed today in U.S. District Court in Houston, against
Parker ITR S.r.l., a manufacturer of marine hose, headquartered in
Veniano, Italy. … Parker ITR has agreed to pay a criminal fine and to
cooperate fully in the Department’s ongoing antitrust investigation.
Parker ITR is the fourth company to be charged in the investigation. To
date, nine individuals have been convicted for their involvement in the
marine hose conspiracy. … Parker ITR is charged with participating in
the conspiracy from as early as 1999 until as late as May 2, 2007.
According to the charge, Parker ITR and its co-conspirators agreed to
allocate shares of the marine hose market and to use a price list for
marine hose in order to implement the conspiracy. Parker ITR and its
co-conspirators agreed not to compete for one another’s customers
either by not submitting prices or bids, or by submitting intentionally
high prices or bids, to certain customers. As part of the conspiracy,
Parker ITR and its co-conspirators provided information received from
customers in the United States and elsewhere about upcoming marine hose
jobs to a co-conspirator who served as the coordinator of the
conspiracy. Parker ITR received marine hose prices for customers in the
United States and elsewhere from the coordinator of the conspiracy and
then sold the marine hose to those customers at collusive and
noncompetitive prices and then concealed the conspiracy through various
means, including code names, private email accounts and telephone
numbers.
Parker ITR is charged
with violating the Sherman Act, which carries a maximum fine of $100
million for corporations. The maximum fine may be increased to twice
the gain derived from the crime or twice the loss suffered by the
victims of the crime, if either of those amounts is greater than the
statutory maximum fine.
18 February
2010 – The DoJ announces that “former military contractor Terry
Hall, 43, of Snellville, Ga., pleaded guilty today to conspiracy to pay
more than $3 million in bribes to U.S. Army contracting officials
stationed at Camp Arifjan, an Army base in Kuwait, and to money
laundering conspiracy.” The DoJ press
release continues--
Terry Hall was
indicted on May 6, 2009, along with U.S. Army Major Eddie Pressley, 39,
and his wife, Eurica Pressley, 37, both of Harvest, Ala. … Hall’s
companies received approximately $21 million between 2005 and 2007. …
To obtain the contracting business and facilitate unlawful payments by
other contractors, Hall admitted he made more than $3 million in
unlawful payments and provided other valuable items and services to
U.S. Army contracting officials stationed at Camp Arifjan, including
U.S. Army Major Eddie Pressley, and former Majors John Cockerham, James
Momon and Christopher Murray, among
others.
… Hall owned and
operated several companies, including Freedom Consulting and Catering
Co., (FCC) and Total Government Allegiance (TGA), which provided goods
and services to the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) in connection with
Operation Iraqi Freedom. Hall’s companies received a Blanket Purchase
Agreement (BPA) to deliver bottled water in Iraq and a contract to
construct a security fence in
Kuwait.
The case against Hall
arose out of a wide-ranging investigation of corruption at the Camp
Arifjan contracting office. To date, eight individuals including Hall
have pleaded guilty for their roles in the bribery scheme. On Dec. 2,
2009, former Cockerham was sentenced to 210 months in prison and
ordered to pay $9.6 million in restitution. According to court
documents, Cockerham arranged for Hall’s companies to receive bottled
water calls worth more than $2.6 million, as a result of which Hall
paid Cockerham approximately
$800,000.
… Momon arranged for
Hall’s companies to receive bottled water calls [against a Blanket
Purchase Agreement] worth approximately $6.4 million, as a result of
which Hall paid Momon more than $300,000. Momon pleaded guilty on Aug.
13, 2008, to receiving bribes from various contractors at Camp Arifjan,
including Hall, and is awaiting sentencing. … Murray arranged for Hall
to receive contracts to construct security fences at Camp Arifjan, as a
result of which Hall paid Murray approximately $30,000. Murray pleaded
guilty to receiving bribes from various contractors at Camp Arifjan,
including Hall, and making a false statement. He was sentenced on Jan.
8, 2009, to 57 months in prison and ordered to pay $245,000 in
restitution.
