• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

CAS and COVID-19 and DCAA

E-mail Print PDF

One thing’s for sure. You can’t believe the hit counts on our website. I mean, yes, they provide an indication of the popularity of each article, primarily in terms of who came to the article after it left the front page or who printed it or downloaded it. But it’s an indication only. The exact number of hits can be very misleading. Some of the hit counts have been inflated by hackers trying to get into the site. I mean, really inflated. Big time. And obviously the older the article, the more hits it would be expected to receive. We don't use the hit counts for anything more than an indication of popularity.

Still, the indications are that the three most popular topics are (1) DCAA stuff, (2) CAS stuff and—more recently—(3) COVID-19 stuff. We thought “what if we combine all three of those popular topics into one article? Yeah, that will be huge.”

So here it is.

As many readers know, the CARES Act—especially Section 3610—authorizes Federal agencies to reimburse contractors for impacts related to COVID-19 in certain circumstances. Importantly, it does not mandate reimbursement; it simply authorizes it.

Many may be wondering why anybody needed specific statutory authorization. After all, the cost principle at 31.205-13 already made reasonable costs associated with efforts to maintain employee well-being allowable. It is hard to imagine some auditor or contracting officer (or, perhaps, a judge) finding that costs incurred to protect worker health and safety during the pandemic were somehow unallowable. Especially if a contractor has DPAS-rated contracts. At a bare minimum, contractors are expected to take actions to mitigate cost and schedule impacts to their government contracts.

What’s the deal then?

The deal is that Section 3610 seemingly permits a contractor to deviate from its standard practices—and its disclosed or established cost accounting practices—with respect to some of its COVID-19-related costs.

Let’s quote Section 3610 so you can see what we’re talking about.

FEDERAL CONTRACTOR AUTHORITY. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, and subject to the availability of appropriations, funds made available to an agency by this Act or any other Act may be used by such agency to modify the terms and conditions of a contract, or other agreement, without consideration, to reimburse at the minimum applicable contract billing rates not to exceed an average of hours per week any paid leave, including sick leave, a contractor provides to keep its employees or subcontractors in a ready state, including to protect the life and safety of Government and contractor personnel, but in no event beyond September 30, 2020. Such authority shall apply only to a contractor whose employees or subcontractors cannot perform work on a site that has been approved by the Federal Government, including a federally-owned or leased facility or site, due to facility closures or other restrictions, and who cannot telework because their job duties cannot be performed remotely during the public health emergency declared on January 31, 2020 for COVID–19: Provided, That the maximum reimbursement authorized by this section shall be reduced by the amount of credit a contractor is allowed pursuant to division G of Public Law 116–127 and any applicable credits a contractor is allowed under this Act.

Let’s break that down a bit.

  1. Applies to a contractor whose employees or subcontractors cannot perform work on a site that has been approved by the Federal government, including a Federally-owned or leased facility or site because of a facility closure or other restrictions.

  2. When the closures or restrictions are related to the COVID-19 health emergency.

  3. And the contractor's (or subcontractor's) employees cannot perform their job duties (with respect to the contract) remotely; they must be performed at the (closed or restricted) site.

  4. When the contractor grants affected employees or subcontractors paid leave, including sick leave, in order to keep its workforce in a “ready state” to resume contract performance when the facilities are reopened or the restrictions are lifted; or, “to protect the life and safety of Government and contractor personnel.”

Thus, for contractors that qualify under the conditions above, their Federal contracts may be modified (without consideration) to reimburse them “at the minimum applicable contract billing rates not to exceed an average of hours per week” for the costs of the paid leave.

From a CAS perspective, the interesting thing about the above is that contractors may have to deviate from their disclosed or established practices in order to comply. Costs of paid time off (PTO) are not normally charged direct to contracts, because it’s not customary to charge contracts for time not actually spent working on contract tasks. Instead, contractors typically charge PTO costs to an indirect cost pool (often the pool the captures all costs of fringe benefits, including the employer’s portion of payroll taxes, the employer’s portion of medical insurance costs, and etc.), for subsequent allocation to contracts (or to other indirect cost pools) on a chosen allocation base. Therefore, charging indirect costs as direct costs is going to require a change in cost accounting practice.

