• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

Misallocation or False Claim? Let’s Ask The Louis Berger Group!

E-mail Print PDF

In most commercial companies, cost accountants toil in relative obscurity. They use terms such as “indirect costs” and “S,G&A”—and their primary purpose seems to be to help management determine the true costs of production so as to support strategic decision-making. These cost accountants are not known for their charisma and, as a result, they work in the relative darkness of the “back office”—away from the spotlights of the executive offices. When management needs some information, they send an e-mail. Otherwise, cost accountants have only their Excel worksheets to keep them company.

However, the average work environment of government contract cost accountants makes the dim obscurity of their commercial kin seem like it’s illuminated by the flashbulbs of Hollywood paparazzi. The governmental cost accounting folks speak in an obscure, poorly-understood dialect only vaguely related to “normal” GAAP accounting, using arcane terms such as “allocability,” “homogeneity,” “directly associated unallowable costs,” and “beneficial or causal relationship”. Sometimes they refer to their Nineteen Commandments, which they call “Cost Accounting Standards” (aka “CAS”). At those times they talk about “disclosed or established cost accounting practices” and something called “consistency”. And they refer to their Bible (the CASB Disclosure Statement) as if it holds the answer to every question management (or government auditors) might possibly ask of them. They are tolerated (barely) because they do some (not well understood) things that, at the end of the day, create “indirect cost rates” or “booking and/or billing rates” that are used to generate invoices and to collect payments from Government customers. If not for their vaguely perceived utility, they obviously wouldn’t be invited to management decision-making meetings, ever.

But sometimes … sometimes those hard-working, low-profile government contract cost accountants can have a huge impact on the bottom-line. Today’s story is one of those times.

The Louis Berger Group, Inc. is “an internationally recognized consulting firm that provides engineering, architecture, program and construction management, environmental planning and science, and economic development services.” LBG is “one of 10 firms that make us the Berger Group Holdings.” Founded in 1953, the company now employs 5,000 and supports clients in diverse markets—including the Federal Government. In that latter capacity, LBG—

… supports more than 30 U.S. federal clients, including agencies within the Departments of State, Transportation, Defense, the Interior, Homeland Security, Energy, and Commerce, as well as the intelligence community. We are a prime contractor on dozens of federal indefinite quantity contracts (IQCs) and hold General Services Administration (GSA) schedules to provide management organizational and business improvement services (MOBIS), environmental advisory services, and professional engineering services (PES).

LBG’s projects include several “reconstruction & recovery” efforts in Southwest Asia, including Afghanistan and Iraq. For example, LBG supported the U.S. Corps. of Engineers at Al Asad Air Base in Al-Anbar, Iraq, by “providing and maintaining 155 megawatts of emergency power to control facilities critical to military operations in Iraq.” And the company has many similar projects for the US Government as well. Though details are sketchy because the company is privately owned, LBG reported that 2009 sales were $694 million.

LBG also reported on November 5, 2010, that it had reached a “global settlement” with the U.S. Department of Justice “related to an investigation of its cost allocating methodologies in place until 2008 for overseas U.S. federal contracts, as well as the misconduct of former employees.” As part of the settlement agreement, LBG will pay the U.S. Government $65 million (although other reports, including that of the DOJ, state the payments will total $69 million).

The company reported the following—

In 2006, prior to the company’s knowledge of the U.S. government’s investigation, LBG initiated its investigation into its accounting procedures. When the company identified issues with its allocations to the federal government for projects overseas, it began refunding the government in addition to implementing a companywide internal improvement program. In 2008, as a result of the investigation, LBG accelerated its reform program, to implement a series of improvements in policies, accounting procedures, internal controls, training and compliance oversight. In addition to hiring a new chief financial officer and controller, LBG has instituted a sweeping ethics and compliance training program for all of its employees, which will be monitored and updated by the company’s expanded compliance department. Additionally, individuals who were involved with this matter have been separated from the company.

According to this article, LBG was accused of filing false claims and overbilling its Government customers though manipulating its indirect cost allocations and thus inflating the resulting indirect cost rates used for government bidding and billing purposes. The article reported—

The former chief financial officer of LBG, Salvatore Pepe, and an ex-controller, Precy Pellettieri, pleaded guilty today in federal court in Newark to conspiring to defraud the United States. They admitted inflating bills to the U.S. government for the firm’s general overhead costs, including rent, legal bills and other expenses. Pepe also said he conspired with another company executive, whom he did not name.

