Updates to Previous Stories: GTSI Suspension Lifted, Camera Guy Sentenced and Chinese Cut Rare Earth Metal Exports
We
are bloggers, not journalists. And what’s more, we blog about things
that your average Joe Six-Pack wouldn’t waste 30 seconds (the length of
the average TV commercial) reading. That said, we also like to catch up
on previous stories. Thus: the UPDATE prefix. Here are updates to three
previous blog articles.
We reported on the suspension of GTSI Corporation here.
GTSI was suspended because (in the words of the GSA), “… the evidence
shows that GTSI was an active participant in a scheme that resulted in
contracts set-aside for small businesses being awarded to ineligible
contractors and with contracts not being performed in accordance with
applicable law, regulations and contract terms.” Since GTSI derived
roughly three-quarters of its total revenue from sales to the Federal
government, this was (shall we say?) a kind of a big deal to the
company.
About
three weeks later, GTSI’s suspension was lifted. What did the company
agree to in order to get the “death sentence” lifted? This article
at WashingtonTechnology.com listed some of the terms of the agreement
between GTSI and the Small Business Administration (SBA). It reported—
-
Over the next three years, the SBA will have access to the company’s books, records, and other documents.
-
An
independent monitor will be appointed. The monitor will have “full
access to inspect the company on an ongoing basis and report to SBA
without interference from GTSI.”
In addition, the article reported—
… the
agreement requires GTSI to give the monitor management-style office
space and it must pay, among other things, all monitor fees, retainers
and other reimbursements, including any legal fees….
Inside the company, GTSI must name an employee as ethics officer and adopt a code of ethics
The
agreement demands other high-profile moves. More specifically, it
forces out GTSI’s CEO Scott Friedlander and general counsel Charles
DeLeon. It also suspends three top company employees: Tom Kennedy, vice
president of civilian sales and general manager; Scott Schmader, senior
sales manager; and Patrick Berg, program manager, until the agreement
ends.
So
the company’s CEO and general counsel have been terminated. Certain
other executives have been “suspended” for three years (with pay). But
that’s not all. The article noted that, “the SBA inspector general’s
office will continue to probe SBA’s charges against GTSI for using
small-business prime contractors as a front to funnel work and revenue
back to itself.” In addition, “the government still reserves the right
to extend the scope of the case if it comes across any additional
revealing facts.” Moreover, “the agreement would remain in effect even
if GTSI were to file for bankruptcy.” Which would have been a strong
possibility, had the suspension continued for much longer.
A follow-up article by FederalTimes.com, link here, discussed the dire straits facing GTSI. It reported—
Even
though GTSI believed that it was abiding by small-business procurement
rules, the suspension was costing almost $2 million a day, [former CEO
Scott Friedlander] said in an Oct. 21 interview. By the second week,
alarm over the possible repercussions had spread from the firm's work
force to its banks and corporate partners, he said.
‘We
had to lift it [the suspension] to save the company or the company
would have gone into financial ruin,’ he said, throwing some 530 people
out of work. ‘I just think leaders have to lead and I had to do what I
had to do.’ SBA officials never gave the company a chance to make its
case, Friedlander said.
Next let’s talk about “Camera Guy”. We previously reported the sad case of John Feeney, Sr., here.
Dubbed “Camera Guy” by one of our regular readers, Mr. Feeney pleaded
guilty one count of mail fraud for using his position with BAE Systems
Training Services to order nearly $500,000 worth of camera lenses and
video equipment on the company’s tab, and then sold the gear on the
internet “for a profit”. (Well, yes. Since his cost was zero any funds
he got would be a profit. We are cost accountants. We can do that kind
of math.)
Mr.
Feeney is going to jail. He must have had a good attorney, because he
was sentenced to serve a paltry 18 months in prison, according to this
Department of Justice press release. In addition to serving his time, the DOJ release also reports that Feeney “was
also ordered … to pay restitution of $464,819 to the Department of
Defense and $11,604 to BAE Systems Training Services Inc. (BAE). In
addition … Feeney [will] serve three years of supervised release
following his prison term.”