And it’s not just that. “Normal” PTO costs associated with employees not impacted by COVID-19 are still going to be accumulated and allocated in accordance with the disclosed or established practices. It’s only the PTO costs associated with maintaining impacted employees in a “ready state” that are going to be direct costs of the impacted contracts. Which brings up a CAS 402 compliance question—is this the same cost, incurred for the same purpose in like circumstances, being treated two different ways (both direct and indirect)?

Sure, we’ll all assert that COVID-19 circumstances are different than the norm, and we’ll all point to the Section 3610 language. But will it be sufficient? That remains to be seen.

Looking at published Section 3610 implementation guidance (especially guidance published by DOD), it seems that there are even more options available to a contractor. “To the extent that the contractor workforce is shared across multiple contracts, contracting officers will need to coordinate on a reasonable allocation of costs, ideally through the administrative contracting officer.” That implies (if not expressly states) that contractors can pool their Section 3610 PTO costs and allocate them to contracts. We’re betting no contractor has a disclosed or established cost accounting practice for pooling COVID-19-related PTO costs and then allocating them to contracts. Note the guidance does not specify that the contracts that receive an allocation of such costs must have been impacted by COVID-19 facility closures or restrictions, only that the allocation of the costs to contracts must be made on a “reasonable” basis. In our view, that gives contractors a lot of flexibility to accumulate and allocate their Section 3610 costs.

Contracting officers are given the authority to determine what contractor Section 3610 costs they decide to reimburse. Who do you think they are going to lean on for an opinion regarding the costs claimed by contractors? That’s right, their contract auditors. Chances are that means DCAA.

The DOD guidance (link above) anticipates that DCAA auditors are going to get to express an opinion regarding whether the contractor has (a) accumulated legitimate Section 3610 costs, (b) accounted for them properly, and (c) allocated them to contracts in a reasonable manner. (And don't forget to propery credit those costs for any other COVID-19-related reimbursements, such as insurance settlements.) Auditors are going to be looking at previous contractor cost accounting practices related to PTO, and asking contractors to support/justify everything. (As we’ve noted before, a failure to document circumstances and decisions now will lead to potential audit issues downstream.) The guidance states “Proper administration and traceability of actions under section 3610 will require special attention to contracting procedures and contract administration by contracting officers, the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA), and contracting officer’s representatives (CORs). … DCAA has oversight of billings under cost-reimbursement, time and materials, and labor hour line items.”

Certain contractors (Hi KBR!) were rather famously burned by DCAA second-guessing their decisions and questioning the resulting costs. They had to engage in expensive, protracted, litigation in order to recover the questioned costs, and many millions of dollars ended-up being left on the table, never reimbursed. Let’s use their painful lessons-learned to guide our decision-making today, during the current pandemic crisis.

We’ll note here that DCAA very recently issued audit guidance addressing how audits should be conducted under the current state of pandemic lock-downs. It states:

If audit teams are unable to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence (e.g., audit teams receive electronic documents from the contractor via e-mail and are unable to validate to original records), the audit team should continue with the audit and validate the electronic documents to original records when the Agency and/or contractor resumes normal operations. When normal operations resume, the audit team should validate the electronic data previously accepted and then issue the audit report. Audit teams are reminded to appropriately document the audit evidence received, including the methods used to obtain the evidence. … The lack of access to original documents, lack of access to contractor personnel, or the inability to validate the source of original documents (e.g., contractor records and contractor downloads) will generally result in a reservation about the engagement (i.e., scope limitation). In most cases, this scope limitation will result in a qualified opinion. However, the audit team should assess the evidence collected and use professional judgment in determining whether a scope limitation is necessary.

There is a FAQ in the back of the MRD that everybody should read. It discusses, among other things, the conduct of “floorcheck” audits using telephone or video conference, and the performance of “walk-throughs” via teleconference and/or Webex. Interesting stuff—but we hope the guidance will become obsolete in a few more weeks or months.

