• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

UPDATES: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

E-mail Print PDF


From time to time we post a piece that updates readers on prior articles.  This is one of those times.

The Good

NASA received some criticism from GAO regarding its satellite programs.  GAO reported that nine of 15 large-scale unmanned NASA programs it reviewed had “experienced significant cost and/or schedule growth from their project baselines.”  In another GAO report, eight DOD satellite programs were assessed, and the auditors were concerned about potential capability gaps stemming from misalignment of satellites, ground control systems, and user terminals. 

We tackled a more in-depth look at one such program—the Advanced Extremely High Frequency (AEHF) defense communication satellite—here.  In that article, we opined as follows—

Like many high-tech developmental programs, the AEHF program has been the victim of Pentagon budget wars. While the program undoubtedly suffered from many of the pains associated with trying put a highly secure, classified payload into space, it also suffered from a lack of firm strategic leadership from the Pentagon. The fluctuations in the number of satellites and budgetary uncertainty clearly impacted the contractors at least as much (if not more) than the technical challenges. While it might serve as a good example of out-of-control defense programs, it might also serve as a good example of the impacts of failed leadership.

So we’re happy to report some good news on the AEHF front.  On August 15, 2010, a United Launch Alliance Atlas 5 rocket successfully launched the first AEHF satellite into orbit.  As this article at Aviation Week reported—

Following a four-min., 19-sec. burn of the Russian-built RD-180 booster engine and two burns of the Centaur’s Pratt & Whitney Rocketdyne RL10 engine, the satellite was released at 7:58 a.m. as it flew over the Indian Ocean.

Over the next three months, AEHF-1’s orbit will be circularized so that it flies about 22,300 mi. over the equator at 90 deg. West longitude for satellite checkout and calibration. It will then be relocated to an operational orbit, which will be determined based on needs at the time, officials said. AEHF-1 should be ready to be put into service in early 2011.

The military says one AEHF spacecraft has more capacity than the entire five-member Milstar satellite constellation, with faster data rates to enhance tactical military communications by providing higher-quality maps, targeting data and live video transmissions.

In addition to secure, jam-resistant communications for multiple branches of the U.S. military, AEHF is the first protected satcom to include partner nations, Air Force Capt. Jonathan Pellum says.

‘It’s a game-changing moment,’ Pellum said during a webcast of the launch.

Congratulations to the United Launch Alliance team!

More Good News—or Is It?

We previously reported on the competition for the Small Diameter Bomb Increment II (aka GBU-53/B) development contract in the context of DOD’s return to the use of fixed-price development contracts.  The Air Force was going to choose the winner from two competing teams:  Raytheon and Lockheed Martin/Boeing.  We said at the time—

What we are left with is the distinct impression that use of a fixed-price contract type on developmental programs is a mistake, one that will not lead to good financial results for the ‘winning’ contractor. And the Pentagon will have yet another program with ‘cost growth’ to explain to Congress.

Certainly the Raytheon team had to be considered the underdog, going up as it was against the team of the two largest defense contractors in the U.S.  So Raytheon had to be elated to be awarded the $451 million contract.  As noted in the Defense Industry Daily article (link above)—

Raytheon’s GBU-53/B seeker features 3 modes of operation: millimeter-wave radar, uncooled imaging infrared, and semiactive laser. The  millimeter wave radar will operate through any weather, and is used in weapons like the Hellfire Longbow missile to give them ‘fire and forget’ capability. Their uncooled imaging infrared (IIR) seeker uses high-resolution thermal scans to a similar end, and is better against some kinds of targets like humans. By combining these 2 fire and forget scan modes, the GBU-53 makes it much more difficult to use countermeasures, or decoys. By using an uncooled IIR seeker, the bomb lowers its cost and maintenance requirements. The 3rd guidance mode, semi-active laser, is standard for a wide range of missiles and rockets, and offers the best accuracy and assurance. Its flip side is problematic performance in heavy fog, sandstorms, etc.

So congratulations to Raytheon!  (But be careful what you wish for….)

The Bad

We have reported, several times, on the story of Public Warehousing Company KSC—now called Agility.  We first reported the story here, and subsequently followed the original story with an update.  Despite winning more than $8 billion worth of logistics support work from DOD, the company was indicted in late 2009 for “conspiracy to defraud the United States, committing major fraud against the United States, making false statements, submitting false claims and wire fraud.”  Subsequently, in April, 2010, the Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) announced it was “replacing” Agility and awarding a $2.2. billion follow-on contract to Dubai-based ANHAM FZCO. 

So it was interesting to learn via published reports that the DLA had “decided to extend Agility’s prime vendor contract for six months starting in September, after the current contract ends.”  No details were given, so we can only speculate as to the cause(s) for the action.  For whatever reason, the DLA seems to have trouble kicking-off its contract with the successor firm.

Why is this “bad” news?  Well, it’s bad for Agility, who is still facing serious charges.  And it’s bad for ANHAM FZCO, who is losing out on some quite a bit of revenue.  And it’s bad for DLA and the Army, who seem to have trouble getting their act together.  We’re guessing, though, that it’s good news for the service men and women who depend on Agility and other logistics support contractors to put food on their tables at chow time.

