• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

Memories of the Big 4

E-mail Print PDF


The large cadre of consultants here at Apogee Consulting, Inc.—you know, the hundreds of consultants who are waiting by the phone for you to call—come from the “Big 4” world of professional service firms. As this Wikipedia article explains, “The Big Four are the four largest international accountancy and professional services firms, which handle the vast majority of audits for publicly traded companies as well as many private companies, creating an oligopoly in auditing large companies.” And they provide consulting services to government contractors, of all sizes, in all industries, as well—which is where we cut our teeth.


PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, Ernst & Young LLP, KPMG LLP, Deloitte LLP. These are the Big 4. And we spent many years working for the audit partnerships.


If you’ve never worked in such an environment, it’s a unique one—trust us. Here are three videos that we found on YouTube, that brought back lots of memories. We thought we’d post them for others to enjoy.


A couple of introductory words first.


Number one, these videos contain lots of Not-Safe-For-Work language. Lots of bad words. No bad images, but lots of bad words. You have been warned.


Second, if you’ve never worked in the firms, you might think these videos are exaggerated and do not depict the reality of the work environment. Trust us, they are spot-on 100% accurate. There are lots of positive aspects of working for the Big 4. But these videos accurately depict some of the less-than-savory aspects.


Enjoy.


Video No. 1 – A Moment in the Life of the Auditor




Video No. 2 – Annual Performance Reviews




Video No. 3 – Project Plans





Perhaps these videos offend you. If so, please accept our apologies. But most folks think they’re funny. We hope you enjoyed them as much as we did.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

Final Inflation Adjustments to Acquisition Thresholds

E-mail Print PDF

We previously reported on significant revisions to the implementation of TINA in the Federal Acquisition Regulation, as implemented by Federal Acquisition Circular (FAC) 2005-45 on August 30, 2010. FAC 2005-45 also implemented changes to key acquisition-related thresholds, based on inflation adjustments calculated from changes to the Consumer Price Index. Every five years, the FAR Councils review the CPI changes and adjust certain “heavily used” thresholds.


These thresholds matter, because they determine when various FAR contract compliance requirements kick-in. Put another way, in order to ascertain the compliance risk associated with a solicitation or contract, one looks at which FAR requirements are invoked—and those requirements vary based on which acquisition threshold has been invoked.


We reported on the proposed rule changes here. As the FAR Councils stated, between the proposed rule and the final rule, “some of the thresholds changed due to lower inflation than was projected at the time of publication of the proposed rule.”


The final rule establishes the following acquisition-related thresholds—


  • The micro-purchase base threshold of $3,000 (FAR 2.101) is not changed.

  • The simplified acquisition threshold (FAR 2.101) is raised from $100,000 to $150,000.

  • Commercial items test program ceiling (FAR 13.500) is raised from $5,500,000 to $6,500,000.

  • The cost or pricing data threshold (FAR 15.403-4) is raised from $650,000 to $700,000.

  • The prime contractor subcontracting plan (FAR 19.702) floor is raised from $550,000 to $650,000, and the construction threshold of $1,000,000 increases to $1,500,000.



 

Latest Dreamliner Drama Involves Exploding Engine

E-mail Print PDF

 

In late August, 2010, Boeing announced yet another delay to the first delivery of its 787 “Dreamliner” passenger aircraft. The Dreamliner, which has been plagued by problems and delays, is now due for first delivery in the first quarter of 2011, according to this Los Angeles Times article. The LA Times article reported that—


The new delay is largely because of the failure of a Rolls-Royce Trent 1000 test engine, which broke apart internally while being run on a ground-test stand at the engine maker's plant in Derby, England, this month.


We have reported on Dreamliner problems before—notably here and here. We have looked at Dreamliner supply chain management problems here—calling it a poster child of “what not to do.” And, to be clear, this is just the latest of a series of seemingly “surprise” production delays. As the LA Times noted, “In July, Boeing said poor workmanship on 787 horizontal tails built by Italian partner Alenia might cause first delivery to slip into the first weeks of 2011.” Boeing has already made at least $1 billion worth of loss provisions for the troubled program.


Remember, the first delivery was originally planned for May, 2008, according to this chronology.


