• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Apogee Consulting Inc

Oracle Settles Sun Microsystems’ GSA SNAFU for $46 Million

E-mail Print PDF

On January 31, 2010, the U.S. Department of Justice announced that Oracle America had agreed to pay $46 million in order to settle a False Claims Act lawsuit filed against Sun Microsystems (whom Oracle acquired in 2010), related to Sun’s federal contracts, including its contracts with the General Services Administration (GSA).

As the DOJ reported in its announcement—

This settlement resolves allegations under the False Claims Act (FCA) and Anti-Kickback Act that Sun knowingly paid kickbacks to systems integrator companies in return for recommendations that federal agencies purchase Sun’s products. Sun executed agreements with consulting companies that provided for the payment of fees each time the companies influenced a government agency to purchase a Sun product. These kickback allegations are part of a larger, ongoing investigation of government technology vendors that has resulted in settlements to date with six other companies.

We’ve previously reported on this series of lawsuits. See, for example, this article or maybe this one. We’ve even ranted about commercial high-tech companies and their apparent propensity to be accused of fraudulent activities in connection with their government contacts (e.g., right here). So this latest settlement is not really a news flash to us.

The DOJ also noted that—

The settlement also resolves claims under the FCA that Sun’s 1997 and 1999 GSA Schedule contracts were defectively priced because Sun provided incomplete and inaccurate information to GSA contracting officers during contract negotiations, as well as claims that the incomplete and inaccurate information resulted in defective pricing of Sun’s contract with the U.S. Postal Service and GSA Schedule contracts held by two resellers of Sun products. At the time Sun entered into its contracts with GSA to sell information technology products and services to federal agencies, applicable regulations and contract provisions required Sun to fully and accurately disclose to GSA how it conducted business in the commercial marketplace so that GSA could use that information to negotiate a fair price for government customers using the GSA contracts to purchase Sun products and services. The defective pricing information that Sun disclosed to GSA was subsequently relied on by the Postal Service in negotiating a contract with Sun, as well as by GSA in negotiating contracts with two resellers of Sun products.


We wonder whether Oracle was aware of these cases when it acquired Sun Microsystems, and whether its “due diligence” properly valued these contingent liabilities. Of course, $46 million is just a small blip on Larry Ellison’s massive radar screen of revenue but, nonetheless, it’s got to sting a little.

 

DCAA in Senate Crosshairs (Again)

E-mail Print PDF

It’s déjà vu all over again as the Senate Committee on Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs (HSGA) and its “ad hoc Subcommittee on Contracting Oversight” held a hearing on February 1, 2011 entitled, “Improving Federal Contract Auditing.”

Chaired by long-time DCAA critic Claire McCaskill (D-MO), the hearing—

… examined how federal agencies use contract audits to detect and prevent waste, fraud, and abuse in government contracts. In particular, the hearing reviewed the findings of the Subcommittee’s ongoing investigation of the type and number of contract audits at federal agencies. The hearing also examined the role played by the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA) in performing contract audits for agencies other than the Defense Department.

Not expressed in the foregoing description was the notion that DCAA may have outlived its usefulness and should be folded into a new, organizationally independent, Federal Contract Audit Agency. As we shall see, opinions on that notion were divided.

Obviously, DCAA would be represented at the hearing by its Director, Patrick Fitzgerald. In fact, Mr. Fitzgerald received an invitation to the hearing two weeks in advance, from Senators McCaskill and Scott Brown (Ranking Minority Member). In addition to Mr. Fitzgerald, other Federal government employees providing testimony included:

  • Thomas Skelly, Acting CFO, U.S. Department of Education

  • Ingrid Kolb, Director, Office of Management, Office of Deputy Secretary, U.S. Department of Energy

  • Brian Miller, Inspector General, U.S. General Services Administration

  • Jeanette Franzel, Managing Director, Financial Management and Assistance, U.S. Government Accountability Office

You can find the written testimony of the above-named individuals at the HSGA Subcommittee website, along with 110 minutes of archived video goodness. But we don’t want to discuss the testimony of those folks. We want to discuss Mr. Fitzgerald’s written testimony, along with the written testimony of Sandy Hoe and Nick Schwellenbach. Sandy Hoe is a partner with the very respected law firm of McKenna, Long & Aldridge (and testified on behalf of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce) while Mr. Schwellenbach testified on behalf of the Project on Government Oversight (POGO).