Under the terms of their deal with prosecutors, Pelletieri, 54 … and Pepe, 58 … face between 30 and 37 months in prison.

N.J. company will pay $69M to U.S. government for over-billing in Iraq, Afghanistan contracts

How did LBG get to the point where it agreed to pay Uncle Sam $69 million? According to the article, a qui tam “whistleblower” was involved. The article reported—

Prosecutors began investigating the firm in 2006, when a former employee gave the government evidence against the company, according to McClatchy News Service. That employee, Harold Salomon, was a senior financial analyst and auditor for Louis Berger.

‘Today I can affirm to those who told me the Louis Berger Group can get away with anything that they were wrong,’ Salomon said. ‘To those who said, ‘If you cannot beat them, you have to join them,’ I say they were wrong, too.’

To wrap-up, we want to visit the website of The Huffington Post, where David Isenberg had a few things to say about the scandal. Here’s a link to his editorial/rant. Here are some selected bits from his piece—

Louis Berger's alleged overbilling, a practice that dates to at least the mid-1990s, swelled to tens of millions in lost tax dollars. In 2006, a former Louis Berger employee handed the government evidence against the company, two months before the U.S. Agency for International Development tapped Louis Berger to jointly oversee $1.4 billion in reconstruction contracts in Afghanistan.

 

Court documents reveal that the Justice Department has been negotiating a deal that would "aid in preserving the company's continuing eligibility to participate" in federal contracting in Afghanistan and elsewhere.

According to McClatchy Louis Berger is accused of manipulating overhead cost data and overhead rate proposals submitted to the U.S. government and several states including Massachusetts, Nevada and Virginia.

In some instances the company is accused of shifting overhead costs from private clients to federal and state contracts, where they were less likely to be noticed. …

 

While it is great the U.S. government has investigated and fined the Berger group it is important to note that this came about because of a whistleblower lawsuit under the False Claims Act and not because of the superb auditing capabilities of the feds.

That’s a great way to end this story – let’s all ask why DCAA didn’t catch the improper cost allocations, and why it took a qui tam “relator” to start the wheels of justice rolling. It is because DCAA can’t perform quality audits (as the GAO has alleged)? Or maybe because the agency lacks adequate resources (as its former Director testified)? Or perhaps the agency is so focused on battlefield audits in Southwest Asia it has de-prioritized audits in CONUS?

Obviously, we don’t have the answer(s). But we hope somebody with authority is trying to find them.

In the meantime, let’s give a shout-out to the underappreciated, over-worked government contract cost accountant, who works long hours to allocate allowable costs, to calculate indirect cost rates, and to support government audits. Ignore his (or her) warnings at your own peril, at The Louis Berger Group learned, to its chagrin.

 

Old Dogs and New Tricks: Government Employees Commit Fraud—And Worse!

E-mail Print PDF

File these two stories under dumb and dumber. What were they thinking?

First, let’s talk about Tyrone Ellis, age 56, of Columbus, Georgia. Tyrone was a “former civilian employee of the Department of Defense” who was assigned to Camp Humphreys in the Republic of Korea (RoK) during 2005 and 2006. While there, Tyrone worked as “an Assistant Army Emergency Relief Officer,” where he administered Army Emergency Relief (AER) funds.

What are AER funds? According to the DOJ press release—

The AER is a private, non-profit organization that serves as the emergency financial assistance organization for the U.S. Army. AER’s operations are financed by voluntary contributions from active and retired soldiers during an annual fund campaign, as well as by unsolicited contributions, repayment of outstanding loans and income from reserve funds.

In his role as Assistant AER Officer, “Ellis was tasked with providing AER loans and grants to service members and their families in financial need.” But according to the indictment, Tyrone apparently felt some financial need himself. The indictment alleged that Tyrone—

… approved grants for at least a dozen soldiers in amounts larger than they needed, and that he requested and received thousands of dollars back from the grant recipients, which he converted to his own use. The indictment also alleges that Ellis conspired with another individual to convert AER funds in the same manner. In addition, Ellis is charged with making false statements to investigators when questioned about the allegations.