The Ugly

Early in 2010 we reported on complex and rather arcane allegations regarding Boeing’s entitlement to at least $271 million in payments related to its Evolved Expendable Launch Vehicle (EELV) program.  As we opined at the time—

So as with many government contract cost accounting matters, the truth is both complex and hard to fathom. Will Boeing have to concede $271 million in payments to which it believes it is contractually entitled? We’ll look forward to the final DCAA audit report(s), and hope that they ignore any political pressure and focus solely on the facts, which (apparently) even the DOD IG seems to have gotten wrong.

This is a great example of how the facts matter, and how easy it is to allege a problem, and how hard it is to refute an allegation. Clearly, Boeing’s entitlement to the $271 million depends on its ‘Lot Accounting’ practices, why the PM&HS costs were not fully absorbed by prior launch contracts, and how Boeing intended to amortize its production costs under future programs (and whether it would be permitted to do so under FAR and CAS parameters).

Finally, nearly eight months later, DCAA’s position was announced to the media via a nearly unprecedented e-mail statement from Director Fitzgerald.  Director Fitzgerald called on the Defense Contract Management Agency (DCMA) to notify the United Launch Alliance team (of which Boeing is one of two team members, along with Lockheed Martin) that the costs are in non-compliance “with federal accounting standards” and are “unallowable.”  According to the Bloomberg article (link above)—

Debra Bingham, a spokeswoman for the Defense Contract Management Agency, which is reviewing the audit recommendations, said that the agency’s Boeing manager in Huntington Beach, California, plans to render a final decision in November.

The official will review the audit agency’s analysis and recommendation, as well as Boeing’s rebuttal, she said.

We will be surprised if this issue isn’t litigated.



 

SECDEF Gates Gets Serious About DOD “Efficiency”

E-mail Print PDF


Every time we sit down to write about the Pentagon’s latest “efficiency” initiative, more content comes in and we have to start over again.  Well, no more.  We’re drawing the line here and anything that happens after today is fodder for a future article.

To level-set, between “affordability” and “efficiency” this is becoming a cornucopia of news-worthy content.  If SECDEF Gates has his way (and early indications are that he will), then these initiatives are going to shape the Defense acquisition environment for years to come … or at least until the next Administration charts a different course.  If you need to get up to speed, we recommend this article as a good starting place.

Now that you’re ready to go, let’s get started, shall we?

McAleese Points

Early on, Jim McAleese published some very cogent points in his mid-July 2010 presentation to NCMA’s World Congress, based on his analysis of SECDEF’s Eisenhower Library speech and initial DOD discussions.  He said—

  • Secretary Gates’ Eisenhower Speech primarily targeted both excess Flag Officer & Headquarters costs within ‘Military Personnel’ Account, plus excessive recent growth within separate ‘Operations & Maintenance’ Accounts, to generate 2%-3% real growth per year for COIN-intensive Force Structure, plus Modernization Accounts.
  • Secretary Gates did not formally-target large cost savings within RDT&E and Procurement Accounts. To the contrary, those Modernization Accounts were intended to be the beneficiary from cuts to manpower-intensive Headquarters, plus O&M.

Nearly a month later, Sandra Erwin (writing in National Defense magazine) echoed Jim’s prescient points as she discussed the Pentagon’s “winners and losers”.  She wrote—

Winners: Troops in uniform, ship programs, weapons systems that are needed to fight current and future wars.


Losers
: Bloated defense and intelligence agencies, redundant bureaucracies, four-star generals and admirals guilty of ‘brass creep,’’ report writers, white-collar contractors.

After SECDEF Gates’ August 9, 2010 press conference (more on that in a bit), Jim “was fortunate enough” to have been invited to participate in a “small group meeting” with the Secretary of Defense.  Following are some of the discussion points, pulled from Jim’s personal notes (and thus cannot be officially attributed to SECDEF Gates).  Astute readers may notice certain points that echo what we’ve been saying and/or forecasting on this blog for the past two years.

Throughout the meeting, the Secretary's relentless focus on high Headquarter costs; excessive O&M Growth; and excess Program Requirements, genuinely-resonated. There is strong probability that Secretary's personal outreach will result in: (1) increased White House reluctance to target immediate DoD Funding; (2) increased public support; and (3) increased Investment Community support.

Secretary Gates is personally-targeting ‘Fat’; ‘Underperformance’; ‘Poor Business Practices’; and is particularly-sensitive to Congressional & White House perception of poor Acquisition Program Management.

OSD will propose significant Defense Health Program modifications in 2012 Budget, given doubling, and expected tripling, of DoD's Health Care costs. (Paraphrase: ‘The good news is there is increasing recognition within Congress, that Defense Health Care costs are eating us alive.’)

… the Secretary was adamant, given the COIN strain on current Force Structure, plus need for continued Modernization. (Paraphrase: ‘I strongly believe that today's world of terrorist threats, cyber threats, failing states and militarizing peer competitors, is just as dangerous, if not more dangerous, than traditional conventional scenarios. I must make my best case to the President. I am not currently prepared to concede any reduction in current topline DoD Base Funding.’)

As a practical matter, Secretary Gates' targeting of JFCOM; Business Transformation Agency; and Network & Information Integration (NII) will establish a de facto mandate for each Service to eliminate 1-3 Headquarters or lower-value Commands.

Secretary Gates refused to be drawn into discussion of potential changes to specific Modernization Programs, ranging from Army Requirements in GCV, to USMC EFV. However, Secretary Gates made several positive references to specific actions being taken by USD(AT&L) Carter, and specifically-authorized USD(AT&L) to continue growth of Defense Acquisition Workforce.