So: COVID-19; Cost Accounting Standards; DCAA. A jam-packed article covering all the popular topics. We trust you enjoyed it.

 

Performance-Based Payments: Final DFARS Rule

E-mail Print PDF

It’s all COVID-19, all the time. Except when it’s not.

In between the pandemic panic1 the wheels of acquisition rule-making continue to grind, albeit with the rapidity of a downhill skier racing through gravel. In fact, on April 8, several DFARS final rules were issued, along with several proposed rules. By and large, there isn’t much in the regulatory revisions that is worth reporting—though note proposed dollar threshold changes to several DFARS regulations/clauses found in this proposed rule.

But the one thing that caught our eye was the final DFARS rule on performance-based payments (PBPs).

Readers know this one because we’ve commented on it before on this blog site, and even submitted a comment into the rule-making process. The “current state” DFARS rules were so bad that the DOD issued a Class Deviation to help contracting officers get it right.

Remember, PBPs are not progress payments. Progress payments are contract financing payments based on a percentage of costs incurred. PBPs are contract financing payments that are fixed amounts tied to accomplishment of significant program or technical events. We discussed the differences in this article.

Anyway, the final rule gets it mostly right. The impacted DFARS clauses have been revised “to specifically state that it is not necessary to have a Government-unique cost accounting system in order to report incurred costs under the clause”—which was our major gripe with them. In addition, “the procedures at DFARS 232.1004 are modified to eliminate the requirement to first agree on price using customary progress payments and then require consideration if performance-based payments are subsequently negotiated.” Those are good things, and we applaud the DAR Council for listening to public input. (Historically, that has not always been the case.)

In the final rule, the DAR Council makes it clear that some type of “job cost accounting” is still required when PBPs are used. In response to public comments on the issue, they wrote “It would be highly unlikely for a fiscally sound company to have no means of identifying the costs of performing a contract. Furthermore, the rule does not require any particular accounting system; rather, the rule states that ‘incurred cost is determined by the Contractor's accounting books and records.’”

Further despite respondents (including us!) pointing out that the government shouldn’t need to use incurred costs as the basis for negotiating future costs, the requirement was retained in the final rule. The DAR Council wrote “… aside from the value to Government negotiators of being able to evaluate current proposals for PBP milestone values against past experience, it remains important for the Government to know the risk it is incurring when it makes payments that may be disproportionate to the contractor's investment in contract performance.”

Regardless, the final rule represents a significant improvement over the current state that existed before the regulatory revision. One suspects that the DOD Class Deviation is no longer needed.

In the midst of COVID-19 thoughts and decisions and actions, consider the DAR Council, who is still grinding through open cases. We wish them well.

 

1 “Pandemic Panic” is the name of my new deathmetal band. I’m calling it now.

 

Update: DOD Progress Payments

E-mail Print PDF
Recently we told readers that the Dept. of Defense was increasing its progress payment rates to help its contractors through the COVID-19 crisis. In that article we documented a bit of confusion regarding which contracts where eligible for the increased rates, whether consideration would be required, and whether DOD was going to take advantage of “block modifications” versus modifications of individual contracts.

For the most part, that confusion was resolved satisfactorily. DCMA modified some 1,500 active contracts via a block change, and no consideration from the contractor was required. Sure, there were some outliers that didn’t make the DCMA list, but that small group could be dealt with relatively easily on an individual basis.

So far, so good.

But what wasn’t being satisfactorily resolved was the implementation of the new progress payment rates. DOD leadership seemed firm that the new rates were to be implemented prospectively, effective March 20, 2020, and not retrospectively on all inception-to-date incurred costs. This was a problem.

Remember, the SF 1443 progress payment request requires the contractor to apply the rate to inception-to-date costs. There is no way to stratify incurred costs into “pre-20 March” and “post-20 March” to apply different rates. Further, our understanding is that DFAS and MOCAS didn’t have the functionality to have two different progress payment rates associated with the same contract.