Mr. Fitzgerald’s testimony can be found here.

Sandy Hoe’s testimony can be found here.

Mr. Schwellenbach’s testimony can be found here.

Looking at Mr. Fitzgerald’s written testimony, we can see the usual fact-based information regarding his audit agency. Nothing new there. Next, Mr. Fitzgerald discussed DCAA’s “reimbursable work” for non-DOD agencies. He noted that, historically, the percentage of DCAA’s audit effort devoted to such activities ranged from 9 to 13 percent of its total workload. To clarify, that means that, at any given time, roughly 10 percent of DCAA’s resources are devoted to auditing non-Defense contracts. Of that effort, about one-third is for NASA contracts and another 20 percent is for the Department of Energy. Mr. Fitzgerald testified that DCAA charges the civilian agencies a rate of $113.84 per hour for its auditors’ time.

We were struck the following statement by Mr. Fitzgerald—

During the past year, DCAA has developed a risk-based approach to performing contract audits. This approach has allowed DCAA to focus on the highest-risk areas with the biggest payback to the U.S. taxpayer. DCAA uses this risk-based approach when performing reimbursable audit effort. In general, this has meant DCAA has expended more resources in the forward pricing area (audits of contractor proposals) at the expense of resources devoted to the incurred cost area.

As expected, Mr. Fitzgerald defended the terrible drop in recent audit productivity by focusing on audit “quality” and compliance with Generally Accepted Government Auditing Standards (GAGAS), saying, “The additional audit procedures ensure the acquisition community is getting the best possible product.” We trust our readership sees through that thin rationale. If not, there are plenty of articles on this website that will paint a different picture and posit different reasons for the growing backlog of uncompleted contract audits.

Mr. Fitzgerald’s written testimony also discussed recommendations to strengthen civilian contract audits. He advocated expanding the pending DFARS business systems rule to all Federal government agencies, and expanding DCAA’s current DCMA contracting officer dispute resolution process to civilian agencies. He also advocated applying DCAA’s recent change in proposal audit thresholds to civilian agencies. Each of these areas has been discussed on this website, and (of course) we had an opinion on the desirability of such initiatives. Suffice to say, we opined that room for improvement existed.

Also as expected, Mr. Fitzgerald defended the status quo, and asserted that there was no need to create a new Federal Contract Audit Agency.

Next Sandy Hoe testified about contractor concerns with recent encroachments by DCAA and the Inspector General into contracting officer authority, noting that such authority conflicts with both Federal regulations and case law. He testified that—

The FAR mandates that the corporate administrative contracting officer (“CACO”) is unilaterally responsible for determining a contractor’s proposal and billing rates, and for determining whether to accept an FPRA as being in the government’s interest, or, alternatively, to issue an FPRR. Decisional authority has further established that DCAA’s role is to be advisory, and that the contracting officer may exercise discretion in deciding whether to follow DCAA audit recommendations. ELS Inc., B-283236, et al., 99-2 CPD ¶ 92, 1999 WL 993094 (Oct. 25, 1999); see also OAO Corp., B-228599.2, July 13, 1988, 88-2 CPD ¶ 42, at 6 (“DCAA audits are only advisory; the degree to which they are used is a matter for the contracting officer to decide”). This balance of authority is appropriate, given the contracting officer’s authority to administer contracts and “make related determinations and findings,” FAR § 1.602-1; § 2.101, as well as the contracting officer’s “wide latitude to exercise business judgment” in requesting and considering the advice of audit specialists. FAR § 1.602-2.

The January 4 DPAP memorandum indicates that contracting officers will apparently now issue final rates as determined by DCAA without the contractor having the opportunity to demonstrate to the Administrative Contracting Officer (“ACO”) why such rates may be unreasonable. Unless the contractor elects to contest the rates by submitting a claim under the Contract Disputes Act (“CDA”), it will, at a minimum, lose the ability to recoup the lost amounts allocated to fixed price contracts based upon the DCAA-determined rates. This approach would be unfair to contractors and directly conflict with established regulatory law.

Sandy also criticized DCAA, testifying that—

Some in industry have noted a sharp upturn in DCAA’s reluctance to engage in rational discussion of audit issues since 2008 and 2009 about the same time when the Congress and the GAO demanded improvements to DCAA. While DCAA took many specific and warranted actions in response to the criticism, a less tangible response has been for DCAA to take a no risk approach to addressing audit issues.