Previously, Secretary Gates withheld public announcement of 2010 & 2011 Budget decisions until formal release of Budget in February. This preemptive targeting of excess Headquarters Overhead; lower-value O&M; and excess Program Requirements, on the eve of FY2011, is clearly anticipated to achieve two purposes. First, is to generate immediate savings in 2011, presumably with or without 2011 Defense Authorization Act, and under Continuing Resolution in absence of 2011 Defense Appropriations Act. Second, Secretary Gates has clearly undertaken a genuine ‘earnest negotiations’ approach with the Services, to provide incentives for them to make their own internal cuts, to redirect Savings from ‘Generating Forces’ into Combat Operating Forces. This increased Service discretion, plus immediate public transparency, is likely to significantly-increase probability of success of Secretary's ‘Efficiency’ Initiative.

That’s quite a bit of “inside scoop” that most readers won’t see in the mainstream media.  Why don’t you read those points again?  In fact, you should Google McAleese & Associates and go check out Jim’s consultancy—because he is clearly an insider.  (Our thanks to Jim for keeping us “in the loop”.)

Jim was interviewed in early August by Federal News Radio – and here’s a link to his interview.

Lexington Institute Points

Even before the Pentagon undertook its “efficiency” and “affordability” initiatives, Dr. Loren Thompson was concerned about budgetary pressures on the Pentagon, including “insourcing” efforts and the costs of government personnel.  Here’s a link to his article on “the perils of insourcing” and here’s a link to another, similar article where he posits that “Pentagon insourcing undercuts search for savings.”  In the latter article, published in mid-June, Dr. Thompson wrote—

Against this backdrop, its seems obvious that the Obama Administration will have to revisit plans announced last year to ‘insource’ tens of thousands of defense jobs previously contracted out to the private sector. The administration argued that civil servants could carry out many of the contracted tasks more cost-effectively and that the capabilities of the civil service needed to be bolstered, especially for roles deemed to be ‘inherently governmental.’ However, undertaking such conversions requires the government to make long-term financial commitments to federal workers in place of short-term contracts with companies -- commitments that may extend several decades into the future.

A case in point is the plan to expand the Pentagon acquisition corps by adding 10,000 new government workers and converting an additional 10,000 contractor positions to civil-service jobs. It is hard to see why such a move is necessary when policymakers are cutting weapons programs left and right, and the joint force is preparing to reduce the pace of overseas contingency operations. This plan will greatly increase the fixed overhead costs of the defense department at a time when Secretary Gates says those costs need to come down. Relying on contractors has advantages and disadvantages, but at least when their services are no longer needed it is easy to get rid of them and save some money.

Dr. Thompson has written several other relevant articles, which can be found at this link.

Defense-Aerospace.com reprinted one of the Lexington Institute’s commentaries with the headline, “Defense Business Board Warns DoD is Heading for Chapter 11.”  The commentary made some good points, as follows—

The DBB’s characterization of the situation all but likens DoD to Greece. Military retirement requires that the government pay veterans and their families for sixty years based on only twenty years of service. Not only do veterans receive generous, indexed pensions but also lifetime medical care. Almost 25 percent of active duty military personnel serve in commercial activities. Despite fighting two wars, some 40 percent of those in uniform have never deployed anywhere overseas.



The size of headquarters and staffs is increasing relative to the number of warfighters as are their salaries. Like Greece, modern business practices have not been applied to major overhead areas so as to improve efficiencies and reduce costs. Congress has made the problem even worse by increasing the generosity of benefits packages and expanding eligibility.



The DBB proposes a set of modest corrections to what is a massive problem. … Much more is needed. … We could not only cut the number of overseas bases -- like the automobile companies canceling dealer franchises -- but even eliminate low payoff territories. Finally, we could seek a partial merger of capabilities or functions with allied nations. Ultimately, we could even agree to a new division of geographic responsibilities in the world. For example, the EU takes over all responsibilities for Europe short of major war and we assume the burden in East Asia.



Boards and panels with ties to the organizations they are assessing often have a difficult time telling their ‘employers’ the unvarnished truth. The DBB has done an excellent job of telling DoD it must reform or go out of business.

As we previously told readers, the entire DBB “pre-decisional” briefing is available on our website under “knowledge resources”—but only for our members.

Obama Announces Support

On August 9, 2010, as SECDEF Gates was holding his press conference (we’re getting to it), the Pentagon issued a press release touting President Obama’s support for SECDEF Gates’ efficiency initiative.  President Obama’s statement said—

Today’s announcement by Secretary Gates is another step forward in the reform efforts he has undertaken to reduce excess overhead costs, cut waste, and reform the way the Pentagon does business. The funds saved will help us sustain the current force structure and make needed investments in modernization in a fiscally responsible way. Change is never easy, and I applaud Secretary Gates and his team for undertaking this critical effort to support our men and women in uniform and strengthen our national security. These reforms will ensure that our nation is safer, stronger, and more fiscally responsible.

SECDEF Gate’s 8/09/2010 Press Conference (Finally)

The press conference seemed designed to announce that this was not just another in a long line of failed reform efforts, that this time the change was for real.

