Federal
Acquisition Circular (FAC) 2005-45 was published in the Federal
Register on August 30, 2010. Among the several FAR revisions was the
final rule implementing FAR Case 2005-036, Definition of Cost or Pricing
Data. As the FAC Introduction states—
This
final rule amends the FAR by redefining ‘cost or pricing data,’ adding a
definition of ‘certified cost or pricing data,’ and changing the term
‘information other than cost or pricing data’ to ‘data other than
certified cost or pricing data.’ The rule clarifies the existing
authority for contracting officers to require certified cost or pricing
data or data other than certified cost or pricing data, and the existing
requirements for submission of the various types of pricing data. The
rule is required to eliminate confusion and misunderstanding, especially
regarding the authority of the contracting officer to request data
other than certified cost or pricing data when there is no other means
to determine that proposed prices are fair and reasonable. Most
significantly, the rule clarifies that data other than certified cost or
pricing data may include the identical types of data as certified cost
or pricing data but without the certification. Because the rule
clarifies existing requirements, it will have only minimal impact on the
Government, offerors, and automated systems.
Currently,
definitions of “cost or pricing data” and “information other than cost
or pricing data” are found in FAR 2.101, Definitions. The rules that
tell Contracting Officers when to obtain the data in support of their
cost and/or cost realism analyses, is found at FAR 15.4, Contract
Pricing. This FAR subpart implements the Truth in Negotiations Act (TINA). (We note that another FAR Case implemented in the FAC raised the TINA threshold from $650,000 to $700,000.)
The
rules in this area are complex and, generally, poorly understood by
both Government and contractor. Here is the current policy, as set forth
in FAR 15.402—
Contracting officers must—
(a)
Purchase supplies and services from responsible sources at fair and
reasonable prices. In establishing the reasonableness of the offered
prices, the contracting officer must not obtain more information than is
necessary. To the extent that cost or pricing data are not required by 15.403-4, the contracting officer must generally use the following order of preference in determining the type of information required:
(1) No additional information from the offeror, if the price is based on adequate price competition, except as provided by 15.403-3(b).
(2) Information other than cost or pricing data:
(i) Information related to prices (e.g.,
established catalog or market prices or previous contract prices),
relying first on information available within the Government; second, on
information obtained from sources other than the offeror; and, if
necessary, on information obtained from the offeror. When obtaining
information from the offeror is necessary, unless an exception under 15.403-1(b)(1)
or (2) applies, such information submitted by the offeror shall
include, at a minimum, appropriate information on the prices at which
the same or similar items have been sold previously, adequate for
evaluating the reasonableness of the price.
(ii) Cost information, that does not meet the definition of cost or pricing data at 2.101.
(3) Cost or pricing data.
The contracting officer should use every means available to ascertain
whether a fair and reasonable price can be determined before requesting
cost or pricing data. Contracting officers must not require
unnecessarily the submission of cost or pricing data, because it leads
to increased proposal preparation costs, generally extends acquisition
lead time, and consumes additional contractor and Government resources. …
Given
the complexity of the current regulatory scheme, it is unsurprising
that the revisions are complex as well. Despite the name of the FAR
Case, the major revisions seem to focus on “information other than cost
or pricing data” rather than “cost or pricing data”. Here’s a link
to the official Federal Register notice setting forth the various
revisions. You should review it carefully. Here are some of the points
that we noticed—
-
A
new definition of “certified cost or pricing data” has been added, to
emphasize the need to submit a Certificate of Current Cost or Pricing
Data.
-
The current definition of
“cost or pricing data” has been “refined” to emphasize that it
encompasses “all the facts that can be reasonably expected to contribute
to the soundness of estimates of future costs and to the validity of
determinations of costs already incurred.”
-
The
phrase “information other than cost or pricing data” (which covers
information submitted by offerors that are not cost or pricing data) has
been renamed “data other than certified cost or pricing data”.
The new definition of “data other than certified cost or pricing data” includes the following—
… pricing
data, cost data, and judgmental information necessary for the
contracting officer to determine a fair and reasonable price or to
determine cost realism. Such data may include the identical types of
data as certified cost or pricing data, consistent with Table 15–2 of
15.408, but without the certification. The data may also include, for
example, sales data and any information reasonably required to explain
the offeror’s estimating process, including, but not limited to—
(1)
The judgmental factors applied and the mathematical or other methods
used in the estimate, including those used in projecting from known
data; and
(2) The nature and amount of any contingencies included in the proposed price.
For comparison purposes, we show the revised FAR 15.4 below—
15.402 Pricing policy.
Contracting officers shall—
(a)
Purchase supplies and services from responsible sources at fair and
reasonable prices. In establishing the reasonableness of the offered
prices, the contracting officer—
(1)
Shall obtain certified cost or pricing data when required by 15.403–4,
along with data other than certified cost or pricing data as necessary
to establish a fair and reasonable price; or
(2)
When certified cost or pricing data are not required by 15.403–4,
obtain data other than certified cost or pricing data as necessary to
establish a fair and reasonable price, generally using the following
order of preference in determining the type of data required:
(i) No additional data from the offeror, if the price is based on adequate price competition, except as provided by 15.403–3(b).
(ii) Data other than certified cost or pricing data such as—
(A) Data related to prices (e.g., established
catalog or market prices, sales to non-governmental and governmental
entities), relying first on data available within the Government;
second, on data obtained from sources other than the offeror; and, if
necessary, on data obtained from the offeror. When obtaining data from
the offeror is necessary, unless an exception under
15.403–1(b)(1)
or (2) applies, such data submitted by the offeror shall include, at a
minimum, appropriate data on the prices at which the same or similar
items have been sold previously, adequate for evaluating the
reasonableness of the price.
(B) Cost data to the extent necessary for the contracting officer to determine a fair and reasonable price.
(3)
Obtain the type and quantity of data necessary to establish a fair and
reasonable price, but not more data than is necessary. Requesting
unnecessary data can lead to increased proposal preparation costs,
generally extend acquisition lead time, and consume additional
contractor and Government resources. Use techniques such as, but not
limited to, price analysis, cost analysis, and/or cost realism analysis
to establish a fair and reasonable price. If a fair and reasonable price
cannot be established by the contracting officer from the analyses of
the data obtained or submitted to date, the contracting officer shall
require the submission of additional data sufficient for the contracting
officer to support the determination of the fair and reasonable price.
We
notice that the prohibition on obtaining cost or pricing data when
certain conditions (e.g., adequate competition) are found has been
de-emphasized in favor of a more detailed discussion of the types of
data the contracting officer should obtain. This appears to represent a
return to a pre-Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act (FASA) pricing
environment, which may add to contractors’ proposal costs— meaning that,
ultimately, the Government may end up paying more for the goods and
services it, acquires.
There
is quite a bit to absorb in the new rule(s). Some of the language seems
favorable. Although we don’t necessarily like the revised emphasis on
obtaining cost or pricing data (certified or not), we believe
contractors should be able to navigate through the rocks and shoals, if
they take the time to understand the revised requirements.