The FAR cost principles and other cost and price compliance regulations are relatively explicit, but still cannot and do not cover every circumstance that may arise. Judgment often is necessary in applying the regulations to resolve issues. Unfortunately, since 2008/2009, DCAA seems to have lost its appetite for analysis of the intent of a regulation versus its literal application. Once it has applied the literal language, DCAA seems little moved by any argument that the result reached is nonsensical or that it could not have been what the drafters intended. This has confounded some in the contractor community who believe that the goal of the regulations, and of government contracting generally, is to reach rational results. Combining DCAA’s recent stridency with the enhanced authority it is being given for FFPA’s and FFPR’s produces a potentially toxic mix for contractors.

(We note for the record that we’ve made many of those same points on this website—but never with such felicitous language.)

Finally, POGO’s Nick Schwellenbach advocated doing away with DCAA and, instead, implementing the Federal Contract Audit Agency that Mr. Fitzgerald asserted was unnecessary. He testified—

We need a contract audit agency that is not afraid of its own shadow. We need an independent and muscular audit agency that protects the taxpayers’ interests. … There are other possible benefits to pulling DCAA out from the DoD and transforming it into an FCAA, the most significant being the independence issue. Currently the DCAA reports to the DoD Comptroller, who is the Chief Financial Officer of DoD, and who in turn reports to the Deputy Secretary of Defense. We have grave reservations whether this structure ensures adequate independence for DCAA, particularly as DCAA’s work often establishes issues with how DOD works with contractors.

Furthermore, it is apparent to us that the DCAA Office of General Counsel is not independent—its attorneys are evaluated by the Pentagon’s Defense Legal Services Agency. It should therefore come as no surprise that some of these attorneys are responsible for the gag letter sent to one of the DCAA whistleblowers. A similar independence problem previously existed with the

Pentagon Inspector General (IG) and in 2008 the IG Reform Act gave the Pentagon IG its own independent general counsel and severed its tie to the Defense Legal Services Agency.

Mr. Schwellenbach also criticized DCAA, as well as the defense contractors that he asserted had taken advantage of the “current turmoil” at the audit agency. He testified—

As Congress weighs the pros and cons of an FCAA, we need to improve DCAA as much as possible. We are concerned about the current direction of DCAA. I have to mention that many current and former DCAA employees and knowledgeable observers believe that companies have taken advantage of the current turmoil at DCAA. In addition, you only have to read the hundreds of comments posted on the Government Executive website by people claiming to work at DCAA to understand that there is at least some part of the DCAA workforce that is deeply angry with the direction of their agency. Many, if not most, of the comments hammer home the belief that the agency has become risk-averse. Of course, contractors want DCAA to be risk-averse, and afraid to issue reports. Congress must make sure that does not happen. Unfortunately, despite its many good auditors and cases where it defended the taxpayers’ interests, there have been signs that the agency is not reaching its full potential. For instance, DCAA has not issued a subpoena to a contractor in over two decades despite long-standing access to records problems they have faced from contractors. That, by definition, is risk aversion and contractors know this.

I believe the subcommittee needs to learn more about why, in FY 2010, far more assignments were canceled at DCAA than were completed, according to records POGO has obtained through the Freedom of Information Act. This is the first time this has happened for at least the past five years, and possibly ever. …

We are concerned by the general decline in contract dollars audited and reviewed by DCAA. In particular, there has been a massive decline in the number of Truth In Negotiations Act assignments conducted by DCAA: in FY 2006 they conducted 468, in FY 2007 438, in FY 2008 348, in FY 2009 148, and in FY 2010 only 59.

[Emphasis added.]

Well, we agree with Mr. Schwellenbach that DCAA is headed in the wrong direction, has become risk averse, and recently has experienced a startling drop in productivity. We agree that many DCAA auditors are embarrassed—and even angry—with the continued leadership failures and bizarre audit guidance issued by DCAA HQ in the past couple of years.

We were startled to see in his testimony an assertion of something we have long suspected—that the number of DCAA’s cancelled audits has grown substantially and potentially represents a huge example of governmental waste. (See the italicized portion of the testimony, above.) We have issues with Mr. Schwellenbach’s credibility (see our comments below). But if true, it is an amazing statistic that DCAA cancelled more audits that it completed in its FY 2010. Along with our previous work showing the huge drop in completed audit reports, it paints the picture of an audit agency in death throes.