In this article, Gates discussed the need for a cultural change.  The article announced—

‘My hope and expectation is that the efforts we have launched will lead to the kind of cultural changes that over time become a part of the department's DNA and institutional memory.’  … The only way the department can make such a persuasive case is if it tackles poor acquisition practices, poor business practices, excessive reliance on contractors, waste and abuse, Gates said.  ‘We need to be able to show that we are actually doing something about these programs in a systematic way that affects every part of the department,’ he said. ‘I think under those circumstances, we have a pretty good opportunity to make our case.’

Another Pentagon press release “article” discussed the actual cuts Gates had already made, and would continue to make, to DOD expenditures.  Here’s some verbiage from the announcement—

Today, Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates announced a series of initiatives designed to reduce overhead, duplication, and excess in the Department of Defense, and, over time, instill a culture of savings and restraint in America’s defense institutions.


These initiatives represent the latest of the secretary’s efforts to re-balance the priorities of the department and reform the way the Pentagon does business.


As part of the fiscal 2010 budget, the department curtailed or cancelled nearly 20 troubled or excess programs - programs that if pursued to completion would have cost more than $300 billion. Additional program savings have been recommended in the defense budget request submitted this year.


In May, the secretary called on the department to take a hard, unsparing look at how it is staffed, organized, and operated. The purpose was not to reduce the department’s top line budget - which he considers the minimum needed to sustain a military at war and prepare for future threats - but to significantly reduce its excess overhead costs and apply the savings to force structure and modernization. …

Earlier this summer, the department began a comprehensive effort along several tracks to gain efficiencies, reduce costs, and improve the effectiveness of the DoD enterprise, the results of which will be rolled out as part of the fiscal 2012 budget request. The secretary believes the department can take the following actions immediately rather than waiting for the normal budgeting and programming cycle.

-- The secretary directed a reduction of funding for support contractors by 10 percent a year for each of the next three years. The goal is to reduce the number of contractors that are performing functions that are inherently governmental.


-- To address the personnel growth in the Office of the Secretary of Defense (OSD), the defense agencies, and Combatant Command (COCOM) staffs, the secretary of defense has directed a freeze in the number of OSD, defense agencies and COMCOM billets at the fiscal 2010 levels for next three years.


* With regard to in-sourcing, no more full-time OSD positions will be created after fiscal 2010 to replace contractors except for critical needs.

* These measures are part of a comprehensive re-base lining of OSD, defense agency and COCOM staffing and organization. Starting essentially from scratch, we will conduct a clean sheet review to determine what our people should be doing, where, and at what level of rank in light of this department’s most urgent priorities by Nov. 1.

* As a result of the re-base lining, there will be a minimum reduction of 50 percent of total growth in billets since 2000. This reduction in civilian senior executive and general and flag officer billets shall be achieved over two years.


-- The secretary directed a freeze at fiscal 2010 levels on the number of civilian senior executives, general and flag officer, and PAS positions. By Nov. 1, we will also assess the number and locations of senior positions as well as the overhead and accoutrements that go with them.


-- To achieve greater benefits in cost and efficiency through “economies of scale,” the secretary of defense directed the consolidation of our information technology infrastructure facilities. This action will allow the increased use by the department of common functions and improve our ability to defend defense networks against growing cyber threats.


-- To combat the enormous amounts of taskings for reports and studies both from Congress and from OSD, the secretary of defense directed starting now:


* Freeze in the number of all DoD-required oversight reports;
* Immediate cut in the dollars allocated to advisory studies by 25 percent;
* Track and publish the actual cost of preparation of each reports and studies prepared by DoD in the front of each document; and
* A comprehensive review of all oversight reports and use the results to reduce the volume generated internally while engaging the Congress on ways to meet their needs while working together to reduce the number of reports by Oct. 1.


-- The Office of the Secretary of Defense funds 65 boards and commissions at an annual cost of $75 million. Therefore, the secretary of defense directed a review of all outside boards and commissions, for the purpose of:

* Eliminating those no longer needed;
* Focusing the efforts of those that continue to be relevant;
* Cutting overall funding available for studies tasked by remaining boards and commissions by 25 percent in fiscal 2011.


-- The secretary directed a zero-based review of all of the department’s intelligence missions, organizations, relationships, and contracts with the goal to eliminate needless duplication to be completed by Nov. 1. In addition, the secretary of defense directed an immediate 10 percent reduction in funding for advisory and assistance contractors in this area and a freeze of the number of senior executive positions in defense intelligence organizations.


-- In addition to flattening and trimming structures, the secretary of defense over the next six to 12 months will eliminate two organizations and recommend the closure of another that perform duplicative functions and/or outlived their original purpose.


* Elimination of the assistant secretary of defense networks integration and information, and J6 function, which deal with enterprise information technology and hardware issues. Their essential missions will be performed by other organizations. A re-fashioned Defense Information Systems Agency will perform the department’s CIO function.
* Elimination of the Business Transformation Agency (BTA), which performs day-to-day oversight of individual acquisition programs, a function largely performed by a number of other organizations. BTA’s essential responsibilities will be shifted to the deputy chief management officer.
* Recommend the closure of Joint Forces Command (JFCOM) which was established to infuse jointness into everything the military does, especially the training and providing of forces for operations. Over time, it has created an unneeded extra layer and step in the force management process. JFCOM’s force management and sourcing functions will be assigned to the Joint Staff while the remaining responsibilities will be evaluated and those determined to be essential will be re-assigned to other entities.
* As a result of closing or consolidating these three organizations, a number of civilian employees and contractors will no longer work in the department.