Tyrone was arrested and charged with “one count of conspiracy, 10 counts of conversion and one count of making a false statement.” The press release noted that, if convicted, Tyrone will be looking at some serious penalties. It stated—

Ellis faces up to five years in prison on the conspiracy charge; 10 years in prison for each felony count of conversion; one year in prison for the misdemeanor charges of conversion; and five years in prison on the charge of making a false statement. He also faces a $250,000 fine for each count of conspiracy, felony conversation and making a false statement. He faces a $100,000 fine on the misdemeanor charges of conversion, as well as terms of supervised release following his prison term on all charged counts.

Not that he’ll do all that time, but we calculate he’s facing 111 years in prison. But remember, he allegedly took for himself funds contributed by active and retired soldiers, and designated for soldiers with dire need. So we hope he spends quite a bit of time in confinement, if convicted.

You think that was bad? You ain’t seen nothing yet.

Next on the hit parade is the story of three unwise men: Richard Paul, Andrew Kaufman, and Nicholas Bickle. Nick Bickle is (for a bit longer) a U.S. Navy SEAL, an “active-duty special warfare operator 1st class”. In a somewhat unrelated note, SEAL Bickle apparently “worked as a consultant on the Hollywood movie, ‘Transformers 3’.” (Should that have been considered a red flag for aberrant SEAL behavior?)

According to this Associated Press story, the trio was arrested on November 3, 2010, and accused of conspiracy to “smuggle and sell weapons”. And not just any weapons, mind you. As the article reported—

Bickle is accused in a criminal complaint of smuggling 80 AK-47 weapons from Iraq or Afghanistan, including factory-made 7.62 mm Iraqi machine guns that would be difficult or impossible to trace. Other weapons included Ruger handguns of the type used by U.S. military police officers.

Oh, but that’s not all. Not by a long-shot.

The AP story noted that, “grenades and night-vision goggles” were also found in the home of Mr. Paul. But that’s not all. The AP story reported that—

Smith said outside court that federal agents expected to find weapons, but were surprised to find five pounds of C-4 plastic explosive, blasting cap detonators and other military items at Paul's home in Colorado.

Okay, let’s repeat that last part. FIVE POUNDS OF C-4 and the means to detonate it. As the article noted the BATF representative “declined to elaborate about the destructive power of the explosives”. Yes, of course.

The AP article concluded—

Smith said Bickle, his close friend, Paul, in Colorado, and their associate Kaufman in Nevada sold machine guns for $1,300 to $2,400 each, and handguns for $300 to an undercover federal agent who told them they would be shipped to Mexico.

The complaint accuses the trio of conspiring to smuggle and sell 18 weapons and 14 other firearms since June to an undercover federal agent in Las Vegas and Colorado. The single conspiracy charge carries a possible sentence of up to five years in prison and a $250,000 fine.

The prosecutor said the group could have reaped hundreds of thousands of dollars selling arms over the last year.

Smith told Foley that prosecutors expect to seek an indictment in Las Vegas on charges including distribution of explosive materials, arms smuggling and illegal firearms dealing. He said the explosives charge carries a possible sentence of 20 years in federal prison.

Okay, so what have we learned here?

First, we’ve posted many articles about misdeeds of employees of the Federal government. We’ve written (and ranted) about theft of funds and theft of fuel, about bribes and corruption and conflicts of interest. The first story falls into that category, albeit in a special place called “especially heinous”.

But as far as we can tell, this is the first article dealing with outright theft of military grade firearms, explosives and other equipment. While we’ve mentioned lax internal controls in the warzone(s) before, this one kind of takes the cake, doesn’t it? How the heck does five pounds of C-4 simply go missing?

So these are kind of new tricks (hence the title). Dumb-guy No. 1 (allegedly) created a nice little scheme, taking advantage of needy soldiers and their families. As a result, some of the donated funds ended-up lining his pocket. Dumb-guy(s) Nos. 2 through 4 (allegedly) executed the first part of their scheme nicely, carting away lots of battlefield souvenirs and getting them into the States. But they (allegedly) made the mistake of selling the souvenirs to the wrong people and, as a result, ended up in jail awaiting trial.

We’re glad these miscreants got caught. But we can’t help wishing better controls had been in place to keep the (allegedly) corrupt actions from happening in the first place.