Here is Mr. Schwellenbach’s footnote supporting his assertion—

DCAA in FY2010 canceled assignments (including assignments with ‘no report issued’) far more often than it completed assignments with reports: 16,298 assignments were canceled or ‘no report issued’ versus 11,788 assignments with reports issued in FY2010, according to assignment data in the DCAA Management Information System provided by DCAA through FOIA to POGO. From FY2006 through FY2009, DCAA finished more assignments with reports issued than assignments that were canceled/no report issued, in most of those years it issued far more. For example, in FY2006, DCAA canceled (or had ‘no report issued’) 16,690 assignments and completed 26,698 assignments where reports were issued.

Overall, there has been a massive decline in the number of DCAA reports issued. According to the database, it has gone from 26,698 assignments with reports issued in FY 2006 to 11,788 in FY 2010 with a drop every single year, but especially large decreases in FY 2009 and FY 2010.

Wow. Go back and read that again. And remember, this is the Federal government’s premier audit agency, the one all the others look to as a role model for how to conduct contract audits.

Getting back to Mr. Schwellenbach’s testimony, we emphatically do not agree with him that contractors want this sad situation and are taking advantage of it. We do not agree that there are “long-standing” access to records “problems;” nor do we agree that DCAA is not aggressively addressing contractor delays in responding to audit requests. We don’t know from what remote ivory tower Mr. Schwellenbach is viewing the current DOD contract audit environment, but from the viewpoint of people on the ground, dealing with DCAA audits and DCMA contracting officers every single day, we can say with a very high degree of certainty that he is flat-out wrong.

Contractors don’t want inaccurate audit reports, nor do they want unconscionable delays in performing audits, nor do they want ridiculous delays in publishing audit reports after completion of field work. They want the same thing everybody in the defense (and civilian) acquisition community wants. They want high-quality contract audits, performed and issued timely—so that everybody can get back to the business of supporting the nation’s national security and other objectives.

 

Legal News

E-mail Print PDF

The logical outcome of a compliance failure—either actual or alleged—is a legal proceeding, normally followed by a settlement of some kind or another. Today’s article focuses on such topics.

A-12 Program Termination Legal Proceedings Enter Second Decade of Litigation

The termination for default of the A-12 Avenger stealth attack fighter is a poster child for everything that was wrong with the 1980’s fascination with fixed-price development contracting. As the USA Today recently reported—

The Navy contracted in 1988 with General Dynamics and McDonnell Douglas Corp. (now Boeing) to develop the A-12, but after delays and conflicts over costs, terminated the contract for default in 1991 and sought return of more than $1 billion paid. The defense giants brought their own claim, arguing they were stalled by the government's reluctance to turn over secret technology needed for the project.

The case is currently before the Supreme Court of the United States. What makes the current round of litigation interesting is that the U.S. Government invoked its “state secrets” argument, which essentially takes the position that certain information cannot be disclosed in court because doing so would harm national security. Consequently, companies suing the Federal government are denied access to otherwise discoverable evidence, cannot meet their burdens of proof, and see their cases dismissed.

As USA Today reported—

General Dynamics and Boeing say that while there are times the state-secrets privilege is legitimately invoked, in this case it was used for a litigation advantage … the companies contended that by raising the state-secrets privilege and limiting access to documents, the government prevented them from proving they were not responsible for delays and should not have to repay the money. Lower courts ruled for the government.

Army Contracting Officer Sentenced

In November 2010, we told you about the former Army Contracting Officer, Major Roderick Sanchez, who pleaded guilty to accepting more than $200,000 in bribes in return for steering Army contracts to (unnamed) foreign companies. On January 19, 2011, the U.S. Department of Justice announced that Sanchez had been sentenced to 60 months in prison, forfeiture of his ill-gotten goods, and payment of a $15,000 fine.

Former Northrop Grumman Engineer Sentenced to 32 Years

The DOJ issued a press release telling us that Noshir Gowadia (age 66) had been sentenced to 32 years in prison “for communicating classified national defense information to the People’s Republic of China (PRC), illegally exporting military technical data, as well as money laundering, filing false tax returns and other offenses.”

According to the DOJ—

On Aug. 9, 2010, following six days of deliberation after a trial spanning nearly four months in Honolulu, a federal jury found Gowadia guilty of five criminal offenses relating to his design for the PRC of a low-signature cruise missile exhaust system capable of rendering a PRC cruise missile resistant to detection by infrared missiles.