-- To see these initiatives through from announcement to action to measurable results over the next 90 to 120 days, the secretary has appointed a task force chaired by his chief of staff. This task force will develop action plans and oversee their implementation and eventual transition to the appropriate department leadership.


The initiatives announced today represent the last of a four-track effort begun earlier this summer:


-- In June, the military services were assigned the task of finding more than $100 billion in overhead savings over the next five years. The services will be able to keep any of the savings they generate to invest in higher priority warfighting needs.


-- At the same time the department began seeking ideas, suggestions and proposals from other than official channels, including outside experts, think tanks and DoD employees who are being asked to solicit ideas directly via the Internet.


-- The secretary directed a comprehensive assessment of every aspect of how this department is organized and operated to inform the fiscal 2012 budget request.


“Instilling habits of restraint, of subtracting as well as adding, of elevating affordability on a par with desirability, is a project of years in the making,” the secretary concluded in his statement today. “This will reflect itself in ways large and small, substantive and symbolic. My hope and expectation is that the efforts we have launched will lead to the kind of cultural changes that over time become part of this department’s DNA and institutional memory.”

(Apologies for the formatting of the foregoing cut’n’paste. The “emdash” indicates a high-level bullet point, while the asterisk indicates a lower-level point.)  Here is a link to the transcript of his press conference.

Another DOD press release described the press conference as “putting meat on the bones of his initiative to reform the way the Pentagon does business and to eliminate duplicative, unnecessary overhead costs.”

Reactions

Predictably, critics were quick to attack the initiative.  Our friends at the Lexington Institute said—

Using the Secretary’s own figures, cutting reports, boards and defense organizations will save, at best, $1 billion. This piddling amount will only be realized if everyone in the named organizations were fired and the gates of the facilities padlocked. But this will not be the case, as the Secretary admitted. Many of the functions of those star-crossed organizations will be transferred to other parts of DoD, requiring people to perform them. So, at best the savings will only be a small fraction of their total budgets.

The only way to save real money is to close offices, stop performing their functions and show the people employed there the door. One of the problems with past efforts to save money through base closure and realignment is that the functions performed on the facilities being closed were moved to other facilities along with the personnel slots to perform them. People either moved to the new facility and organization or new people were hired. Because of the increase in people and workload, the bases receiving these functions built additional facilities. Just look at all the building going on in places like Fort Belvoir, Virginia, and Huntsville, Alabama, both of which are experiencing major influxes of people from facilities being closed as a result of the last round of base closures. So, in the end, very little will be saved.

We note that Gates’ decision to curtail “insourcing” should lead to some real savings.  Why?  Check out this article.

In another piece, the Lexington Institute wrote that the efficiency initiative faced “insurmountable obstacles” because of lack of Congressional support. 

Indeed, almost immediately members of Congress sought to keep Gates from cutting any part of the DOD bureaucracy—at least in their districts.  This Washington Post article reports that at least one Virginia Senator (who’s a former Secretary of the Navy) thinks that Gates cannot actually reduce his headcount without going through the arduous base realignment and closure (BRAC) process.  The Post article quotes Senator Webb as saying, "a strong legal case can be made that the base-closure statutes are applicable because this involves a reduction of more than 1,000 civilian personnel."  That same article quotes Virginia Congressman Robert Scott (D) as saying, “Even if it's not technically the letter of the law, the spirit of the law is clearly implicated" by the secretary's action.  According to the article—

Scott, Webb and other members of the Virginia congressional delegation -- Sen. Mark Warner (D) and Reps. Glenn Nye (D), J. Randy Forbes (R) and Rob Wittman (R) -- sent a letter to Gates on Friday expressing their ‘deep disappointment and concern’ over his plan, saying it would result in ‘the dismissal of thousands of highly skilled civilians and defense contractors.’

The dance is only beginning.  Stay tuned for the rest of the show.



 

DOD Officials Defend DCAA

E-mail Print PDF


DCAA has received perhaps more than its fair share of criticism over the past couple of years.  We have even doled out some of the criticism ourselves.  In November, 2009, Patrick Fitzgerald replaced April Stephenson as Director of the Defense Contract Audit Agency, and many of us hoped the new leadership would guide the agency away from the problems caused by its truculent attitude.  But Mr. Fitzgerald has yet to create any substantive reforms, and recent audit guidance gives little—if any—reason for optimism that DCAA is going to rejoin the ranks of the Defense acquisition corps as a valued (and value-added) member. 

Various commenters have questioned the audit agency’s commitment to change.  In this article, we reported on a blog post from POGO in which the author thought the auditors were playing too nice with the Defense Contract Management Agency (DCMA).  He wrote—

But on the other hand—and I think this is probably the case—this memo demonstrates another instance where DCAA's independent audit findings may be undermined. The memo states that auditors and contracting officers should work together to ‘resolve’ audit issues and emphasized that even when differences occur, DCMA and DCAA should strive to work the issues within the respective organizations. This memo gives the impression that audit findings are something to be ‘resolved’ between the two organizations rather than audit findings to be acted upon by the contracting officer. And to the degree that this is the case, or that this memo confuses the independent role of DCAA, the Director of DCAA should consider withdrawing the memo.