Our
final vignette in this trilogy concerns a more abstract problem, that
of the dependence of the United States on China as the near sole
supplier for rare earth metals. We reported this situation here,
noting that an April 2010 GAO report was “rather alarming.” Even though
the United States has rare earth ore deposits that it could mine and
process, between 1985 and 2005, the U.S. essentially exited the rare
earth production process, ceding the market in its entirety to China. As
we said at the time—
We
don’t want to be overly alarmist here—but this is a potentially very
serious problem that could affect a number of major defense acquisition
programs, from the DDG-51’s Hybrid Electric Drive Ship Program to the
M1A2 Abrams Tank’s reference and navigation system. We encourage DOD’s
Industrial Policy Directorate to get moving on this potential supply
chain ‘interruption’.
An October 20, 2010, article by Bloomberg.com reported
that, “Rare-earth prices have jumped as Chinese export quotas crimped
worldwide supplies for the elements used in the manufacture of disk
drives, wind turbines and smart bombs.” The article reported—
Prices
have climbed sevenfold in the last six months for cerium oxide, which
is used for polishing semiconductors, and other elements have more than
doubled, according to Metal-Pages Ltd. in London, which tracks
rare-earth prices. … China reduced its second-half export quota for the
minerals by 72 percent in July. It is now further restricting exports,
according to industry participants.
Contributing to the rise in prices is an expectation of further restrictions.
‘It’s
pretty frightening that there may be a gap where U.S. industry pays an
extraordinary price,’ U.S. Representative Mike Coffman, a Colorado
Republican, said in an interview. He said U.S. rare-earth mining isn’t
likely to resume until at least late 2012 at a mine in Mountain Pass,
California. …
Companies
and government officials have already begun to react to the threat of a
shortage of the elements. The U.S. rare-earth mine in Mountain Pass,
California, shut down most operations in 2002. Molycorp, Inc., which
owns the mine, plans to reopen it, and [its CEO] said this week that it
may double the planned capacity to 40,000 metric tons. Glencore
International AG, the world’s biggest commodities trader, also said this
week that it would try to restart the Pea Ridge rare-earth mine in
Missouri. …
In
Germany, the government yesterday adopted a strategy to secure supply
of raw materials including rare earths. Chancellor Angela Merkel said
last week that it’s “urgently necessary” to boost European investment in
eastern Europe and Central Asia to counter expanding Chinese interest
in rare minerals.
We don’t have any witty conclusion to this collection of updates. As always, stay tuned for further developments.
Oh My God—It’s Full of Fraud!

Our headline for today comes from the last words uttered by Astronaut Dave Bowman’s in the movie, 2001: A Space Odyssey—as
reinterpreted for this occasion. What causes this particular bout of
Internet hyperbole? Well, it’s like this, folks. We have two more
stories about fraud in the public procurement process to talk about
today.
We recently wrote
about four separate fraud/corruption enforcement actions undertaken by
the Department of Justice, all of which were reported within one
two-week span of time. We opined, “With the constant stream of news
stories like these, it’s no wonder government auditors and law
enforcement officials think so many people (and contractors) are
crooks.”
And
this is not the first time we’ve muttered (or yelled, if you will)
similar sentiments. A site wordsearch on “fraud” yields more than a
score of articles on fraud, corruption, bribery, and outright theft
within the public procurement process. In this article,
published in February, 2010, we asked whether such wrongdoing was
simply “business as usual” in the government contracting environment. In
that article, we noted, “… these three stories, coming essentially on
top of one another, and put in context of other articles we’ve posted
recently … should remind readers that there is enough wrongdoing to
justify all the many auditors and law enforcement officials we encounter
in this highly regulated industry.”
What does today’s menu of wrongdoing contain? What’s the corruption du jour, if you will? As a famous poet once wrote:
Oh, do not ask, “What is it?”
Let us go and make our visit.
The
first item on our menu is the case of Richard Harrington, age 38, of
Jacksonville, North Carolina—a former Major in the United States Marine
Corps., and former Contracting Officer’s Representative It is said that
there is no such thing as a former Marine, but we bet that the Corps. wouldn’t mind it if Major Harrington stopped calling himself one. Here’s the link
to his tawdry tale of accepting bribes from contractors while stationed
in Iraq. According to the article, “Harrington requested and received
Rolex watches, a Persian rug and $35,000 in cash from contractors while
working on a project for new gym equipment.” The article reported—
Harrington
was stationed at Camp Fallujah, Iraq … serving as a contracting officer
representative. Tasked with inspecting and accepting work from
contractors and monitoring their compliance, he wrongfully solicited and
accepted gifts from a contractor while working on a $2.2 million gym
equipment contract with Al Jazaer Group….