The case against Eddie
Pressley and his wife, Eurica Pressley, is scheduled for trial on April
5, 2010. The indictment alleges that the Pressleys received more than
$2.8 million in money and other valuable items from Hall, in exchange
for Eddie Pressley’s agreement to take official actions to benefit
Hall. Eurica Pressley, at her husband’s request, allegedly arranged for
an entity named EGP Business Solutions Inc., (EGP) to be incorporated,
opened a bank account in the name of EGP, and opened bank accounts in
her name in the United States, Dubai, United Arab Emirates and the
Cayman Islands, all in order to receive the bribe
payments.
The charge of bribery
conspiracy carries a maximum prison sentence of five years and a
$250,000 fine. The money laundering conspiracy carries a maximum prison
sentence of 20 years and a $250,000 fine. According to the court
documents, Hallwill forfeit $15,757,000 to the U.S. government.
19
February 2010 – The DoJ announces that “A U.S. Army contracting
official was charged today with bribery and unlawful salary
supplementation in connection with two schemes to solicit more than
$30,000 in bribes from an Egyptian businessman in Kuwait.” The DoJ
press release provided
the following details—
William
Rondell Collins, 46, of Bartlett, Tenn., was charged today in a
four-count indictment … with two counts of soliciting and accepting
bribes as a public official and two counts of unlawful salary
supplementation from a source other than the U.S. government.According
to the indictment, the U.S. Army Area Support Group-Kuwait (ASG-KU) is
responsible for maintaining Camp Arifjan, a U.S. military installation
providing support for operations in Afghanistan, Iraq and other
locations in the Southwest Asian Theater. As part of those
responsibilities, the ASG-KU maintains an off-post housing office in
downtown Kuwait City, which procures, leases and supervises off-post
housing for government employees and military service members stationed
at Camp Arifjan. According to the indictment, Collins was employed in
the ASG-KU’s off-post housing office as a housing specialist
responsible for supervising private contractors and procuring off-post
apartment rentals.
The
indictment alleges that, in January 2009, a company owned by an
Egyptian businessman was awarded a fixed-price U.S. government contract
to provide maintenance services for off-post housing managed by Collins
and the ASG-KU off-post housing office. … in July 2009, Collins
allegedly solicited a monthly fee of approximately $1,400 from the
Egyptian businessman in return for Collins’s agreement to provide
favorable and preferential treatment and advice to the Egyptian
businessman’s company on the performance and renewal of the contract.
Collins also allegedly agreed to conceal from his supervisors the
existence and nature of the monthly fee arrangement. According to the
indictment, Collins allegedly accepted five $1,400 payments from the
Egyptian businessman between July and December
2009.
The
indictment also alleges that, between July and December 2009, Collins
solicited a monthly payment of approximately $962 from the Egyptian
businessman in exchange for drafting and submitting an inflated
off-post apartment lease to the United States for approval. According
to the indictment, Collins allegedly received approximately $5,775 from
the Egyptian businessman on Dec. 13, 2009, representing a six-month
advance on the scheme.
The
bribery counts each carry a maximum penalty of 15 years in prison and a
fine of the greater of $250,000 or twice the value gained or lost. The
unlawful salary supplementation counts each carry a maximum penalty of
five years in prison.
Look,
we don’t want to go on a rant here. But seriously, this is getting out
of control. Not a week goes by without a story of corruption, bribery,
and/or fraud hitting the internet. We’re glad these wrongdoers are
getting caught, but why do so many participants in the public
procurement process think they can get away with such blatant
wrongdoing? Clearly, they expect to get away with it. Our question
is, why? Are internal controls so loose in the Southwest Asia theater
of operations? Is management oversight lax? Are the wrongdoers simply
stupid? We don’t think so—some of these malefactors are senior military
officers. What in the world is going
on?
Lexington Institute Publishes “Contrarian” Viewpoint on Acquisition Reform
What is the Lexington
Institute? It is a policy institute (i.e., “think tank”) focused on
issues such as national security, education, taxation, and
immigration. In its own words—
The Lexington
Institute believes in limiting the role of the federal government to
those functions explicitly stated or implicitly defined by the
Constitution. The Institute therefore actively opposes the unnecessary
intrusion of the federal government into the commerce and culture of
the nation, and strives to find nongovernmental, market-based solutions
to public-policy challenges. We believe a dynamic private sector is the
greatest engine for social progress and economic
prosperity.