What’s going on? We have no special insider information. But we can use Internet search engines. We found this great blog article over at The Economist. In that article, the author wondered if Boeing’s engineering talent has simply deteriorated to the point where the company has lost the formula of how to design and build great airplanes. The blog linked to a satirical piece over at The Onion—


Boeing Lays Off Only Guy Who Knows How To Keep Wings On Plane

CHICAGO—With the airline industry continuing to suffer under the ongoing recession, the Boeing Company was forced Monday to lay off Al Freedman, the only guy left at the corporation who knows how to keep wings from falling off planes. "We used to have a whole team of engineers who knew how to make the wings stay on, but those days are long gone," Boeing CEO James McNerney, Jr. said. "We'll make it work, though. The wings are not necessarily the most important part of the plane, anyway." McNerney added that at least they were able to save the job of the guy who knows how to prevent jet engines from exploding.


All attempts at humor aside, the blogger on The Economist site had a good point to make. The author wrote—


When The Onion starts making fun of your company's problems, you're in trouble. It means that those problems are well-known enough to be funny to a mass audience. That's the sign of a badly damaged reputation. … The way things have been going, it looks like Boeing's—and the Dreamliner's—problems may only get worse.


Indeed. This article reported that


The Boeing Co.’s sixth postponement of its 787 Dreamliner could put the planemaker at greater risk for paying penalties to customers frustrated by more than 21/2 years of delays. …


Even before Friday’s delay, Deutsche Bank AG analyst Myles Walton estimated that penalty payments to 787 buyers could reach about $5 billion. Boeing will probably try to use discounts, maintenance agreements, options, purchase rights, delivery-slot availability and other means instead of cash payments, Walton said.



Boeing already faces compensation claims for late 787s. National Aviation Co. of India Ltd., Air India’s state-owned parent, said this month that it plans to seek about $840 million for the delays in its order.



‘There’s a slippery slope here,’ said George Hamlin, president of Hamlin Transportation Consulting in Fairfax, Va., and a former Airbus SAS executive. ‘If some carriers start receiving penalties, all will want them. It’s unfortunate that this is coming piled on top of the earlier delays.’






 

 

Changes to “Cost or Pricing Data” Federal Acquisition Rules

E-mail Print PDF

Federal Acquisition Circular (FAC) 2005-45 was published in the Federal Register on August 30, 2010. Among the several FAR revisions was the final rule implementing FAR Case 2005-036, Definition of Cost or Pricing Data. As the FAC Introduction states—


This final rule amends the FAR by redefining ‘cost or pricing data,’ adding a definition of ‘certified cost or pricing data,’ and changing the term ‘information other than cost or pricing data’ to ‘data other than certified cost or pricing data.’ The rule clarifies the existing authority for contracting officers to require certified cost or pricing data or data other than certified cost or pricing data, and the existing requirements for submission of the various types of pricing data. The rule is required to eliminate confusion and misunderstanding, especially regarding the authority of the contracting officer to request data other than certified cost or pricing data when there is no other means to determine that proposed prices are fair and reasonable. Most significantly, the rule clarifies that data other than certified cost or pricing data may include the identical types of data as certified cost or pricing data but without the certification. Because the rule clarifies existing requirements, it will have only minimal impact on the Government, offerors, and automated systems.


Currently, definitions of “cost or pricing data” and “information other than cost or pricing data” are found in FAR 2.101, Definitions. The rules that tell Contracting Officers when to obtain the data in support of their cost and/or cost realism analyses, is found at FAR 15.4, Contract Pricing. This FAR subpart implements the Truth in Negotiations Act (TINA). (We note that another FAR Case implemented in the FAC raised the TINA threshold from $650,000 to $700,000.)


The rules in this area are complex and, generally, poorly understood by both Government and contractor. Here is the current policy, as set forth in FAR 15.402—


Contracting officers must—



(a) Purchase supplies and services from responsible sources at fair and reasonable prices. In establishing the reasonableness of the offered prices, the contracting officer must not obtain more information than is necessary. To the extent that cost or pricing data are not required by 15.403-4, the contracting officer must generally use the following order of preference in determining the type of information required:



(1) No additional information from the offeror, if the price is based on adequate price competition, except as provided by 15.403-3(b).