Before
an official trip to Dubai, United Arab Emirates, in November 2005 to
conduct market research, Harrington told a corporate representative for
Al Jazaer that he wanted two Rolex watches. The company would deliver
the watches, valued at more than $5,000 apiece, to Harrington while he
was in Dubai.
During
the trip, Harrington was also unofficially accompanied by a
representative from AVA International Corporation who paid for most of
his expenses, including transportation and hotel, and the gift of a
Persian rug. In spite of this, Harrington submitted expense reports for
more than $10,000 following the trip, and was reimbursed in full by the
U.S. Government.
Harrington
would later receive additional watches from Al Jazaer and other
contractors. Shortly after Al Jazaer received its final payment on the
contract, Harrington received the $35,000 he had requested from the
company.
When
he returned to Jacksonville in Dec. 2005, Harrington took the watches
with him and shipped the $35,000 home in a trunk. He declared neither on
customs forms. He would use the money to buy a car, pay off a car loan
and purchase another Rolex watch.
… Al
Jazaer enlisted Harrington’s help after his return home in a dispute
over more than 30 shipping containers, valued at $90,000, which were in
the custody of the Marine Corps. Harrington contacted officials in Iraq
and assisted the company in getting the containers back.
Well, that’s a nice way to profit from one’s military career, is it not? What else might we have to report on?
Our
second story concerns, among other things, a counterfeit “Jesus nut”.
What’s a Jesus nut? That’s the part of a helicopter that secures the
main rotor to the rest of the aircraft. If it doesn’t work right, the
rotor stops turning (or separates from the helicopter) and the
helicopter experiences an extreme challenge in maintaining lift. As this
Wikipedia article
notes, “The term may have come from the idea that, if the Jesus pin were
to fail in flight, the helicopter would detach from the rotors and the
only thing left for the crew to do would be to pray to Jesus.” Suffice
to say that counterfeit Jesus nuts that don’t meet MILSPEC requirements
are a very big deal to those folks who have to ride helos for a living.
So what (allegedly) happened? Let’s look at this story,
published by the Register-Guard of Coos Bay, Oregon. The story reports
on a local military contractor—Kustom Products, Inc.—that (allegedly)
“routinely and systematically engaged in a scheme to defraud the United
States by providing nonconforming substitute parts and supplies to the
(Defense Department) … substantially profiting from this practice.” The
story reported—
Two
generations of a longtime family business here are under federal
investigation for allegedly selling thousands of defective, knock-off
parts to the U.S. military — including a critical helicopter part Army
mechanics call “the Jesus Nut” because it secures the main rotor to the
aircraft.
Kustom
Products Inc. and its predecessor companies landed more than $31
million in Defense Department contracts between 2005 and 2009… Company
president Harold Ray Bettencourt, his ex-wife and the couple’s four
adult sons paid themselves nearly $3.7 million between June 2007 and
December 2009 from mark-ups of 22 percent to 3,745 percent on their
military contracts… A Defense Department investigation allegedly turned
up their flawed, look-alike parts as far away as Kuwait.
Search
and seizure warrants unsealed late last month by U.S. District
Magistrate Judge Thomas Coffin in Eugene suggest that the three oldest
Bettencourt brothers — Bo, 29, Nick, 28, and Pete, 23 — used contract
proceeds to build new $400,000 to $500,000 homes on the same street in a
North Bend subdivision overlooking the Pacific Ocean.
Those
homes have been seized for forfeiture to the federal government, along
with the business complex and a $1.2 million home on a Myrtle Creek
ranch still jointly owned by Harold and Kathy Sue Bettencourt despite
their 2009 divorce. Dozens of bank accounts also are under seizure,
along with late-model boats and high-end vehicles including a Lexus, a
Mercedes-Benz and a Hummer.