Finally, there was a potential cash flow problem if a 90% liquidation rate was applied to a cost that had been previously subject to an 80% progress payment rate. It was quite possible that a contractor could actually see negative cash flow in that situation, which was a result that was obviously contrary to the intent of the Class Deviation.

That last bit of confusion was resolved via an undated “Q&A” guidance document from Kim Herrington, Acting Director, Defense Pricing and Contracting. Here’s a link to that updated guidance document. That document resolves any remaining confusion, as follows:

The [Class] Deviation for the increased progress payment rate applies to prospective Progress Payment Requests (PPRs) only and not to prior requests. However, 52.232-16 (DEVIATION 2020-O0010), paragraph (a)(1), explicitly states, “Unless the Contractor requests a smaller amount, the Government will compute each progress payment at 90 percent of the Contractor’s total costs incurred under this contract whether or not actually paid, plus financing payments to subcontractors (see paragraph (j) of this clause), less the sum of all previous progress payments made by the Government under this contract.” Therefore, there is no need to resubmit adjustments to previous PPRs. The SF1443 should continue to be completed based upon inception to date cost. As a result, the first post-modification PPR will result in the application of the higher progress payment rate against all qualified costs, including costs that have been incurred prior to the issuance of the Deviation

(Emphasis in original.)

In addition, the guidance clarifies that there is no intent to impact contractor cash flow negatively. If the scenario where the increase in financing requested is offset by the increase in required liquidations, then “the contractor should stop progress billing until the progress payment calculation turns positive.”

To conclude, DOD implemented new, higher, progress payment rates for all fixed-price contracts—both existing ones and new ones to be awarded. Although there was some confusion about how those new rates actually would be implemented on existing contracts, that confusion was sorted relatively quickly. So: good on DOD!

 

COVID-19 Resources

E-mail Print PDF
The tendency over here is to just write about COVID-19 stuff, because that’s what’s on everybody’s mind right now. Contractors are concerned about workforce health and safety (as they should be), and also about impacts to their existing contracts. Of course there will be impacts.

There will be direct cost impacts associated with absent employees, or with quarantined employees, or simply because of inefficiencies created by the need to keep social distancing. We’ve heard it referred to as “employee density.” We’ve also heard about some contractors being directed to reduce their “footprint” at certain governmental installations, also in the name of reducing employee density. If you were a learning curve contractor, you’re pretty much going to throw that learning curve right out the window.

There will be indirect cost impacts associated with unanticipated paid time off, or with additional standby/idle time, or with the additional costs associated with facility cleaning/sterilization. Many contractors are giving their employees facemasks to wear—and those facemasks cost money. Whatever indirect rates you thought you were going to run at for 2020, you’re pretty much going to throw those rates out the window.

Recovery of the direct and indirect cost impacts associated with COVID-19 will depend on contract type, contract terms and conditions, your customer, and your contracting officer. Recovery will also depend on how well you documented your circumstances and your decisions made in response to those circumstances. As we’ve posted before, every contractor should be (1) segregating COVID-19 impacts in their accounting system, and (2) documenting everything. Two or three years from now, you’re going to be glad you did so.

Auditors are going to push contractors to justify why their decisions—and the resulting costs—were reasonable. FAR 31.201-3 establishes the basis for reasonableness. It states:

(a) A cost is reasonable if, in its nature and amount, it does not exceed that which would be incurred by a prudent person in the conduct of competitive business. Reasonableness of specific costs must be examined with particular care in connection with firms or their separate divisions that may not be subject to effective competitive restraints. No presumption of reasonableness shall be attached to the incurrence of costs by a contractor. If an initial review of the facts results in a challenge of a specific cost by the contracting officer or the contracting officer’s representative, the burden of proof shall be upon the contractor to establish that such cost is reasonable.

(b) What is reasonable depends upon a variety of considerations and circumstances, including-

(1) Whether it is the type of cost generally recognized as ordinary and necessary for the conduct of the contractor’s business or the contract performance;

(2) Generally accepted sound business practices, arm’s-length bargaining, and Federal and State laws and regulations;

(3) The contractor’s responsibilities to the Government, other customers, the owners of the business, employees, and the public at large; and

(4) Any significant deviations from the contractor’s established practices.