Here is a link to the Lexington Institute’s
home
page. In
addition to scholarly works, it also publishes the “Early Warning”
blog. One of the blog posts, by Dr. Loren Thompson, caught our eye
with the interesting title: “Weapons Spending: Much of the
Logic Behind Acquisition
Reform is Flawed.” See the
entire post here. We agree—and have posted similar thoughts in
the past. (See this
article or this
one).
We encourage visitors
to read the linked article in its entirety. To summarize, though, Dr.
Thompson makes the following four points.
1.
Competition does not
improve performance, but it does lower efficiency. The Government
doesn’t need to hold competitions to drive best value acquisitions or
to incentivize contractor performance. There are plenty of contracting
tools in the Government’s toolkit to motivate contractors to operate
efficiently. As Dr. Thompson says, “The notion
that normal rules of competition can be made to work in a system
of monopsonybuyers and oligopolistic sellers
is nonsensical, because the market is too distorted to function
normally. If there are to be two suppliers, then the sole customer must
pay for two sets of everything -- design teams, production facilities,
spare parts, etc.”
2.
Use of Fixed-Price
contract types does not control contractor cost growth, but it does
encourage contractors to bid high prices. Dr. Thompson asks, “Is it
really so hard to fashion a cost-plus approach to weapons development
where the contractor is rewarded for holding down costs rather than
encouraged to bid high from day one?”
3.
Contractors are
encouraged to bid low, and cost realism is never rewarded. Because the
top-tier of defense contractors is largely interchangeable, the
distinguishing characteristic between bids is often price. Dr.
Thompson asks, “What source-selection authority is going to pick the
system that costs a billion dollars more when all of the competing
solutions meet performance requirements?” He cites the
recent award of the multi-billion dollar FMTV
award to Oshkosh as a prime example of this rule, where he asserts that
Oshkosh’s bid was “30% below what the incumbent is currently charging
for identical trucks,” and Oshkosh’s profit projection
was based on receipt of “financial aid from state and local
governments.”
4.
Adding more
acquisition, audit, and program management professionals
to DoD’s ranks won’t solve the myriad problems with the Pentagon’s
acquisition process, but it will compound the problem.
We are all familiar
with the lack of Government resources in this area, and the current
reliance on contractors to augment short-staffed contracting offices.
But Dr. Thompson notes that those new heads will take additional
funds—not just to cover the costs of salary and benefits,
but also
to cover the costs of training, equipping, housing and supporting
them. As Dr. Thompson notes, “When you add up all these costs, the
long-term burden of taking on 20,000 new acquisition professionals will
be over $80 billion -- which just happens to be the projected cost of
buying a replacement for the Trident ballistic-missile
sub.”
|
DOD Implements the Franken Amendment
In
one of his first actions since becoming Senator in July 2009, Minnesota
Senator Al Franken successfully added an amendment to the 2010 Defense
Appropriations Act
that would prevent the award of defense contracts to companies that
mandate use of alternate dispute resolution (ADR) procedures instead of
litigation when employees sue them for such crimes as sex
discrimination or workplace sexual assault.
Commonly
known as the “Franken Amendment,” its creation was traced back to the
case that Jamie Leigh Jones tried to bring against her employer
(Halliburton) in 2007. Ms. Jones alleged she was raped by multiple
co-workers while in Iraq performing on Halliburton/KBR contracts.
Although she attempted to litigate the matter, her employment agreement
mandated use of arbitration instead. When binding arbitration is used, there are only limited rights of appeal.
This article summarizes the amendment thusly—
Specifically,
the amendment would bar federal funds from going to defense contractors
that continue to apply mandatory arbitration clauses to claims of
sexual assault, assault and battery, intentional infliction of
emotional distress, and negligent hiring, retention and supervision.
The amendment also covers civil rights claims of workplace
discrimination, according to Franken's office.
The amendment does not require contractors to change or modify existing employment contracts.
Not everybody was happy that the Franken amendment passed and was signed into law by President Obama. This op/ed piece rails against it, calling it a victory for trial lawyers and the plaintiff’s bar. Nonetheless, it is current law and the DoD has been forced to implement it.