In another article, we reported that the same gadfly group (POGO) had sent a letter to influential senators in March, 2010, telling them that—

We worry that these problems are indicative of a systemic strategy for reform that seeks to decrease congressional pressure rather than to institute meaningful reform. More importantly, we think that it would be naïve to assume that removing April Stephenson from DCAA solves the systemic problems at DCAA.

Perhaps becoming a bit impatient with the lack of substantive reform, Congress weighed-in, proposing legislation (H.R. 5013) that would mandate reforms to the agency—reforms that the agency seems reluctant to make.

The foregoing provides some context for a “viewpoint” posted on FederalTimes.com, written by Robert Hale (Undersecretary of Defense, Comptroller) and Mr. Fitzgerald.  The piece, entitled “DCAA Working to Improve Audit Quality, Management,” recapped the progress made in reforming the admittedly “tarnished” audit agency.  The progressive actions that have been taken are nothing new to anybody who reads our articles and, in fact, tend to mask the agency’s continued failure to address its withdrawal from—and, indeed, active attempts to sabotage—the Defense acquisition system in the name of “independence” and compliance with generally accepted government auditing standards. 

Suffice to say, we were not impressed.

Nor were the few commenters who posted their thoughts.  One comment, posted on the POGO site, had this to say—

These must be the only two people in DoD that think DCAA is on the right track! The audits need to be timely, e.g. issued before the need no longer exists, to be meaningful. Please if there is anyone out there that is receiving timely reports fro DCAA, please post the info here so we can share in their glory. I suggest Mr.Hale and Mr. Fizgerald share some success stories concerning timely reports, I bet there aren't many to share. Just how many reports has DCAA issued this FY in total? I hear auditors spend most of there time waiting for their reports to be issued. None of the auditors I've spoken with consider themsevles busy, most would wlecome more work if the resulting reports would be issued.

We deplore the grammar and spelling, yet sympathize with the sentiments expressed.



 

Camp Arifjan, Kuwait—Another Den of Iniquity?

E-mail Print PDF


When we wrote about Bagram Airfield, located in Afghanistan, we asked rhetorically, “Is Bagram just another military base, with the number of corrupt fraudsters simply in proportion to its overall population? Or is it something more—perhaps a poster child for failed leadership and ineffective oversight and missing controls.”  Those were some harsh words, perhaps—but we were upset from the sheer quantity of stories of corruption emanating from the Army Airbase.  Now we are hearing about a place that sounds even more corrupt, and home to even more pernicious perfidy, than Bagram.

And what’s more, this place isn’t located in the direct line of fire.  Sure, it supports the warfighters, but it’s located far behind the front-lines, far away from mortars and suicide sappers. 

We’re talking about Camp Arifjan, Kuwait.

Wikipedia has this to say about Camp Arifjan—

Camp Arifjan is an Army installation located in the State of Kuwait which accommodates elements of the US Air Force, US Navy, US Marine Corps and US Coast Guard.  The camp was funded and built by the government of Kuwait. … Camp Arifjan is a US military installation utilized as a forward logistics base, Aviation Classification and Repair Activity Depot (Task Force AVCRAD) for the entire Southwest Asian Theater (through Patton Army Air Field), helicopter ground support base, and as a motor pool for armored and unarmored vehicles.

An “insider’s view” of life at the Camp reports the following—

Camp Arifjan is a wierd place, and sort of a mixture between busy military installation, hip university campus, grimy industrial park, and stark correctional facility. Nevertheless, the quality of life is surprisingly good. The Morale, Welfare, and Recreation (MWR) facilities rival those of many stateside installations. There are two large PXs, several fast food places, two nice recreational centers, a state-of-the-art gym, and even a wood crafts shop. Nearly all indoor facilities have air conditioning. There's a large outdoor pool and several athletic fields. The quality of the food and service at the three dining facilities is exceptional. Bottled water (and even Gatorade) is readily available. … Your work environment will vary greatly on your section's "likership" and mission requirements. Some work standard duty day hours, while others maintain 24-hour operations in shift. As with any workplace, some work hard for big results, while a few work little for little results, and still others work hard for no results. The near-constant rotation of individual replacements from all service components and backgrounds ensures a perpetual state of institutionalized uncertainty.

Moreover, the author describes the Arifjan nightlife as “vibrant” but offers no specifics.

So much for background.  Let’s move on to another point of view—that of the Department of Justice, who reported on August 11, 2010, that Wajdi Birjas, age 39, of Evansville, Indiana, had pleaded guilty to “conspiracy to bribe U.S. Army contracting officials stationed at Camp Arifjan” as well as to money laundering conspiracy.  The DOJ reported that—

The charge of bribery conspiracy carries a maximum prison sentence of five years and a $250,000 fine. The money laundering conspiracy charge carries a maximum prison sentence of 20 years and a $250,000 fine. Under the plea agreement, Birjas agreed to forfeit $675,000 to the government.

So if Mr. Birjas gets the maximum sentence (which is doubtful) he’ll be released when he’s 64 years old. What did he do?  The DOJ stated that he was a “contract employee at the Host Nation Affairs office,” where he was responsible for “identifying Kuwaiti companies able to provide certain goods and services to the U.S. military in Kuwait.”  While assigned to Camp Arifjan—

… Birjas, acting at the direction of a contractor working in Kuwait, developed corrupt relationships with certain Army contracting officials, including Christopher Murray, James Momon and a sergeant first class deployed to Camp Arifjan as a senior procurement non-commissioned officer (NCO.) By bribing these Army contracting officials … the contractor ultimately received a total of more than $1.7 million in connection with contracts to provide various goods and services to the U.S. military. In exchange for his assistance in the bribery scheme, Birjas received a share of the profits that the contracts generated and was allowed to live rent-free in a villa that contained a hidden safe.