Property is subject to forfeiture under federal law if it is used in or bought with proceeds of a criminal enterprise. …
‘Fraud
involving space vehicle or aircraft parts in interstate commerce’ is
among the possible charges... Penalties for that crime range up to 15
years in prison and $500,000 in fines if a fraudulent part was installed
on an aircraft.
Investigators
are also probing allegations that KPI provided ‘false records and
documents to disguise their scheme’ when the Defense Department tried to
trace the ‘nonconforming parts’… [They] alleged that owners and
employees of KPI and a sister company, Southern Oregon Sterling Parts
and Service Inc., ‘routinely and systematically engaged in a scheme to
defraud the United States by providing nonconforming substitute parts
and supplies to the (Defense Department) … substantially profiting from
this practice.’ And Bo Bettencourt told investigators that KPI’s
survival depended on providing knock-off parts ‘like everyone else’ in
the defense contracting business …
[Allegedly]
KPI and Sterling won contracts using a Pentagon computer program known
as PACE, which automatically awards contracts of $25,000 or less based
solely on the lowest bid submitted. The Bettencourts were low-balling
their competition … then sending photos of the authentic parts to a
Texas company they hired to ‘reverse engineer’ replicas. They got caught
when military mechanics found some of the parts defective — including a
locking nut that secures the main rotor to the mast of Kiowa
helicopters… Mechanics with the Kentucky Army National Guard discovered
defects in eight of the nuts as they attempted to install them on
helicopters in August 2008… The flaws prompted them to send out an
Army-wide warning… ‘This part is manufactured wrong. It has a flat
surface where it goes into the latch instead of a radius,’ the mechanics
reported, adding: ‘Keep these nuts from being installed on aircraft,
safety of flight issue.’ … The affidavit does not allege — and The
Register-Guard could find no evidence — that the defective parts caused a
helicopter crash.
When
Defense Department investigators traced the defective nuts to KPI and
Sterling, the Coos Bay firms acknowledged that they were not the parts
required under the contract ... But they blamed the discrepancy on the
nuts being placed in the wrong bin, rather than admitting they had
ordered them from an unauthorized manufacturer. That manufacturer, Coloc
Manufacturing of Canton, Texas, later told investigators that KPI never
revealed that the parts ‘were to be used on a military helicopter’s
main rotor assembly.’ …
Despite
the Defense Department probe, KPI [allegedly] continued to order …
‘nonconforming’ parts from Coloc. The … company simply asked the Texas
firm to re-engineer the knockoff parts to more closely resemble the
authorized parts specified in the contracts…
When
the Defense Department began scrutinizing other KPI and Sterling
military contracts, it found 83 different product deficiency reports
against the Coos Bay company ... The defective parts reportedly included
generators, alternators, filters and safety relief valves for light
armored vehicles, medium tactical vehicles and Humvees. [According to
the investigators] ‘In most cases, the parts were ‘critical application’
items essential to operating personnel.’
That
grinding sound you hear right now is not a failing Jesus nut; it is the
sound of our teeth. As always, defendants are innocent until proven
guilty in a court of law. (We heard that on a recent Law & Order
episode.) However, if these allegations are proven true, then we wish
this family a long visit to a Federal prison.
Perhaps they should have thought before putting lives in jeopardy. Perhaps they should have asked themselves this question. It might have helped.
|
Fraud, Fraud, Everywhere is Fraud

(With apologies to the Five Man Electrical Band)
This article
in the Journal of Accountancy explores why people commit fraud.
According to the article, a 1980’s-era study found that “an astonishing one-third
of employees actually had stolen money or merchandise on the job.” The
article asserts that the “fraud triangle” is composed of three factors:
Pressure, Rationalization, and Opportunity. One theory is that the more
dissatisfied the employee, the more likely he or she is to engage in
criminal behavior. Another theory is that when personal financial
pressure meets an opportunity to commit and conceal a crime, and the
offense(s) can be rationalized as something other than criminal
activity—then fraud, corruption, and other criminal activity occurs.