(2) Information other than cost or pricing data:



(i) Information related to prices (e.g., established catalog or market prices or previous contract prices), relying first on information available within the Government; second, on information obtained from sources other than the offeror; and, if necessary, on information obtained from the offeror. When obtaining information from the offeror is necessary, unless an exception under 15.403-1(b)(1) or (2) applies, such information submitted by the offeror shall include, at a minimum, appropriate information on the prices at which the same or similar items have been sold previously, adequate for evaluating the reasonableness of the price.



(ii) Cost information, that does not meet the definition of cost or pricing data at 2.101.



(3) Cost or pricing data. The contracting officer should use every means available to ascertain whether a fair and reasonable price can be determined before requesting cost or pricing data. Contracting officers must not require unnecessarily the submission of cost or pricing data, because it leads to increased proposal preparation costs, generally extends acquisition lead time, and consumes additional contractor and Government resources. …


Given the complexity of the current regulatory scheme, it is unsurprising that the revisions are complex as well. Despite the name of the FAR Case, the major revisions seem to focus on “information other than cost or pricing data” rather than “cost or pricing data”. Here’s a link to the official Federal Register notice setting forth the various revisions. You should review it carefully. Here are some of the points that we noticed—


  • A new definition of “certified cost or pricing data” has been added, to emphasize the need to submit a Certificate of Current Cost or Pricing Data.

  • The current definition of “cost or pricing data” has been “refined” to emphasize that it encompasses “all the facts that can be reasonably expected to contribute to the soundness of estimates of future costs and to the validity of determinations of costs already incurred.”

  • The phrase “information other than cost or pricing data” (which covers information submitted by offerors that are not cost or pricing data) has been renamed “data other than certified cost or pricing data”.


The new definition of “data other than certified cost or pricing data” includes the following—


… pricing data, cost data, and judgmental information necessary for the contracting officer to determine a fair and reasonable price or to determine cost realism. Such data may include the identical types of data as certified cost or pricing data, consistent with Table 15–2 of 15.408, but without the certification. The data may also include, for example, sales data and any information reasonably required to explain the offeror’s estimating process, including, but not limited to—


(1) The judgmental factors applied and the mathematical or other methods used in the estimate, including those used in projecting from known data; and

(2) The nature and amount of any contingencies included in the proposed price.


For comparison purposes, we show the revised FAR 15.4 below—


15.402 Pricing policy.


Contracting officers shall—


(a) Purchase supplies and services from responsible sources at fair and reasonable prices. In establishing the reasonableness of the offered prices, the contracting officer—


(1) Shall obtain certified cost or pricing data when required by 15.403–4, along with data other than certified cost or pricing data as necessary to establish a fair and reasonable price; or


(2) When certified cost or pricing data are not required by 15.403–4, obtain data other than certified cost or pricing data as necessary to establish a fair and reasonable price, generally using the following order of preference in determining the type of data required:


(i) No additional data from the offeror, if the price is based on adequate price competition, except as provided by 15.403–3(b).


(ii) Data other than certified cost or pricing data such as—


(A) Data related to prices (e.g., established catalog or market prices, sales to non-governmental and governmental entities), relying first on data available within the Government; second, on data obtained from sources other than the offeror; and, if necessary, on data obtained from the offeror. When obtaining data from the offeror is necessary, unless an exception under

15.403–1(b)(1) or (2) applies, such data submitted by the offeror shall include, at a minimum, appropriate data on the prices at which the same or similar items have been sold previously, adequate for evaluating the reasonableness of the price.


(B) Cost data to the extent necessary for the contracting officer to determine a fair and reasonable price.


(3) Obtain the type and quantity of data necessary to establish a fair and reasonable price, but not more data than is necessary. Requesting unnecessary data can lead to increased proposal preparation costs, generally extend acquisition lead time, and consume additional contractor and Government resources. Use techniques such as, but not limited to, price analysis, cost analysis, and/or cost realism analysis to establish a fair and reasonable price. If a fair and reasonable price cannot be established by the contracting officer from the analyses of the data obtained or submitted to date, the contracting officer shall require the submission of additional data sufficient for the contracting officer to support the determination of the fair and reasonable price.


We notice that the prohibition on obtaining cost or pricing data when certain conditions (e.g., adequate competition) are found has been de-emphasized in favor of a more detailed discussion of the types of data the contracting officer should obtain. This appears to represent a return to a pre-Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act (FASA) pricing environment, which may add to contractors’ proposal costs— meaning that, ultimately, the Government may end up paying more for the goods and services it, acquires.