Court documents indicate that Birjas paid Murray approximately $10,000; paid the senior procurement NCO approximately $14,000; and paid the airplane and hotel expenses of a co-conspirator and Momon to celebrate New Year’s eve in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. According to the court documents, Birjas also allowed Momon to hide hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of his bribe money in Birjas’s safe.

Birjas admitted that he agreed to arrange for $250,000 of Momon’s bribe money to be transferred from Kuwait to the United States, after Momon had returned to the United States at the end of his tour. Birjas admitted to working out this agreement with the third Army officer and one of his associates, a former master sergeant in the Army who operated a concession to sell clothing at U.S. military bases in Kuwait. According to court documents, Birjas delivered approximately $85,000 worth of Momon’s bribe money to the former master sergeant for ultimate delivery to Momon.

But that’s not all. If that were all to the story, we’d simply shrug and get back to bashing DCAA audit guidance.  The DOJ added this little gem toward the end of the press release—

The case against Birjas arose out of an investigation into corruption at the Kuwait contracting office at Camp Arifjan, which has led to charges against 14 individuals. Of those 14 defendants, 12 have pleaded guilty to their crimes, with some are already serving prison sentences. For example, on Dec. 2, 2009, former U.S. Army Major John Cockerham was sentenced to 210 months in prison and ordered to pay $9.6 million in restitution. On Dec. 17, 2009, Murray was sentenced to 57 months in prison and ordered to pay $245,000 in restitution. On Aug. 13, 2008, Momon pleaded guilty to receiving approximately $1.6 million in bribes and agreed to pay $5.7 million in restitution. On Feb. 18, 2010, Army contractor Terry Hall pleaded guilty to bribery conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy and agreed to forfeit $15.7 million to the U.S. government in connection with his payment of more than $3 million in bribes to Cockerham, Momon, Murray and former Army Major Eddie Pressley. The case against Hall’s co-defendants, Eddie Pressley and Eurica Pressley, is scheduled for trial on Nov. 29, 2010, in Decatur, Ala.

14 corrupt U.S. Army contracting officials at one single base?  Is this a joke?

We griped about lax oversight and ineffective controls in the article on Bagram.  When we wrote about Captain Mike—who did everything he could to get caught, but who would have gotten away with his crimes but for those meddling kids his neighbors who reported him to the IRS—we bemoaned the failed command environment and asked whether his commanding officer was disciplined for negligence.  (Apparently, Captain Mike’s CO kept a safe with about a million dollars in it and never checked to see how much was still there, even after Captain Mike rotated back to the States.)  But we never imagined a military base so corrupt that 14 individuals “who were regularly receiving unlawful payments” could operate for so long without getting caught.

Camp Arifjan may just have set the bar—at a new low—for government contract-related corruption.

Which is emphatically not a good thing.



 

Contractors Pay Penalties for Kickbacks

E-mail Print PDF


We’ve written about kickbacks before.  We did a quick search of the site’s news archive, and found eight articles dealing with kickbacks, including this article that discusses (in some depth) the FAR prohibition on accepting kickbacks (found at § 3.502), in the context of allegations that employees of KBR accepted “unlawful kickbacks in the form of meals, drinks, tickets to sports events and golf outings” as well as this one, discussing EMC’s $87.5 million False Claims Act settlement, related to inaccurate disclosure of commercial pricing practices and an “illegal kickback scheme” related to its contract with the General Services Administration (GSA).  We’ve got kickbacks covered.

Another large, well-known company was recently in the news, related to a settlement with the Department of Justice over practices related to its GSA schedule contracts.  That company was Hewlett-Packard, one of the largest (if not in fact the single largest) technology company in the America.  HP, who coincidentally saw its CEO resign for inappropriate conduct in the same week, reportedly settled with DOJ for a figure in the $47 - $50 million range.

Details of the allegations and settlement are sketchy.  Perhaps the best report we have been able to find is here, at the Financial Times.  According to the FT story—

The justice department eventually intervened in a False Claims Act case brought by Normal Rille and Neal Roberts in federal court in Arkansas.  Their suit said that HP paid a list of systems integrators millions of dollars in ‘influencer fees’ if they successfully put HP products forward in government deals. The integrators had an obligation to act in the government’s best interest but did not, the suit said.

The number one computer maker also gave ‘New Business Opportunity’ payments when it was included as a subcontractor on government contracts. Those payments were not intended to be passed on to the government agency, and the same products could have been obtained with volume pricing deals that would have reduced the payments, according to the suit.

Both types of payments met the definition of kickbacks in federal laws designed to stop overcharging, the suit said.

A dozen other technology companies were implicated in the case as well.

According to the FT story, HP denies the allegations, but believed that settling with the DOJ was in the best interests of its shareholders.  (It often is.)  Nonetheless, HP took a $0.02/share hit to earnings in its Q3 results.