According to the article—
The lesson in these stories is that fraud does not occur in isolation. All crime is a combination of motive and opportunity. The
opportunity to commit fraud is typically addressed through internal
controls—if the proper checks and balances exist, it is more difficult
(though still not impossible) to defraud an organization. …
The
body of research into why “good” employees turn to fraud can be
distilled into at least two important concepts. Employees and executives
who feel unfairly treated sometimes believe they can right the scales
by committing occupational fraud and abuse. Workplace conditions are
therefore a major risk factor in predicting fraud. Also, employees faced
with embarrassing financial difficulties pose a significant problem.
The simple moral to the auditor is to pay attention to what goes on outside the
books, too. So while you’re looking at the numbers, keep one eye and
both ears open for disgruntled or financially strapped employees. It may
mean all the difference in detecting fraud.
Frequent
readers of this site may have noticed a penchant to report on stories
of fraud, bribery, false statements, theft of government property, and
other corrupt actions within the public procurement process. Although it
is “conventional wisdom” that many government contractors are crooks, a
perusal of articles on this site shows that there are as many corrupt
government employees as there are corrupt government contractors. If one
believes the now thirty year-old study referenced in the above article,
then perhaps as many as one-third of government employees might be
corruptible—especially when opportunity and rationalization meets
personal financial pressure.
The
foregoing is simply prologue to yet more stories of corruption. **
Sigh. ** Here are three stories that recently came our way.
First, here’s a Washington Post story
about John Alfy Salama Markus, also known as John Salama. Markus, who
was allegedly “a soldier in Iraq” where he was awarded a Purple Heart
and Bronze Star, before becoming a project engineer for the U.S. Army
Corps. of Engineers (USACE). According to the article—
Markus
faces charges of conspiracy to defraud the United States and money
laundering. The money laundering count carries a 20-year maximum prison
sentence. … The complaint alleges Markus took bribes from Nouri in
exchange for providing confidential information to [Ahmed] Nouri's
company, Iraqi Consultants & Construction Bureau, about bidding
negotiations on certain projects.
Markus
also allegedly steered Army Corps of Engineers projects to Nouri,
including a $6.25 million project to enhance security at the Bayji Oil
Refinery in central Iraq for which Markus allegedly received at least
$200,000 in bribes.
Citing
Army Corps of Engineers records, the complaint alleges four more
contracts were awarded to ICCB in the summer of 2007 totaling
approximately $6.3 million. For those projects, Markus allegedly sought
$550,000 in bribes.
The
[complaint] alleges Markus deposited the bribes in bank accounts in the
Middle East and in the U.S. and used the money to build a $1.1 million
house for himself and his wife in Nazareth, Pa. They had previously
lived in Belle Mead, N.J.
Second,
let’s talk about property control. Control of Government Property is
important, and so is control of company-owned inventory and material.
Theft of Government property is a fairly serious issue and we’ve
reported before on people who thought they were merely stealing
company-owned inventory—only to realize that the stuff they took
actually belonged to Uncle Sam. Sadly, we have another similar story to
share today. Here’s a Department of Justice press release
that announces a guilty plea by Annapolis resident Levon Smith, an
employee of AAI Corporation (a Government contractor). Mr. Smith pleaded
guilty to “theft of government property in
connection with a scheme to steal and sell over $340,000 worth of copper
cables and other government property used in foreign military
operations.” According to the press release—
… from
March 2008 to November 2009, Smith was a Senior Material Control
Analyst at AAI Corporation, located in Hunt Valley, Maryland. AAI
provides innovative aerospace and defense technologies, including
unmanned aircraft to the U.S. government and other entities. …
The
U.S. government purchased remote vehicle terminal cables and copper
cables for AAI to install in U.S. property, including unmanned aerial
vehicles (drones) used in foreign military operations. The United States
government stored these drone cables at AAI buildings in Hunt Valley.
On more than 40 occasions from June 2008 to October 2009, Smith removed
cables and other U.S. property from the AAI buildings, including
replacement parts for the drones operated by the U.S. military.
Smith
took the stolen cables and property to a recycling company located in
Rosedale, Maryland, presented an expired Arizona driver’s license and
sold the stolen materials at scrap metal prices. Smith stole
approximately $340,000 worth of government materials and received
approximately $22,000 from the recycling company.