The jury also convicted Gowadia in three counts of illegally communicating classified information regarding lock-on range for infrared missiles against the U.S. B-2 bomber to persons not authorized to receive such information. The B-2 bomber is one of America’s most critical defense assets, capable of utilizing its stealth characteristics to penetrate enemy airspace and deliver precision guided weapons on multiple targets. Gowadia was also convicted of unlawfully exporting classified information about the B-2, illegally retaining information related to U.S. national defense at his home, money laundering and filing false tax returns for the years 2001 and 2002. … ‘Mr. Gowadia went beyond disclosing information to China, he performed defense work in that nation with the purpose of assisting them in their stealth weapons design programs.’

Contractor Employee Sentenced for Bribery

We have posted our thoughts on Camp Arifjan (Kuwait) before. On January 25, 2011, the DOJ announced that Dorothy Ellis (age 53) had been sentenced to 37 months in prison for “participating in a conspiracy to pay $360,000 in bribes to U.S. Army contracting officials stationed at a U.S. military base in Kuwait.” As the DOJ reported—

The case against Ellis arose from a corruption probe focusing on Camp Arifjan, a U.S. military base in Kuwait.  As a result of this investigation, 16 individuals, including Ellis, have been charged, of which 14 have pleaded guilty.  These individuals include Ellis’s former boss and military contractor, Terry Hall, and several U.S. Army contracting officials, including former Army Majors James Momon and Christopher Murray. … Ellis admitted that she participated in the bribery scheme by providing Momon and Murray access to secret bank accounts established on their behalf in the Philippines to enable Hall and others to transfer bribe payments to them.  Ellis also admitted that, to further Hall’s unlawful dealings with Momon, she obtained confidential Army contract pricing information from Momon that was designed to give Hall an unlawful advantage in the bidding process for an ice contract from the DoD.

We could have added another story, about Raytheon’s latest foray before Judge Firestone in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims. But we thought, “why sully this great litany of criminal acts with a dreary bit about CAS 413 and segment closing pension adjustments?” We know you’ll thank us for that.

 

“Combat Barbie” Prepares for Afghanistan Deployment

E-mail Print PDF

Well, you don’t see this everyday….

In 2006/2007, “Combat Barbie”—aka Corporal Katrina Hodge, then age 18—served a seven month deployment in Iraq as part of Britain’s Royal Anglian Regiment (1st Battalion), one of only ten women in the Regiment. Cpl. Hodge has served in Britain’s armed forces since she left school at age 16. The UK’s Daily Mail related a part of her military service history—

While she and comrades from her unit … were taking a suspected rebel fighter back to base near Basra, their vehicle crashed. When the prisoner grabbed two rifles, Katrina wrestled them from him and restrained him with her bare hands. 'For a moment I thought I was going to die,' she says.

Her commanding officer rewarded her bravery with a commendation to go along with the Iraq Medal she received for her tour of duty, and she was promoted to corporal.

In addition to her military service, Corporal Hodge competed in beauty pageants. In July 2009, she was runner-up in the Miss England contest. Not being crowned the winner, she returned to her barracks and went back to the profession of arms. But a few months later she learned that she had a second chance at the crown, because the winner had been arrested in a Manchester nightclub on suspicion of assault (“She is alleged to have hit fellow beauty queen Sara Jones … during a row over a boyfriend.”) For another take on the incident—

The alleged attack happened during a porn-themed night in the early hours of Monday, where Miss Christie was dressed as an angel, and Miss Jones was dressed as a cavegirl. Miss Christie's spokesman said: ‘She can't go through to Miss World with this hanging over her. She is really devastated by what has been alleged but we are fully supporting her.’

But this is not a story about a porn-themed nightclub party gone bad. This is a story about a soldier who is both brave and beautiful. Back to that story….

Combat_Barbie
After the winner was stripped of her crown, Corporal Hodge was asked to assume the title of Miss England and compete, representing her country, in the Miss Universe pageant that was to be held in Johannesburg, South Africa.

As the Daily Mail reported—

 

'I was in Army mode with no nails when I found out,' she says. 'I don't have any swimsuits or day wear. I'm going to have to run into a shop and grab every size eight dress they have.' … She was offered a modelling contract with lingerie firm La Senza this summer and wants to carry on serving in the Army for the foreseeable future - even if she ends up winning Miss World. 'I am hard-working and will make sure I can commit to the two,' she says. 'I want to break down the boundaries.'