In completely unrelated news, here’s an article from the Tri-Cities area near Hanford, Washington—home of one of the nation’s largest active nuclear waste clean-up efforts.  According to the article, Greg Detloff has been charged with 27 counts of wire fraud, one count of conspiracy, and one count of witness tampering.  The article states that the wire fraud counts are related to “federal credit card fraud.”  Each of the 29 charges is punishable by 20 years in prison and a $250,000 fine.  So we’re talking about 580 years in prison and $5 million in fines, should Mr. Detloff be found guilty.  That could set one’s vacation plans back quite a bit.

Mr. Detloff has pleaded not guilty to the charges.  But what did he do to merit such attention from the Feds?

The article states that, while employed as a material coordinator by two Hanford contractors (Fluor Hanford and CH2M Hill Hanford Group), Mr. Detloff is alleged to have conspired with Martin Perez, who was employed as a salesman by Kennewick Industrial and Electrical Supply (KIE).  They (allegedly) agreed that Detloff, acting for the contractor(s), would purchase “supplies and materials” from KIE—if KIE agreed to order those supplies from Detloff Industries—which was a company owned by his wife and operated out of the family home.

The article reports that “Perez received a 3.5 percent commission on orders placed by Detloff, and the Detloffs received their net profit from all materials and supplies sold by Detloff Industries through KIE.”  Even though Detloff Industries was an approved Hanford supplier, and even though there have been no allegations that prices paid by the contractors (and ultimately the Department of Energy) were higher than they otherwise would have been, the relationship (allegedly) created a clear conflict of interest.

According to the article, “The case against Detloff and Perez was one of three cases alleging fraud in Hanford purchases filed this spring in federal court. Defendants have pleaded innocent and the first case could go to trial as soon as September.”

This article from May, 2010, provides some details on the other alleged fraudsters.  First, it notes that Detloff (allegedly) used a corporate credit card to make the purchases from KIE, so that’s where the federal credit card fraud charges come from.  The article also reports that—

In a second indictment, federal prosecutors filed wire fraud charges against Suzie Zuniga, who held a job similar to Detloff’s while working for Fluor Hanford.  The same indictment includes charges against Tommy L. Honeycutt Jr., a former pipe fitter for a Hanford company; and Pedro Alvarado Jr., a former driver.  The indictment said that between 2004 and 2008, Zuniga used a company card issued to her by Fluor Hanford to authorize purchases that totaled almost $560,000.  It alleges Zuniga, Honeycutt and Alvarado prepared phony invoices for purchases of supplies or materials from a number of vendors approved for Hanford’s Plutonium Finishing Plant.

In addition, the article reports that—

… federal prosecutors filed fraud charges against … Paul F. Kempf and his wife, Anita M. Gust, alleging the couple bilked two Hanford contractors out of roughly $500,000 through unauthorized purchases. The charges allege Kempf, a former manager at Fluor Hanford and then at CH2M Hill Hanford, and Gust used phony product orders to obtain personal items or cover personal expenses from 2001 to 2005.

These stories are not necessarily related in an obvious way.  HP allegedly paid kickbacks in order to have its products recommended for Government purchase, and the Hanford miscreants allegedly participated in more prosaic, blue-collar types of purchasing fraud.  Yet all the stories point to a need to establish internal controls over the acquisition function—whether it be sell-side “business development” or buy-side “purchasing/supply chain management”.  And once those controls are in place, an independent compliance function needs to periodically probe for violations.

Post-Script

After we sent our article to press (well, to the webmaster) details emerged regarding the transgressions that led to the resignation of Hewlett-Packard’s CEO, Mr. Mark Hurd.  Although we noted Mr. Hurd’s resignation in passing—saying “HP, who coincidentally saw its CEO resign for inappropriate conduct in the same week, reportedly settled with DOJ for a figure in the $47 - $50 million range”—it turns out that the transgressions may not have been so coincidental after all.  We were writing about (alleged) procurement fraud at the Hanford nuclear waste site, which involved (among other things) fraudulent purchase orders, expense reports, and credit card activities.  Turns out Mr. Hurd would fit right in with our “blue-collar” (alleged) miscreants.

According to this article (one of many we could have linked to), Mr. Hurd was exonerated of the sexual harassment charges of which he was accused.  But the investigation revealed several instances of falsified expense reports regarding his “management consultant.”  We’ll let the Wall Street Journal take it from here—

Mr. Hurd was forced to resign last week, ostensibly for filing false expense reports amounting to about $20,000. H-P deemed this sum ‘not material,’ which is beside the point. Anything related to Mr. Hurd's departure is plainly material, since on Monday the news shaved $8.7 billion off H-P's market value. … Apart from the expense-report issues, exactly what services was Ms. Fisher performing for H-P? The company said she was an outside marketing consultant, and its general counsel indicated she may not have provided all the services she contracted for. But what were those services, and what were Ms. Fisher's qualifications? Her resume doesn't include an M.B.A., to put it mildly, although it appears she did work in real estate and in sales for Xerox in addition to her movie work and appearance on NBC's ‘Age of Love.’ Supposedly she was a glorified hostess at H-P sales events, making sure big clients got face time with Mr. Hurd. Who hired her and why, based on what qualifications?

Nice.  Notice that what’s not said by the WSJ author in the foregoing speaks volumes about what may have really been going on.  Just to remind readers, we’ve covered the use (and misuse) of consultants before.  And we’ve discussed “tone at the top” before, as well.




 


Page 228 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.