Think
that’s a petty issue? Well, if you’re expecting to build a UAV but you
don’t have the materials you need, that’s a problem—not only for the
company but also for the warfighters who need their UAVs in the field.
For our finale, though, we have an even more mundane issue. Here’s
a Department of Justice press release that discusses false claims
associated with postage. You might think that it would be tough to rack
up of any serious dollar issues about postage, but you’d be wrong.
According to the DOJ—
California-based
companies Quicksort Inc., Quicksort LA Inc. and Quicksort Sacramento
Inc. have agreed to pay the United States $4.2 million to settle
allegations that Quicksort violated the False Claims Act by falsely
representing the level to which it had pre-sorted mailings in order to
obtain discounted postage rates from the U.S. Postal Service. … The U.S.
Postal Service offers lower postage rates to mailers who automate and
sort their mail by zip code because these steps save the Postal Service
time and money. Mailers use the services of businesses such as Quicksort
that combine the mail of many customers and pre-sort it in order to
qualify for the pre-sort discounts. After processing customers' mail,
these pre-sort businesses present the mail to the Postal Service for
mailing.
We
started off by inquiring why people commit fraud and other corrupt
actions. We reported that opportunity to commit and the ability to
rationalize the action(s) need to be present. We noted job
dissatisfaction and difficult working conditions as red flags—as was
personal financial pressure. As you read over the three stories
above—discussing common bribery, theft of property, and misreporting of
data to obtain a financial advantage—we recommend you think about what
conditions might have been present and whether there were any red flags
(or other signs) that might have alerted leadership to the wrongdoing. Naturally, we
don’t have all the facts and can only speculate, but we believe the
thought experiment to be worth performing.
Next,
consider your own business or working environment. What red flags do
you see around you? What signs point toward a possible confluence of motive and opportunity? And, more importantly, what are you going to do about them?
UPDATE: The Army’s NextGen Ground Combat Vehicle

When last we posted
on the Army’s multi-billion dollar GCV program, we noted that the
solicitation had been cancelled. The Army reported that it intended to
issue a new Request for Proposals (RFP) within 60 days, but that
contract award might be delayed for up to six months—leaving the three competing teams in limbo.
It
should not be forgotten that the three teams undoubtedly spent
significant funds preparing their first bids, funds that will be
recovered through each contractor’s G&A expense allocation to
existing DOD contracts. As the Pentagon continues to focus on driving
affordability into its programs, somebody in a leadership position might
want to consider how much it costs the taxpayers for such failed
competitions. (Should we even mention the USAF’s KC-X Aerial Tanker
program?)
Anyway,
the teams will need to submit new proposals in response to the Army’s
changing requirements. In the first go-round, the Army reportedly
“overreached” with respect to technology integration. As we reported, “A
disconnect emerged between what the Army required in its RFP and what
the service expected to get….” A Pentagon review concluded that the
program plan was simply too risky to proceed.
We
quoted a GCV program spokesperson as saying, “The new RFP will reflect
changes to the program’s efforts to minimize technology integration risk
and to ensure that we have a viable acquisition strategy to deliver the
vehicle within seven years of the contract award….”
So
as the 60 days come to an end, we were interested to see how the Army
was revamping its approach. One answer was provided during an October 1, 2010 “industry day” in which “Army
officials explained their vision of the GCV program and gave industry
insight into what they can expect with the release of the request for
proposal that will kick off the development of the new vehicle.” Nearly
300 attendees listened to the Army briefings. Various sources carried
articles about the industry day, but we are going with this one from the Fort Leavenworth Lamp.
According
to the article, the Army still intends to issue its RFP very soon. More
details regarding the Army’s requirements emerged during the industry
day. The article reported—
Michael
N. Smith, director of the Army Maneuver Center of Excellence, said the
Army emphasized the importance of the infantry fighting vehicle to
potential GCV contractors during the industry day. ‘The requirement is
that we need an infantry fighting vehicle that can deliver a squad to
the battlefield, in an improvised-explosive-device environment —
realistically in an environment of anywhere along the continuum of
operations under Army,’ Smith said.
Smith
also said the Army already has ‘solutions’ that can operate in an IED
environment, but that those cannot operate across the full spectrum of
operations the Army may be called on to operate in. ‘So GCV ... as a
platform, is designed to allow us to address ... that spectrum of
operations, spectrum of conflict, while moving that squad to where it
needs to be,’ Smith said.