Corporal Hodge did not win the Miss Universe pageant. But that’s not the end of her story, as the Korea Herald reported. As her reign as Miss England came to a close, she married her boyfriend (a fellow soldier) “in a secret ceremony in Sri Lanka.”

 

... she has now handed over her crown and is back on exercise in Army fatigues preparing for a possible tour of war-torn Afghanistan.

 

The married soldier … insisted she was glad to be back in the forces and ready to take on the challenge. ‘At the end of the day, it's my job. If that's what I've got to do, then that's what I've got to do,’ she said. ‘It's hard to be excited about going to Afghanistan but it's the reality of our job. Our job is be out there, protecting our country.’ [Returning to army life] involved a month on exercise and tough training to get her up to speed. ‘I'm not going to lie, it was hard to come back,’ she said.

 

‘It's definitely a change of lifestyle from having your hair and make-up done every day to being in your combats and having your hair scraped back. I was thrown in at the deep end and realised that this was reality.’

We’ve told you before about U.S. Army Master Sergeant (and Ranger) Mark Moran, who served six tours of duty in Southwest Asia, was awarded a Bronze Star, and who was recently named one of the top three pastry chefs in the world. We are aware that U.S. Army General George Patton competed in the 1912 Olympics, where he placed fifth in the fencing competition. We understand that our military services contain many, many outstanding individuals with an amazing range of unexpected skills and competencies. But really, this story kind of rocked our world—in a good way. We simply did not expect beauty queen and decorated soldier in the same package.

Best wishes to Corporal Hodge—“Combat Barbie”—and may she return safely from her next tour of duty to her husband and family.

 

 


 

LockMart Settles with DOJ on Bid Rigging Conspiracy Charges

E-mail Print PDF

On January 24, 2011 the Department of Justice announced that Lockheed Martin had agreed to pay $2 million to resolve allegations related to a 2009 qui tam whistleblower suit filed in Mississippi. The charges are complex and took some untangling. Here’s what we think happened.

In April 2004, the General Services Administration (GSA) awarded a task order to SAIC, which had teamed with LockMart and Applied Enterprise Solutions (AES) to provide support services to the National Center for Critical Information Processing and Storage (NCCIPS) at the Naval Oceanographic Major Shared Resource Center (NAVO MSRC), which was located at the Stennis Space Center in Mississippi. According to the DOJ, SAIC received $115 million under the task order, of which $2 million was paid to LockMart as a subcontractor.

Got all that? Let’s clarify: we are talking about a contract to provide support services at a Naval facility located at a NASA facility … awarded by a civilian agency. Yeah, that’s the kind of government logic that puzzles us as well.

Anyway, the suit alleged that—

… then government employees, Stephen Adamec and Robert Knesel, conspired with Lockheed Martin, Galloway, SAIC and AES to ensure that SAIC and its teaming partners were awarded the task order by (a) sharing non public, advance procurement information with the SAIC team that was not provided to other potential bidders; (b) sharing information about the solicitation with the SAIC team before providing that information to other bidders; and choosing a type of contract and putting language in the solicitation in order to bias the selection process to favor the SAIC team.

(We have no idea who “Galloway” is in the above paragraph, or what his role was.)

The qui tam suit, filed by David Magee (a former employee of NAVO MSRC), alleged that LockMart “caused the submission of false claims and conspired to submit such claims” when it invoiced the GSA for costs incurred on the tainted task order. This is not an uncommon assertion in such circumstances. Essentially, the government’s argument is that the contract was obtained by dishonest or fraudulent conduct, and thus any invoice under that contract is a false claim—subjecting the malefactor to treble damages plus up to $11,000 per invoice submitted.

In our view, that LockMart settled for an amount equal to its total billings (rather than treble damages) speaks to the difficulty of the prosecution’s arguments, and the perceived difficulty in making a jury understand the complexities of the case. In any case, Mr. Magee will receive $560,000 as his share of the government’s recovery. The DOJ did not report how much of that amount will go to Mr. Magee’s attorneys.

 


Page 212 of 279

Newsflash

Effective January 1, 2019, Nick Sanders has been named as Editor of two reference books published by LexisNexis. The first book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Federal Acquisition Regulation. The second book is Matthew Bender’s Accounting for Government Contracts: The Cost Accounting Standards. Nick replaces Darrell Oyer, who has edited those books for many years.