(Emphasis added.)

Document decisions made with an eye to supporting the reasonableness of those decisions, giving the definition quoted above. Obviously, the COVID-19 pandemic crisis is hardly normal circumstances, so deviations from the contractor’s established practices should be expected. However, undocumented deviations that haven’t been communicated to customers and contracting officers are going to be suspect.

Further, note that what is reasonable can turn on “the contractor’s responsibilities to the Government, other customers, the owners of the business, employees, and the public at large.” Use that. Actions taken to address COVID-19-related responsibilities to the government, the employees, and the public at large should be deemed to be reasonable actions, and the resulting costs accepted as being reasonable costs. Document why that is the case!

Also look at the cost principle 31.205-13. We’ve written about that cost principle before—particularly as it interacts with the cost principle at 31.205-14.

In this article, we discuss a couple of contractors who got it wrong.

In another article, we spent a bit more time comparing the 31.205-13 principle to the 31.205-14 principle.

In essence, the 31.205-13 cost principle states “Aggregate costs incurred on activities designed to improve working conditions, employer-employee relations, employee morale, and employee performance (less income generated by these activities) are allowable, subject to the limitations contained in this subsection.” But it’s not that straightforward and so you need to read the details for yourself, in case you end up like the contractors we write about.

However, it seems fairly clear to us that costs associated with COVID-19 activities intended to protect employee health and welfare, and to keep employees working on their DPAS-rated government contracts, are (generally speaking) fully allowable under 31.205-13. Further, even if you are a contractor that doesn’t have DPAS-rated contracts, at some point this crisis is going to be over and you will need a workforce ready and available to perform those contracts. Actions taken now to ensure performance can resume will likely be viewed as being both reasonable and allowable.

If you document them.

Before we wrap this up, we wanted to list some important COVID-19-related websites that have important resources. Those resources are already establishing the government’s position on many issues we’ve discussed here. In particular, DOD has issued many guidance documents, and so you need to be aware of them if you are a defense contractor.

So, presented in no particular order:

https://www.acquisition.gov/coronavirus

https://www.businessdefense.gov/coronavirus/

https://www.acq.osd.mil/dpap/pacc/cc/COVID-19.html

https://www.dentons.com/en/issues-and-opportunities/covid-19-coronavirus-hub

https://www.cov.com/en/news-and-insights/insights/2020/03/covid-19-evolving-considerations-for-global-business

https://www.insidegovernmentcontracts.com/tag/covid-19/

https://www.crowell.com/Practices/Coronavirus-COVID-19-Resource-Center

https://www.bdo.com/insights/business-financial-advisory/risk-advisory/novel-coronavirus-(covid-19)-impact-and-risk-respo

https://www.pillsburylaw.com/en/news-and-insights/scenarios-government-contractors-may-face-during-the-covid-19-national-emergency.html

https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2020/3/19/contractor-tips-for-covid19-pandemic

http://thecgp.org/coronavirus-resources-for-federal-contractors

 

Hey Nineteen

E-mail Print PDF
Everybody is dealing with COVID-19. Big companies, small companies, we’re all in this together right now.

Changes are happening quickly. The CARES Act. DOD Class Deviations. Direction to increase cash flow throughout the industrial base.

It’s hard to keep up with it all—and meanwhile, contractors have real issues to deal with.

The workforce is affected. Some are getting sick; others may have been exposed but aren’t showing symptoms yet. Freight costs are soaring (when you can get deliveries.) Suppliers are shutting down. And when suppliers are up and running, they’re running behind. Basic consumable supplies are hard to get. Some companies are retooling to make healthcare products.

Yeah, there’s a lot to worry about now.

You can find any number of free webinars on the various COVID-19 issues, offered by both law firms and providers of accounting services. They are, for the most part, worthy of your time if you have questions about how to respond to the various challenges your company is facing.

We’re not going to duplicate their content on this site. Go find one of the freebies and spend an hour getting up to speed.