So
on February 17, 2010, Mr. Shay Assad (Director, Defense Procurement and
Acquisition Policy) issued a “Class Deviation to Implement Additional
Contractor Requirements and Responsibilities Restricting Use of
Mandatory Arbitration Agreements.” The Class Deviation memo can be
found here.
The Class Deviation provides DoD contracting officers with a new contract clause (DFARS Clause 252.222-7999) that must be used in all DoD
contracts in excess of $1 million that utilize FY 2010 Defense funds.
Exceptions are made for acquisitions of commercial items and
commercially available off-the-shelf items. The clause must be used in the following circumstances:
1. An
order valued at more than $1 million that uses FY 2010 funds, placed
against an ID/IQ contract, is covered by the Franken restriction
“regardless of whether the basic ID/IQ contract was covered.”
2. An order valued at more than $1 million that uses FY 2010 funds, placed against a GSA Schedule, is covered.
3. A contract modification adding more than $1 million in FY 2010 funds to a contract awarded before February 17, 2010, is not
covered by the restriction. However, a “bilateral modification adding
new [contract] work after February 17, 2010 to such a contract is
covered” by the restriction.
The clause requires a contractor executing the awarded contract to agree to the following –
1. Not
to enter into an agreement with any of its employees or independent
contractors that requires, as a condition of employment, that the
employee or independent contractor agree to resolve through arbitration
any claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, or any tort
arising from a sexual assault or harassment, or negligent hiring,
supervision, or retention (among other matters).
2. Not to take any action to enforce any provision of an existing agreement that mandates the above actions.
3. Pass the foregoing restrictions to all covered subcontracts (i.e., those valued in excess of $1 million that use FY 2010 funds, excepting commercial item acquisitions and acquisitions of commercially available off-the-shelf items.
It’s
difficult to estimate the impact from the Franken Amendment and its
associated ADR restrictions on defense contractors. Certainly, one
might speculate that legal costs will increase as ADR use drops. We
might also guess that procurement systems will have to be revised to
add the new clause into covered subcontracts—and that somebody (or
bodies) will need to verify that covered subcontractors are complying
with the restrictions. The impact may be minimal, or could be
disruptive if implemented poorly. More importantly, contractors now
have one more certification to comply with. A knowing failure to
comply may result in allegations of violation of the False Statements
Act, which could be expensive to resolve.
Army Reconsiders, Reconfirms FMTV Award to Oshkosh
Our latest report
on the on-going saga of the Army’s Family of Medium Tactical Vehicles
(FMTV) award indicated the areas of protest—both the areas sustained
and those denied by the GAO. At that time, we predicted, “unless the
Army seriously misevaluated the offers, or seriously misled the GAO, we
don't think the original award to Oshkosh will be changed.” Looks like our prediction was spot-on.
On February 12, 2010 the Army announced that it had completed its “re-evaluation” and, as a result—
Oshkosh
Corp. has been awarded a competitive, five-year requirements contract
for production of up to 12,415 trucks, 10,926 trailers, and associated
support and engineering services. The total estimated contract value at award was $3.023 billion.
The official announcement notes that a peer-review of the re-evaluation was performed by the Office of the Secretary of Defense.
This is bad news for BAE Systems, whose Sealy, Texas subsidiary was the FMTV incumbent contractor. According to this report by the Wall Street Journal—
With
confirmation of this decision the group will include in its 2009
accounts an impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
amounting to GBP592 million relating to the Armor Holdings Inc.
transaction and specifically the FMTV product line. [Currency conversion: US$ 927.2 million.]
Predictably, Texas politicians were unhappy at the outcome. One “gentleman” from Texas had this to say—
For
nearly two decades, Sealy, Texas, has been the manufacturing home of
the Army’s FMTV truck. There, thousands of proud Texans have
contributed countless hours to the production of world-class vehicles
for our troops, who deserve – and have received – nothing less than the
best. The Army’s decision to discard this important and valuable asset
is ill-informed, and it makes no sense.
Naturally, Oshkosh was “very pleased” by the outcome. Life is sweet in Wisconsin these days, if a bit chilly.
|