 

Russia Gains New Satellite Launch Capability from Boeing

E-mail Print PDF

Sea Launch

In 1995, Sea Launch was created. According to this Wikipedia article, Sea Launch “is a spacecraft launch service that uses a mobile sea platform for equatorial launches of commercial payloads on specialized Zenit 3SL rockets.” The article explains, “The sea-based launch system means the rockets can be fired from the optimum position on Earth's surface, considerably increasing payload capacity and reducing launch costs compared to land-based systems.”

Originally, Sea Launch was a consortium comprised of Energia Overseas Ltd., a subsidiary of the Russian aerospace “giant” Energia (25% ownership), a Boeing subsidiary (40% ownership), Norwegian company Aker ASA (20% stake) and Ukraine’s SDO Yuzhnoye/PO Yuzhmash (15% ownership). Boeing managed the consortium. Since 1999, Sea Launch has had 27 of 30 successful satellite launches. But the financial seas of the commercial satellite launch business were rough and the consortium ran into problems. As one report explained—

One of the chief uncertainties before Sea Launch's mid-2009 filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection was the Ukrainian Zenit rocket supply chain. According to court filings, the global financial crisis, a catastrophic launch mishap in 2007, and late equipment deliveries and cash payments triggered several serious delays.

In June, 2009, the company announced it was filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. In July 2010, Energia subsidiary Energia Overseas Limited (EOL) acquired a controlling 85% ownership stake in Sea Launch by a bankruptcy court ruling. The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) cleared the new ownership on September 8, 2010.

Effective October 27, 2010, Sea Launch emerged from Chapter 11 reorganization “debt-free” and “under majority Russian ownership”—according to this article at SpaceFlightNow.com. The company plans to resume satellite launches in 2011. The reorganized company will have more Russian involvement. For example, “an Energia affiliate in Moscow will oversee the supply chain in Russia and Ukraine,” and “Energia Logistics Ltd., a U.S. corporation, is taking over management of rocket and satellite operations in Long Beach.” Moreover, land launches “are managed by Space International Services Ltd. of Moscow.”

In prior articles, we noted that Russia was “resurgent” and playing a larger role on the world’s aerospace and defense stage. Although its bid to build the next generation USAF aerial tanker was lost through a series of missteps, Russian management of Sea Launch indicates that it is a player, and should be taken seriously.

 

Aviation Week Editorial Calls for “More Rigor” in Defense Audits

E-mail Print PDF

The October 18, 2010, edition of Aviation Week & Space Technology magazine carried an unsigned editorial entitled, “Put More Rigor Into Defense Audits”. Look, it’s one thing when POGO or a similar gadfly watchdog organization complains about lack of contract oversight. It’s an entirely different thing when the leading aerospace/defense industry magazine calls for the same thing. It means that things are getting serious.

The AW&ST editorial started out with a bang, saying “Lost in the debate about U.S. defense spending … is the glaring fact that no one knows precisely where the money is being spent or even how much is being spent.” The editorial explains the root cause for this lack of knowledge: “One reason such calculations involve so much guesswork is because defense audits—whether for the whole department or one program—are often incomplete, error-laden or biased.” [Emphasis added.] Amen brother!

The editorial explores the well-known (to our readership, at least) criticisms of DCAA by “congressional auditors” and Senator Claire McCaskill. The editorial explains—

Congressional aides and auditors say changes are being made, but … doubts remain about the government’s own agencies that monitor program management. Just recently, the Congressional Research Service renewed a warning about Navy accounting in pursuing its 30-year, 313-ship plan. The Navy estimates the plan will require an average of $15.9 billion per year in today’s dollars to implement, but the Congressional Budget Office—which has a better track record—says it is more like $19 billion per year. How can two sets of professionals using accepted accounting principles be off by a whopping 19%?

But DCAA and the Navy are not the only targets of AW&ST’s wrath. The magazine also had some choice words for Lockheed Martin and its EVM System. Readers may recall our previous article, which discussed the Government’s disapproval of LockMart’s EVM System. The AW&ST editorial asserted that the decertification of LockMart’s EVM System is “the latest example of insufficient discipline” and rigor. The editorial asked, “When contractors cannot even implement the tool correctly, is it any wonder that so many lawmakers, lobbyists and others believe they can challenge the Pentagon’s programmatic decisions?”