Having said that, we will offer some thoughts that we have gleaned from thinking about various challenges companies are facing. We’re not lawyers and we’re not your consultants, so there is no guarantee we’ve got this figured out. In the “for what it may be worth” department:

  • Employees who can’t work because they are sick are going to burn through a lot of sick leave. If they are sick, you do not want them coming back to work. Have you considered amending your sick leave policy to offer more sick leave? What about “borrowing” future entitlements? We’re thinking allowable if reasonable in amount.

  • Employees who are sick are going to incur a lot of healthcare expenses. Deductibles, co-pays, etc. They may run up against annual limits. Have you considered covering those expenses on their behalf? That would mean revising your healthcare policies. We’re thinking allowable here as well.

  • Employees who’ve been exposed need to stay away from everybody else for at least 14 days. How should they charge that time? Direct or indirect? What about paid time off? What about administrative leave or stand-by time? (Have you read the CARES Act?) You need a labor charging policy right now to deal with this.

  • Speaking of labor charging policy, what happens if the government denies entry to a site where your employees have been working? What happens if employees can enter, but need to be quarantined for 14 days before they interact with anybody else? What happens if you have to shut down your own office or factory, because somebody with COVID-19 symptoms went into work? You need a policy position for all these contingent events—plus more we haven’t listed.

  • You may have a Forward Pricing Rate Agreement (FPRA) or you may have a Provisional Billing Rate Agreement (PBRA). Or you may be pricing and billing contracts on an individual basis. Whatever your situation, it is almost certain that your 2020 indirect cost rates are going to exceed what you budgeted/forecasted/negotiated. What are you doing about it? Let’s be clear: right now the US Government (and especially DOD and DOE) are concerned about the health of their industrial bases, and they are telling contracting officers to enhance contractor cash flow wherever and whenever possible. Use that policy guidance to negotiate higher bidding and billing rates. Obviously, you don’t know (because nobody does right now) the impact that will be felt by year-end. But don’t let that stop you from making an estimate now and seeing if your CACO/DACO/ACO/PCO is amenable to an upward adjustment. We’re betting most of them will be. You can always adjust later as more information becomes available.

  • Subnote to those who have FPRAs. Read FAR 15.407-4 and comply with its requirements. Even if you don’t adjust your FPRA, you still have an obligation under the Truthful Cost or Pricing Data Act (“TINA”) to make appropriate disclosures.

  • Any number of government contractors have DPAS-rated contracts. Normally, nobody cares about that (except for people who deal with CPSRs) but now it matters, since POTUS invoked the Defense Production Act (which constitutes the first three letters of DPAS). If you have a rated contract, you must do everything you can to keep working. If you did your job and properly flowed-down the DPAS rating to your suppliers, then they have to keep working as well. Which is to say: if your supplier tells you they are shutting down because of COVID-19, you get to tell them NO, they are not shutting down, because their subcontract/PO doesn’t let them. When the auditors question your charging decisions a year or more from now (as they will), your primary defense is going to be the DPAS rating in your contract. (The secondary defense is going to be the CARES Act. The third line of defense is going to be DOD press releases, guidance memoranda, and Class Deviations.)

  • Speaking of future audits, perhaps the single most important thing that contractors can and should be doing right now is to isolate COVID-19-related expenses from the normal routine expenses. Be in a position to show the (future) auditors where your costs increased because of the virus. Create new charge codes where necessary. Create new cost accounts and/or cost centers. Do everything you can to bucket the COVID-19 stuff because, a year or more from now, everybody is going to want to know how much the crisis cost your company.

  • The second most important thing we can think of is documentation. Your company is making a lot of decisions very quickly, and it’s likely that the documentation of those decisions is going to be a low priority. Don’t let it be. Document the circumstances and the rationale for the decisions. That documentation is going to be huge when the auditors challenge you to support why what you did was reasonable under the circumstances.

Whether you are a small contractor or one of the largest contractors, you are facing the same issues and challenges as everybody else. Everybody is struggling to adjust to the new normal and nobody has figured out every answer to every challenge yet. This article is intended to get you thinking about some of the challenges and their possible solutions. The rest is up to you.

 


Page 24 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.