He
went on to say that Army leadership developed four imperatives for the
GCV, and emphasized those to industry representatives. Those include
capacity, force protection, full-spectrum operations and timing. Four
imperatives, he said, which are ‘non-negotiables’ with regard to GCV
development.
Capacity,
he said, means ‘a requirement to deliver the entire infantry squad on a
single platform.’ The force-protection requirement is separate from
vehicle survivability, he said, but rather is about ensuring safety for
Soldiers. …
‘Full-spectrum
operations’ means the vehicle must be able to perform missions that
include both offensive and defensive operations, as well as stability
operations. ‘From an operational perspective, (that) means I have to
have modular and scalable capabilities,’ he said. Smith added that the
vehicle must include ‘a whole suite of things to allow me to adapt the
platform to accomplish the mission in a wide variety of environments and
terrain sets.’
Timing, Smith said, means ensuring the vehicle is developed in time to ensure the end product is still valid for the mission. …
Cost is another significant element in GCV development and will play a key role in the RFP when it is released.
‘Our
intent for this RFP is to give them a target range and to use that as
part of assessing their proposals and making a determination — among
other factors, certainly — who ultimately will be selected,’ DiMarco
said. The colonel said a specific price range for manufacture would be
specified in the RFP, though he was unable to say what that range would
be.
Well,
there you go. The Army’s NextGen Ground Combat Vehicle must operate in a
“full-spectrum” threat environment, must be able to carry an entire
infantry squad and safely deliver that squad into whatever threat
environment is out there, and it has to be developed, tested, and
fielded ASAP. Oh—and by the way—it has to be cheap. In other words, it
has to do everything, meet an ambitious schedule, and meet aggressive
cost targets.
Let
us ask you, gentle readers—exactly what about the Army’s new strategy
is new or different, or even feasible? The Army wants everything and it
wants it now and it wants it to be affordable. Yes, that is clearly the
low-risk approach. (Note: Sarcasm.)
We are not alone in criticizing the Army’s revised same-‘ol-same-‘ol approach. Here’s an editorial from the American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research. It says—
The
‘back to the future’ direction in which the service is headed will be
expensive, controversial and expose what is perhaps the Army's most
chronic weakness: the inability to talk about combat basics in a plain
and coherent way. … The stakes on the Ground Combat Vehicle could not be
higher and go well past the issue of the vehicle itself. The Army's
approach to its future is best characterized as a return to land-combat
basics, a reconsideration of essential truths--and, in particular,
truths about the fog of war and the need for adequate manpower as well
as firepower in land combat--that will also prove very inconvenient. In
particular, in a time of austerity, they will prove especially
unsettling to those with an eye on the Pentagon's bottom line. …
Army
leaders have convinced one another many times before that their plan
for modernization was on target. Given the service's recent procurement
history, the Pentagon, Capitol Hill and other Washington audiences will
be skeptical. The program will also be a legacy of the Future Combat
Systems in the sense that it will capture a number of the FCS successes,
such as the network capabilities. It will also push technology in a
number of areas. For example, whether it has a hybrid electric or diesel
power plant, it's likely to be something on the order of 1500
horsepower; that is, as mighty as the turbine that drives the Abrams' 70
tons.
The
GCV will also be a big and heavy vehicle, whether one measures by the
‘deployment’ weight of about 50 tons or with the add-on armor that might
add another 20 tons. One design proposal received very cold water in
response from the COINdinistas who frequent the Small Wars Journal
website: ‘Dang! It looks like a middle-aged Bradley with a huge beer
belly and other baggage, not to mention the triple chins!’ was one of
the milder takes.
It
has been said by experienced former senior Government acquisition
officials that writing a proposal in response to inadequate Government
requirements is nothing more than an exercise in creative writing—an
exercise in writing fiction. We expect that RFPs that contain these
types of requirements will generate unparalleled new heights in such
creative fiction writing.
But
we sincerely doubt it will get the Army’s soldiers a better GCV any
faster, or that it will get the taxpayers a more affordable program.
This is not the way to do it, United States Army.
|