As the editorial noted, by decertifying the F-35’s EVM System, “In a nutshell, the Pentagon is publicly questioning the internal cost and schedule management at its largest contractor in managing its largest program … as well as its own seriousness in responding to government oversight.”

The AW&ST editorial concluded—

It would be easy to chide the Defense Department and its contractors to get their numbers straight. Such calls have been issued for years. The Lockheed EVM rebuke, however, is concrete evidence of officials holding contractors accountable for shared work. Lockheed should take it seriously and get its house in order. Moreover, the Pentagon should not hesitate to call other contractors into question publicly when it finds hazy or lax management controls elsewhere.

One recurring theme on this website is the call for corporate leadership to invest in appropriate internal controls and internal oversight, to get its own house in order before DCAA and/or DCMA level criticisms, and before the Department of Justice demands serious cash for criminal wrongdoing by “rogue” employees. It’s one thing to read rants at this site. It’s one thing to read rants at POGO. But it’s quite another thing entirely to read near-rants from Aviation Week & Space Technology, calling-out one of its largest advertisers, and demanding enhanced oversight and public branding of miscreants.

We’ve been warning you for years. Here’s another warning, courtesy of Aviation Week & Space Technology magazine. How many times do you have to read the same rants from different sources before you start to take them seriously?

 

Text Messaging is a Contract Compliance Issue

E-mail Print PDF


 

We recently spent six enlightening hours listening to Washington, D.C., attorney Stephen Knight, of the firm Smith/Pachter/McWhorter PLC, discuss recent regulatory changes that might affect government contractors. Some of what he discussed was already familiar to us, and we’ve published articles on those topics on this website. But there were new things to learn as well (as one might expect from such an accomplished legal practitioner), and we want to share one of them with you today. It’s about the contract compliance issue(s) associated with text messaging while driving.

Now, we confess that when this interim rule was issued in late September 2010, we didn’t take much notice. After all, California and other states already prohibit such unsafe practices. So what’s the big deal? Well, Stephen explained the big deal and we’re going to try to explain it to you.

Federal Acquisition Circular 2005-46, published September 29, 2010, contained several proposed and final FAR revisions. Amongst those revisions was FAR Case 2009-028, issued as an interim rule. As the FAR Councils explained, “This interim rule [implements] Executive Order 13513, issued on October 1, 2009 … entitled “Federal Leadership on Reducing Text Messaging While Driving.” The interim rule revised FAR Part 23 and implemented a new subpart at 23.11 (“Encouraging Contractor Policies to Ban Text Messaging While Driving”).

Helpfully, the new rule provides definitions for challenging concepts, such as the term “driving” and the term “text messaging”. You may be relieved to note that the definition of “text messaging” “does not include glancing at or listening to a navigational device that is secured in a commercially designed holder affixed to the vehicle”. However, that exception only covers the situation when “the destination and route are programmed into the device either before driving or while stopped in a location off the roadway where it is safe and legal to park”. Otherwise, you are (apparently) not permitted to listen to your navigation device—nor are you (apparently) permitted to use your smart phone as such a device, unless it is “secured in a commercially designed holder affixed to the vehicle”. Okay, we could go on but you get the point—this is a bit of a bureaucratic joke.

What’s not funny is the new contract clause (52.223-18) that came along with the new rule. It states—

(c) The Contractor should--

(1) Adopt and enforce policies that ban text messaging while driving--

(i) Company-owned or -rented vehicles or Government-owned vehicles; or

(ii) Privately-owned vehicles when on official Government business or when performing any work for or on behalf of the Government.

(2) Conduct initiatives in a manner commensurate with the size of the business, such as--

(i) Establishment of new rules and programs or re-evaluation of existing programs to prohibit text messaging while driving; and

(ii) Education, awareness, and other outreach to employees about the safety risks associated with texting while driving.

Moreover, the contract clause is a mandatory flow-down for “all subcontracts that exceed the micro-purchase threshold”.

Need we point out that, in order to comply with the new contract clause, your company may well have to develop new policies and procedures to “prohibit” the undesirable behavior, and will need to educate employees about the new policies and procedures? And you are going to have to perform some level of due diligence on your subcontractors to make sure they are complying with the new rules.

The foregoing really is no laughing matter. In this environment of cost-consciousness, you’re going to have to modify existing HR or ES&H policies and conduct even more employee training.

So now you know.


 



 



 


Page 219 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.