There is quite a bit to absorb in the new rule(s). Some of the language seems favorable. Although we don’t necessarily like the revised emphasis on obtaining cost or pricing data (certified or not), we believe contractors should be able to navigate through the rocks and shoals, if they take the time to understand the revised requirements.


 

Informal Information Exchange or Espionage? Contractor Employee to Find Out Soon

E-mail Print PDF


The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) release on Friday, August 27, 2010, wasted no words in announcing that a Washington, D.C., federal grand jury had indicted Stephen Jin-Woo Kim for “unlawfully disclosing national defense information to a reporter for a national news organization and making false statements to the FBI.” According to the DOJ press release, Kim (age 43) “was an employee of a federal contractor who was on detail to the State Department” at the time of the alleged crimes.


The DOJ provided the following details of the alleged crimes—


Kim knowingly and willfully disclosed information contained in an intelligence report classified Top Secret/Sensitive Compartmented Information (TS/SCI) to a reporter for a national news organization who was not entitled to receive it. The classified information related to the national defense, specifically, intelligence sources and methods and intelligence concerning the military capabilities and preparedness of a particular foreign nation.



… in September 2009, Kim made false statements to the FBI when he denied having had any contact with the reporter for a national news organization since meeting the reporter in March 2009, when in fact, Kim had had repeated contact with the reporter in the months following that meeting.


The Washington Post had a few more details, in this article. The Post article noted that Kim was “a senior adviser for intelligence on detail to the State Department’s arms control compliance bureau.” The Post reported that the “national news organization” to which Kim allegedly disclosed the classified information was Fox News, and noted that in June, 2009, Fox News reporter James Rosen reported that “U.S. intelligence officials had warned that North Korea planned to respond to a new round of U.N. sanctions with another nuclear test. Rosen reported that the CIA warning was developed through sources inside North Korea.”


The foregoing is not good. The DOJ press release stated what most everybody already knew—i.e., “The willful disclosure of classified information to those not entitled to it is a serious crime.” It noted that, “If convicted, [Kim] faces up to 10 years in prison for the unlawful disclosure of national defense information and up to five years in prison for the making of false statements.”


Kim’s attorneys are already spinning his defense. The Post article reported that the attorneys “faulted the government with criminalizing exchanges ‘that happen hundreds of times a day in Washington.’" According to Kim’s attorneys—



“In its obsession to clamp down on perfectly appropriate conversations between government employees and the press, the Obama Administration has forgotten that wise foreign policy must be founded on a two-way conversation between government and the public."


Um, how about “no”?


We’re not talking about policy; we’re talking about Top Secret SCI stuff here. Before anybody gets briefed into the compartment, they are told, in crystal clear language, just what unauthorized disclosure of such information would mean to the country—and to them personally.


The Post article also noted that Mr. Kim is not the first person to be charged with unauthorized disclosure of sensitive or classified information in recent months. The Post article stated—


Since December, prosecutors have indicted Thomas A. Drake, a National Security Agency official, with improperly handling classified information with a Baltimore Sun reporter; secured a guilty plea from Shamai Kedem Leibowitz, a former FBI contract linguist, for leaking documents to a blogger; and arrested Army Pfc. Bradley E. Manning, 22, suspected of giving a classified video of a U.S. military helicopter firing at civilians in Baghdad to the WikiLeaks.org site. Manning is also suspected of leaking 76,000 classified documents about the Afghanistan war that WikiLeaks posted this month.


The Post article didn’t mention the case of Dongfan “Greg” Chung, who was sentenced to 15 years in federal prison in February, 2010, for “six counts of economic espionage and acting as an unregistered foreign agent of the People’s Republic of China (PRC), for whom the engineer stole Boeing trade secrets related to several aerospace programs, including the Space Shuttle.” We reported that story here. Chung, a naturalized U.S. citizen, held a Secret clearance and, according to reports, spent the years between 1979 and 2003 working for both U.S. defense contractors (as an employee) and the People’s Republic of China (as a spy).


Nice.


We have no sympathy for such people, whether they have cute code names such as “The Falcon and The Snowman” or more mundane names, such as “Greg”.





 


Page 226 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.